Car storage in Bay Shore, NY

Top-rated

Average rating of 4+ stars

Cheapest price

Store your car as low as $75/month

Closest to me

Enter your zip for nearby units

Large vehicles

Oversized units for larger vehicles

Multiple vehicles

Storage for more than one car

95% of listings respond within 12 minutes, with an average rating of 4.5 stars.
80% of top rated listings offer outdoor uncovered storage, one offers a first-month discount.
Average cost for a 20x10 space is $188, close to market average of $375.

Driveway

30’ × 10’

5.0

Islip, NY

1.6 mi

near 28 Bay 3rd St

Fenced Property

Attendant or Security

$62.50

1st month

$125/ mo

Average price of lowest car storage: $157. First month discount available on 33% of listings.
Top spaceType: Driveway (50%). Close by: 50% within 0.5 miles.
Average host response time: 12.8 minutes. Outdoor_uncovered feature in 92% of listings.

Other

20’ × 10’

Bay Shore, NY

1.7 mi

near 41N

Security Camera

Private Space

No Stairs

$37.50

1st month

$75/ mo

Driveway

25’ × 20’

Bay Shore, NY

1.2 mi

near 41N

Locked Area

Security Camera

Private Space

No Stairs

$64.50

1st month

$129/ mo

Life Storage

2 sizes available

110 Saxon Ave Bay Shore, NY

1 mi

95% more expensive

10'×15'

starting at

$336/ mo

10'×20'

starting at

$416/ mo

10'×15' starting at

$336

Closest options average 0.7 miles away, with a top response time of 6 minutes.
Unpaved lots dominate, averaging $164 per space, some with camera features.
Driveways average $151, offering 20 feet length, 0.9 miles away on average.

Unpaved Lot

2 sizes available

5.0

Bay Shore, NY

0.1 mi

near 38 S Montgomery Ave

Instant book

Security Camera

25’ × 30’

$169/ mo

20’ × 20’

$225/ mo

25’ × 30’ starting at

$169

Unpaved Lot

70’ × 28’

5.0

Bay Shore, NY

0.4 mi

near 15 Oakland Ave

Instant book

Private Entrance

Security Camera

Smoke Free

No Stairs

$316.15

1st month

$632.29/ mo

Average dimensions: 33 ft by 21 ft; Ideal for trucks, vans, SUVs.
Outdoor lots: 67% of listings; Average price: $258/month.
Quick responses: Average host response time: 13 minutes.

Driveway

3 sizes available

5.0

Bay Shore, NY

0.1 mi

near 38 S Montgomery Ave

Instant book

Security Camera

Private Entrance

No Stairs

Smoke Free

20’ × 10’

$99/ mo

35’ × 30’

$237/ mo

90’ × 20’

$290

1st month

$580/ mo

20’ × 10’ starting at

$99

Average price for Unpaved Lot: $373; 0.2 miles to 0.4 miles from Bay Shore
50% of listings feature security cameras; average host response time: 10 minutes
67% of listings are outdoor uncovered; 42% of hosts respond within 11 minutes

Unpaved Lot

2 sizes available

4.8

Bay Shore, NY

0.3 mi

near 86 Shore Ln

Private Space

No Stairs

21’ × 11’

$116/ mo

20’ × 10’

$116/ mo

21’ × 11’ starting at

$116

Public Storage

3 sizes available

122 Saxon Ave Bay Shore, NY

1 mi

78% more expensive

Pros:

Clean property
eRental saved time and money

Cons:

Charged full month after vacating
High rental and insurance costs
Uncooperative with billing issues
Recent unjustified price increase

10'×15'

starting at

$324/ mo

10'×20'

starting at

$341/ mo

10'×25'

starting at

$468/ mo

10'×15' starting at

$324

Find nearby storage locations

Islip, New York (2 mi)

North Bay Shore, New York (2 mi)

Brentwood, New York (4 mi)

North Babylon, New York (4 mi)

Babylon, New York (5 mi)

West Babylon, New York (6 mi)

Wyandanch, New York (6 mi)

Islandia, New York (7 mi)

Lindenhurst, New York (7 mi)

North Lindenhurst, New York (8 mi)

How Neighbor compares to traditional storage facilities

Neighbor

Traditional facilities

Wide variety of sizes

Lowest prices

Highest safety rating

Protection plans

Nationwide availability

Verified hosts

Manage rental online

View reviews for Neighbor

Storage facility cost comparison

	10×20	10×30	10×40
Average storage facility Bay Shore, NY	$379	--	--
Neighbor 100+ storage spaces nearby	$149	$125	$314
Public Storage Bay Shore, NY (1 miles)	$341	--	--
Life Storage Bay Shore, NY (1 miles)	$416	--	--

Storage for Rent in Bay Shore, NY

Select storage type

What type of vehicle storage is best for you?

Choose whether to store your vehicle using uncovered parking, covered parking, or an indoor storage unit. Each offers their own benefits and downsides.

Uncovered Parking

three cars parked together next to a field

Parking spaces are affordable options at commercial lots & residential properties.

Uncovered storage is more expensive than covered storage by Infinity% on average in Bay Shore

Find outdoor parking

Covered Parking

boat on trailer with fabric cover in outdoor covered area

Covered parking provides a roof or partial enclosure around your car.

There are 200% more hosts in Bay Shore that are part of our Top Host program than surrounding cities

Find covered parking

Indoor Storage

Shared & private storage includes drive-up storage units, private garages & warehouses.

Indoor storage in Bay Shore is 62% more expensive than nearby areas

Find indoor storage

Additional New York car storage locations

Upper Whitfield Road, Accord

145 88 180th Street, Queens

4 Bedford Banksville Rd, Bedford

9 South Lewis Street, Auburn

2907 Rte 9w, New Windsor

Alternative Car Storage Facilities near Bay Shore

Bay Shore offers many different storage companies for car storage. Traditional self storage facilities, however, often are pricier, less secure, and farther from home than self storage on Neighbor.

If you'd like information about traditional storage units in Bay Shore, use the below list of car storage facilities for more details:

Public Storage (1 miles)

122 Saxon Ave Bay Shore, NY

Life Storage - Bay Shore (1 miles)

110 Saxon Ave Bay Shore, NY

Need car storage in Bay Shore?

Neighbor is the world’s largest storage marketplace. Call for rates or search online for the cheapest, closest, and safest storage units.

(844) 449-1099