Self storage units in Indianapolis, IN

  • Average listing price $108; locations as low as $15.98 for a 5x5 unit.

  • Over 30% of listings feature "Drive Up" access; only 17% offer first month discounts.

  • Most listings within 5 miles; perfect for nearby storage needs.

Street view of Extra Space Self Storage

Extra Space Self Storage

7 sizes available

4.9

1215 E Washington St Indianapolis, IN

4.7 mi

41% less expensive

Pros:

  • Friendly and helpful staff

  • Smooth and easy move-in process

  • Clear and detailed explanations

  • Clean and secure facility

Cons:

  • High prices

  • Price increases during rental period

5'×5'

starting at

 

$16/ mo

5'×7'

starting at

 

$25/ mo

10'×5'

starting at

 

$25/ mo

10'×8'

starting at

 

$89/ mo

10'×10'

starting at

 

$50/ mo

10'×12'

starting at

 

$63/ mo

10'×15'

starting at

 

$68/ mo

10'×5' starting at

$25


Street view of Public Storage

Public Storage

6 sizes available

4.9

5151 W Pike Plaza Rd Indianapolis, IN

4.5 mi

2.2x more expensive

Pros:

  • Simple and quick reservation process

  • Professional and nice staff

  • Helpful and kind staff behavior

  • Highly recommended by multiple users

  • Staff available even on holidays

Cons:

  • Fine for being there past 9 pm

5'×6'

starting at

 

$30/ mo

10'×6'

starting at

 

$36/ mo

10'×12'

starting at

 

$129/ mo

10'×16'

starting at

 

$157/ mo

12'×6'

starting at

 

$45/ mo

20'×24'

starting at

 

$491/ mo

5'×6' starting at

$30


securcar...rage.com

SecurCare Self Storage

27 sizes available

3.9

551 Stover Ave Indianapolis, IN

6.3 mi

4% less expensive

Pros:

  • Friendly and professional manager reported

  • Affordable pricing compared to rivals

  • Helpful staff ensuring smooth move-ins

Cons:

  • Multiple accounts of security issues

  • Slow or unresponsive customer service

  • Inconvenient access reported by users

  • Mistakes and delays with rental contracts

5'×7'

starting at

 

$28/ mo

6'×6'

starting at

 

$28/ mo

6'×8'

starting at

 

$32/ mo

10'×6'

starting at

 

$35/ mo

10'×7'

starting at

 

$39/ mo

10'×10'

starting at

 

$70/ mo

10'×12'

starting at

 

$79/ mo

10'×15'

starting at

 

$92/ mo

10'×18'

starting at

 

$99/ mo

10'×20'

starting at

 

$113/ mo

10'×25'

starting at

 

$122/ mo

10'×30'

starting at

 

$199/ mo

10'×35'

starting at

 

$235/ mo

10'×40'

starting at

 

$263/ mo

12'×4'

starting at

 

$28/ mo

12'×6'

starting at

 

$39/ mo

12'×8'

starting at

 

$56/ mo

12'×12'

starting at

 

$85/ mo

12'×15'

starting at

 

$93/ mo

12'×20'

starting at

 

$121/ mo

12'×30'

starting at

 

$242/ mo

12'×35'

starting at

 

$285/ mo

15'×15'

starting at

 

$118/ mo

15'×20'

starting at

 

$199/ mo

15'×27'

starting at

 

$263/ mo

15'×30'

starting at

 

$299/ mo

20'×7'

starting at

 

$82/ mo

6'×8' starting at

$32


  • Average distance of 2.3 miles with 75% within 3.2 miles.

  • Average price is $89, 28% lower than city average.

  • 58% offer drive-up access, 50% have climate control.


Street view of Foxes Den Self Storage

Foxes Den Self Storage

2 sizes available

3.3

633 N Lynhurst Dr Indianapolis, IN

1.3 mi

70% more expensive

Pros:

  • Friendly staff available by phone

  • Convenient on the near Westside

Cons:

  • Frequent break-ins reported by users

  • Many units fail to lock securely

  • Security cameras often do not work

  • Poor communication from management authorities

  • Extra fees charged without notification

10'×5'

starting at

 

$60/ mo

10'×10'

starting at

 

$85/ mo

10'×5' starting at

$60


Street view of Extra Space Storage

Extra Space Storage

7 sizes available

5390 Rockville Rd Indianapolis, IN

1.4 mi

51% more expensive

Pros:

  • Clean and well-kept facility

  • Easy access to units

  • User-friendly website for booking

  • Convenient month-to-month contracts

Cons:

  • Significant rent increases upon renewal

  • Some units infested with roaches

5'×5'

starting at

 

$42/ mo

10'×5'

starting at

 

$62/ mo

10'×7'

starting at

 

$79/ mo

10'×10'

starting at

 

$128/ mo

10'×15'

starting at

 

$165/ mo

10'×20'

starting at

 

$211/ mo

15'×5'

starting at

 

$80/ mo

5'×5' starting at

$42


Street view of Downtown Indy Self Storage

Downtown Indy Self Storage

8 sizes available

4.0

1233 W 18th St Indianapolis, IN

2.8 mi

95% more expensive

Pros:

