•  50% cheaper
  •  14x safer
  •  Right next door

Self storage units in Middle Island, NY

7 x 7 Closet in Port Jefferson Station, New York near [object Object]

Closet

|

7’ × 7

Port Jefferson Station, New York

5.4 mi

near 1500 RT-112

Private Space

Pet Free

No Stairs

$55/ mo


12 x 8 Shed in Coram, New York near [object Object]

Shed

|

12’ × 8

Coram, New York

3.4 mi

near 16 Cammann Rd

Private Entrance

No Stairs

Locked Area

$86/ mo


15 x 15 Shed in Medford, New York near [object Object]

Shed

|

15’ × 15

Medford, New York

3.8 mi

near 810 Long Island Ave

Private Entrance

No Stairs

Smoke Free

$69

  1st month

$138/ mo


9 x 9 Bedroom in Bayport, New York near [object Object]

Bedroom

2 sizes available

Bayport, New York

9.8 mi

near 1598 Lakeview Ave

Smoke Free

Smoke Detectors

Pet Free


12 x 10 Shed in Patchogue, New York near [object Object]

Shed

|

12’ × 10

Patchogue, New York

8.7 mi

near 73 N Summit Ave

Private Entrance

$46

  1st month

$92/ mo


20 x 10 Garage in East Patchogue, New York near [object Object]

Garage

|

20’ × 10

5.0

East Patchogue, New York

8.7 mi

near 9 Beatrice Ct

Smoke Free

Private Entrance

Pet Free

$119/ mo


10 x 10 Shed in Centereach, New York near [object Object]

2 sizes available

Centereach, New York

6.5 mi

near 33 Ruland Rd

Private Space

No Stairs

Security Camera


20 x 10 Garage in St James, New York near [object Object]

Garage

|

20’ × 10

5.0

St James, New York

13.5 mi

near 440 Nissequogue River Rd

Security Camera

Smoke Detectors

Private Entrance

$110

  1st month

$220/ mo


24 x 11 Attic in Centereach, New York near [object Object]

Attic

|

24’ × 11

Centereach, New York

7.8 mi

near 93 Forest Rd

Smoke Free

Private Entrance

Locked Area

$208/ mo


20 x 20 Garage in Setauket- East Setauket, New York near [object Object]

Garage

|

20’ × 20

Setauket- East Setauket, New York

8.6 mi

near 54 N Belle Mead Rd

Pet Free

No Stairs

Smoke Free

$249/ mo


19 x 19 Garage in Islip, New York near [object Object]

Garage

|

19’ × 19

Islip, New York

17.6 mi

near 25 Bay 3rd St

Security Camera

Pet Free

Locked Area

$75

  1st month

$150/ mo


30 x 15 Garage in Mastic Beach, New York near [object Object]

Garage

|

30’ × 15

Mastic Beach, New York

9.9 mi

near 27 Hampton Rd

Security Camera

Smoke Detectors

Private Entrance

$325/ mo



20 x 10 Garage in Bridgeport, Connecticut near [object Object]

Garage

|

20’ × 10

Bridgeport, Connecticut

23.7 mi

near 59 Post Rd

Smoke Free

Private Entrance

Pet Free

$62.50

  1st month

$125/ mo


16 x 10 Garage in North Babylon, New York near [object Object]

Garage

|

16’ × 10

North Babylon, New York

23.2 mi

near August Rd

Smoke Free

Private Entrance

$49

  1st month

$98/ mo


19 x 13 Basement in Commack, New York near [object Object]

2 sizes available

Commack, New York

17.5 mi

near 19 Cameo Rd

Climate Controlled

Smoke Free

Private Entrance


30 x 10 Garage in Deer Park, New York near [object Object]

Garage

|

30’ × 10

Deer Park, New York

22.8 mi

near August Rd

Smoke Free

No Stairs

Locked Area

$178/ mo


16 x 13 Self Storage Unit in Milford, Connecticut near [object Object]

