Car storage in Smithtown, NY

Top-rated

Average rating of 4+ stars

Cheapest price

Store your car as low as $72/month

Closest to me

Enter your zip for nearby units

Multiple vehicles

Storage for more than one car

Average rating of 5.0 with 100% of listings reviewed.
67% of listings respond within 12 minutes.
67% of listings are outdoor uncovered spaces.

Unpaved Lot

2 sizes available

5.0

Saint James, NY

1.5 mi

near 10 Glenrich Dr

Private Space

No Stairs

20’ × 10’

$100

1st month

$200/ mo

15’ × 30’

$125

1st month

$250/ mo

20’ × 10’ starting at

$200

Prices start at $72 per month for outdoor, uncovered spaces.
Average price for outdoor spaces is $104; most offer first month discounts.
Driveway spaces are common, averaging $85 and within 2 miles distance.

Driveway

20’ × 10’

5.0

Saint James, NY

1.7 mi

near 40 Hobson Ave

Private Space

$36

1st month

$72/ mo

Parking Lot

20’ × 10’

Smithtown, NY

0.8 mi

near 37 Elliot Pl

Security Camera

Private Space

No Stairs

$39.50

1st month

$79/ mo

Driveway

20’ × 10’

Nesconset, NY

1.5 mi

near 404 Lake Ave S

Private Space

No Stairs

$85/ mo

Average distance of car storage is 1 mile; 67% of listings are within 1 mile.
58% of spaces are Driveways; average response time of 7 hours for these.
50% of listings offer first month discount; prices range from $72 to $250.

Driveway

2 sizes available

Smithtown, NY

0.5 mi

near 65 Maple Ave

20’ × 10’

$45

1st month

$89/ mo

35’ × 10’

$99/ mo

20’ × 10’ starting at

$89

Parking Lot

20’ × 10’

Saint James, NY

1 mi

near 44 Prospect Ave

Locked Area

Private Space

$124/ mo

Driveway

20’ × 10’

Smithtown, NY

1.8 mi

near 65 Maple Ave

Security Camera

Private Space

$85/ mo

Average price is $162; most listings are Driveways and Unpaved Lots.
67% have host response times under 12 minutes; average rating is 0.0.
75% offer outdoor uncovered spaces; 25% offer first month discount.

Public Storage

2 sizes available

72 Southern Blvd Nesconset, NY

0.9 mi

2.4x more expensive

Pros:

Clean facilities and well maintained
Good central location
Provides excellent access to main roads

Cons:

Parking lot a little small
Rental amounts can increase significantly
Issues with incorrect billing and payments
Poor customer service reported on several occasions

10'×15'

starting at

$281/ mo

10'×30'

starting at

$505/ mo

10'×15' starting at

$281

Find nearby storage locations

Islandia, New York (3 mi)

Commack, New York (6 mi)

Brentwood, New York (6 mi)

Selden, New York (7 mi)

North Bay Shore, New York (8 mi)

East Northport, New York (8 mi)

Sayville, New York (9 mi)

Port Jefferson, New York (9 mi)

Islip, New York (9 mi)

Bay Shore, New York (9 mi)

How Neighbor compares to traditional storage facilities

Neighbor

Traditional facilities

Wide variety of sizes

Lowest prices

Highest safety rating

Protection plans

Nationwide availability

Verified hosts

Manage rental online

View reviews for Neighbor

Storage facility cost comparison

	10×20	10×30	10×40
Average storage facility Smithtown, NY	$505	$505	--
Neighbor 100+ storage spaces nearby	$95	$99	$250
Public Storage Nesconset, NY (1 miles)	$505	$505	--

Storage for Rent in Smithtown, NY

Select storage type

What type of vehicle storage is best for you?

Choose whether to store your vehicle using uncovered parking, covered parking, or an indoor storage unit. Each offers their own benefits and downsides.

Uncovered Parking

three cars parked together next to a field

Parking spaces are affordable options at commercial lots & residential properties.

Uncovered storage is more expensive than covered storage by Infinity% on average in Smithtown

Find outdoor parking

Covered Parking

boat on trailer with fabric cover in outdoor covered area

Covered parking provides a roof or partial enclosure around your car.

There are 200% more hosts in Smithtown that are part of our Top Host program than surrounding cities

Find covered parking

Indoor Storage

Shared & private storage includes drive-up storage units, private garages & warehouses.

Indoor storage in Smithtown is 33% cheaper than nearby areas

Find indoor storage

Additional New York car storage locations

9 South Lewis Street, Auburn

377 Ocean Ave, Islip

Carmans Road, Massapequa

145 88 180th Street, Queens

2907 Rte 9w, New Windsor

Alternative Car Storage Facilities near Smithtown

Smithtown offers many different storage options for car storage. Traditional self storage, however, are pricier, less secure, and typically farther way than storage on Neighbor.

If you'd like information about traditional storage facilities in Smithtown, check out the below list for more information:

Public Storage (0.9 miles)

72 Southern Blvd Nesconset, NY

Need car storage in Smithtown?

Neighbor is the world’s largest storage marketplace. Call for rates or search online for the cheapest, closest, and safest storage units.

(844) 449-1099