  • Affordable unit prices

  • Convenient downtown location

  • Clean and well-kept facility

  • Good customer service

Cons:

  • Occasional refund issues or delays

  • Reports of unprofessional staff

  • Instances of adding unwanted charges

  • Rat infestations reported by users

5'×5'

starting at

 

$40/ mo

5'×6'

starting at

 

$45/ mo

10'×5'

starting at

 

$65/ mo

10'×10'

starting at

 

$120/ mo

10'×12'

starting at

 

$140/ mo

10'×15'

starting at

 

$170/ mo

12'×9'

starting at

 

$130/ mo

12'×25'

starting at

 

$349/ mo

5'×5' starting at

$40


  • Average price for self storage medium units is $68; prices range from $25 to $143.

  • Typical unit size is 10x10 feet; average distance to units is 6.0 miles.

  • 60% of units offer camera security; 100% have host response under 6 hours.

6 x 8 Bedroom in Indianapolis, Indiana near 1051 S Emerson Ave, Indianapolis, IN 46203-1606, United States

Bedroom


6’ × 8

Indianapolis, IN

7.2 mi

near 1051 S Emerson Ave

Climate Controlled

Smoke Detectors

Smoke Free

$14.50

  1st month

$29/ mo


12 x 12 Basement in Beech Grove, Indiana near 3706 E Sumner Ave, Indianapolis, IN 46237-1211, United States

Basement

2 sizes available

Beech Grove, IN

7.9 mi

near 3706 E Sumner Ave

Smoke Free

Pet Free

Security Camera

12’ × 12’ starting at

$54


  • Average price per drive-up access unit is $123, with climate control at $136.

  • Most units are 20x10 feet, 7.5 miles away on average.

  • 50% of units are garages with top hosts; average rating is 5.0.

20 x 10 Garage in Indianapolis, Indiana near 1774 Alton St, Beech Grove, IN 46107-1612, United States

Garage


20’ × 10

5.0

Indianapolis, IN

7.5 mi

near 1774 Alton St

Private Space

"David was a really good host, he always responded to my texts on time."

$125/ mo


  • Average price of climate controlled units: $108; units range from $29 to $300.

  • Units with the highest average rating: 100% of listings have 5-star ratings.

  • Quick host responses: 65% of hosts reply within 30 minutes; shortest time is 2 minutes.

17 x 10 Basement in Beech Grove, Indiana near 3706 E Sumner Ave, Indianapolis, IN 46237-1211, United States

Basement


17’ × 10

5.0

Beech Grove, IN

7.7 mi

near 3706 E Sumner Ave

Climate Controlled

Smoke Free

Smoke Detectors

$39.50

  1st month

$79/ mo


  • 50% of listings have security cameras; average response time is 40 minutes.

  • Average rating of 5; 33% of listings offer 24/7 access.

  • Garage space type is most common; average size is 20x12 feet.

20 x 15 Garage in Indianapolis, Indiana near National Ave, Indianapolis, IN 46227, United States

Garage


20’ × 15

Indianapolis, IN

6.4 mi

near National Ave

Climate Controlled

Smoke Free

Smoke Detectors

$300/ mo


  • 33% of listings have climate control; all are under 4 miles away.

  • Average price for 25 sq. ft. units is $29; 50% of those are drive-up.

  • Host response time averages 45 minutes; 50% of units have exterior access.

Street view of Public Storage

Public Storage

6 sizes available

4.7

7435 Rockville Rd Indianapolis, IN

3.5 mi

23% more expensive

Pros:

  • Leasing process was easy and efficient

  • Manager helps when problems arise

  • Staff shows good service overall

Cons:

  • No staff usually present for help

  • Strangers living in and entering units

  • Prices can increase sharply

  • Hard to exit facility after hours

5'×5'

starting at

 

$22/ mo

10'×5'

starting at

 

$39/ mo

10'×7'

starting at

 

$49/ mo

10'×10'

starting at

 

$62/ mo

10'×15'

starting at

 

$106/ mo

10'×30'

starting at

 

$158/ mo

5'×5' starting at

$22


Street view of Simply Self Storage

Simply Self Storage

8 sizes available

4.8

7828 W Washington St Indianapolis, IN

4.4 mi

16% more expensive

Pros:

  • Helpful and professional customer service

  • Clean and well-maintained facility

  • Flexible options for storage needs

  • Affordable prices compared to competitors

Cons:

  • Ongoing roach infestation affecting units

  • Limited number of carts available

  • Facility is becoming more expensive

5'×5'

starting at

 

$37/ mo

10'×5'

starting at

 

$34/ mo

10'×10'

starting at

 

$77/ mo

10'×15'

starting at

 

$105/ mo

10'×20'

starting at

 

$110/ mo

10'×25'

starting at

 

$126/ mo

10'×30'

starting at

 

$145/ mo

15'×20'

starting at

 

$155/ mo

5'×5' starting at

$37


  • Average price of large units is $131, with sizes up to 400 sq ft.

  • 83% of listings have security cameras and average distance is 5.8 miles.

  • Hosts respond within 21 minutes on average, with 17% rated as Top Hosts.