Self Storage Unit

|

16’ × 13

Milford, Connecticut

23.9 mi

near 45 Howe St

Private Entrance

Security Camera

Locked Area

$179/ mo


20 x 10 Garage in Stratford, Connecticut near [object Object]

Garage

|

20’ × 10

5.0

Stratford, Connecticut

23.8 mi

near 35 Lenox Ave

Private Entrance

Pet Free

Smoke Free

$335/ mo


150 x 50 Basement in Medford, New York near [object Object]

Basement

|

150’ × 50

Medford, New York

2.5 mi

near 115 W Bartlett Rd

Smoke Detectors

Climate Controlled

Pet Free

$910

  1st month

$1,820/ mo


60 x 30 Basement in Yaphank, New York near [object Object]

Basement

|

60’ × 30

Yaphank, New York

3.2 mi

near 275 E Main St

Climate Controlled

Smoke Free

Smoke Detectors

$500/ mo

Show more storage units

Find nearby storage locations

Brookhaven, New York (8 mi)
Patchogue, New York (9 mi)
Lake Grove, New York (9 mi)

How Neighbor compares to traditional storage facilities

badge w/star

Neighbor

Traditional facilities

Wide variety of sizes

Lowest prices

Highest safety rating

Protection plans

Nationwide availability

Verified hosts

Manage rental online

View reviews for Neighbor

Storage for Rent in Middle Island, NY

Select storage type

parking spaces
RV storage
truck parking
car storage

Storage Units in Middle Island, New York: FAQs

On average, it costs $194 a month to rent a storage unit in Middle Island. The larger the storage space, the more you'll pay.

Storing a vehicle? An RV may require a storage unit as large as 10' X 30', while a full-sized car most likely needs a 10' X 20' storage unit. For reference, you'll generally need a 5' X 10' storage unit to fit the contents of a studio or 1-bedroom home. The size storage unit you need depends on what and how many items you're storing as well as the size of your belongings.

Use our handy map view to help you find local storage units near Middle Island, or add your desired location in the search bar for a list of all storage rentals nearby. Chances are you'll discover a self storage space just down the street from your location.

You'll find several features and amenities for your secure self storage unit near Middle Island. Here are some of our most popular features:

  • Flexible Access: Need to access your items at any time of day (or night)? No prob. Rent a storage unit listing on Neighbor that allows flexible access.
  • Drive-Up Access: Usually garages or sheds near driveways, self storage units with drive-up access permit for easy drop-offs or pick-ups of your belongings right from your car.
  • Climate Control: Give your possessions the most protection by choosing a climate-controlled storage unit. Usually, these units have a humidifier or temperature control, or both.
  • Security: Many storage units in Middle Island have security such as a padlock or access code, while some even have security cameras or 24-hour surveillance. We have the best safe self storage.
  • Yes, climate-controlled storage is good to have in Middle Island, as winter and summer humidity levels can get relatively high. It will also be beneficial during these times of year when temperatures can get extreme.

    To prepare items for long-term storage, it's important to clean them properly to prevent damage over time. Use quality storage materials, such as boxes and covers, to ensure that sensitive items are well protected. It may also be wise to invest in moisture absorbers to prevent mold and mildew.

    Alternative Self Storage Facilities near Middle Island

    Middle Island offers many different traditional self storage companies for self storage. Traditional self storage, however, are usually more expensive, less safe, and typically farther way than Neighbor.com.

    Reference the list of self storage facilities for details:

    Extra Space Storage (3.5 miles)

    2025 Route 112 Coram, NY

    U-Haul Moving & Storage of Coram (3.7 miles)

    532 Middle Country Rd Coram, NY

    Public Storage (3.9 miles)

    550 Middle Country Rd Coram, NY

    Public Storage (4.4 miles)

    922 Route 25A Miller Place, NY

    U-Haul Moving & Storage Of Medford (4.6 miles)

    3118 Horseblock Rd Medford, NY

    Need self storage in Middle Island?

    Neighbor is the world’s largest storage marketplace. Call for rates or search online for the cheapest, closest, and safest storage units.