16 x 12 Shed in Indianapolis, Indiana near 4511 Mesa Dr, Indianapolis, IN 46241-6546, United States

Shed


16’ × 12

5.0

Indianapolis, IN

3.1 mi

near 4511 Mesa Dr

Private Space

Smoke Free

No Stairs

"Quick to respond."

$95/ mo


    Street view of Simply Self Storage - Indianapolis/Beachway Drive

    Simply Self Storage

    7 sizes available

    4.8

    749 Beachway Dr Indianapolis, IN

    2.2 mi

    11% more expensive

    Pros:

    • Quick and easy renting process

    • Friendly and helpful staff

    • Secure facility with good units

    • Competitive rates

    Cons:

    • Added unexpected charges for a lock cut

    • Price changes after initial quotes

    • Technical issues setting up gate access

    5'×7'

    starting at

     

    $21/ mo

    10'×5'

    starting at

     

    $42/ mo

    10'×10'

    starting at

     

    $85/ mo

    10'×20'

    starting at

     

    $135/ mo

    10'×25'

    starting at

     

    $127/ mo

    10'×30'

    starting at

     

    $146/ mo

    15'×5'

    starting at

     

    $55/ mo

    5'×7' starting at

    $21


    Find nearby storage locations

    Beech Grove, Indiana (8 mi)
    Carmel, Indiana (14 mi)

    How Neighbor compares to traditional storage facilities

    badge w/star

    Neighbor

    Traditional facilities

    Wide variety of sizes

    Lowest prices

    Highest safety rating

    Protection plans

    Nationwide availability

    Verified hosts

    Manage rental online

    View reviews for Neighbor

    Storage facility cost comparison

    5×5

    10×10

    10×20

    10×30

    Average storage facility

    Indianapolis, IN

    $51

    $110

    $185

    $231

    Neighbor

    17 storage spaces nearby

    Foxes Den Self Storage

    Indianapolis, IN (1 miles)

    $60

    $85

    --

    --

    Extra Space Storage

    Indianapolis, IN (1 miles)

    $42

    $128

    $211

    --

    Simply Self Storage

    Indianapolis, IN (2 miles)

    $21

    $85

    $127

    $146

    Storage for Rent in Indianapolis, IN

    Select storage type

    self storage
    RV storage
    boat storage
    car storage
    monthly parking
    truck parking
    garages
    long term parking

    What’s the best self storage option for you?

    Compare the pros and cons of renting from various storage unit options, including drive-up and interior units

    Drive-up Exterior Units
    open view of an empty garage

    Enclosed drive-up storage units, like garages, have an outdoor entrance

    42% of storage spaces in Indianapolis have security cameras as an amenity provided by the host

    Find drive-up storage
    Interior-Access Storage Units
    row of indoor storage lockers

    Indoor spaces like vacant offices or residential rooms offer increased protection

    In Indianapolis, 57% of listings do not have stairs leading to the storage space, allowing for easy access

    Find indoor storage units
    Vehicle Storage Units
    view of a half-closed garage with a car inside

    Indoor storage units that allow vehicles provide protection over outdoor parking

    Residential indoor parking in Indianapolis is 97% more expensive than nearby areas

    Find car storage units

    Alternative Self Storage Facilities near Indianapolis

    Even though self storage on Neighbor.com has the lower-priced, more secure, and nearest self storage, traditional self storage units could also be a potential option for self storage in Indianapolis, IN.

    Look at the list of self storage facilities for details:

    Simply Self Storage - Indianapolis/Beachway Drive (2.2 miles)

    749 Beachway Dr Indianapolis, IN

    Simply Self Storage (4 miles)

    7937 W 10th St Indianapolis, IN

    Public Storage (3.5 miles)

    7435 Rockville Rd Indianapolis, IN

    Extra Space Self Storage (4.7 miles)

    1215 E Washington St Indianapolis, IN

    Simply Self Storage (4.4 miles)

    7828 W Washington St Indianapolis, IN

    Public Storage (4.5 miles)

    5151 W Pike Plaza Rd Indianapolis, IN

    SecurCare Self Storage (4.8 miles)

    3912 N Glen Arm Rd Indianapolis, IN

    Extra Space Storage (3.2 miles)

    6231 Crawfordsville Rd Indianapolis, IN

    Public Storage (3.2 miles)

    2230 N High School Rd Indianapolis, IN

    Store Space Self Storage (3.4 miles)

    1426 W 29th St Indianapolis, IN

    Public Storage (4 miles)

    6910 Waterfront Dr Indianapolis, IN

    Public Storage (4.6 miles)

    4305 Lafayette Rd Indianapolis, IN

    Storage Express (3.5 miles)

    2950 S Lynhurst Dr Indianapolis, IN

    Foxes Den Self Storage (1.3 miles)

    633 N Lynhurst Dr Indianapolis, IN

    Public Storage (3.3 miles)

    6817 W Washington St Indianapolis, IN

    Need self storage in Indianapolis?

    Neighbor is the world’s largest storage marketplace. Call for rates or search online for the cheapest, closest, and safest storage units.

    (844) 448-0855