Self storage units in Indianapolis, IN
Neighbor reviews near Indianapolis, IN
5.0 (3,412 reviews)
Based on 3,412 verified reviews, renters rated Neighbor's service for finding self storage units in Indianapolis 5.0 out of 5 on average
Closest units to my location
50% of closest listings within 1.4 miles, average $93.
67% of units with drive-up access, average price $110.
75% of climate-controlled spaces, average $130, average 2.4 miles.
Search your zip code:
- 46217
- 46240
- 46298
- 46247
- 46113
- 46277
- 46220
- 46285
- 46237
- 46226
- 46222
- 46283
- 46268
- 46228
- 46234
- 46230
- 46224
- 46250
- 46260
- 46183
Not affiliated with Neighbor
Downtown Indy Self Storage
Indianapolis, IN
2.8 mi
1233 W 18th St Indianapolis, IN
4.0
Pros: affordable unit prices, convenient downtown location, clean and well-kept facility, good customer serviceCons: occasional refund issues or delays, reports of unprofessional staff, instances of adding unwanted charges, rat infestations reported by users
starting at
$37
per month
Not affiliated with Neighbor
Extra Space Storage
Indianapolis, IN
3.2 mi
6231 Crawfordsville Rd Indianapolis, IN
4.8
Pros: great customer service consistently praised, polite and helpful staff interaction, efficient and knowledgeable assistanceCons: several hidden fees including admin fee, storage door broken during visit
starting at
$25
per month
Not affiliated with Neighbor
Store Space Self Storage
Indianapolis, IN
3.4 mi
1426 W 29th St Indianapolis, IN
4.7
Pros: big and clean facility, affordable pricing availableCons: frequent issues with entry doors, entry can be dangerous and confusing, security concerns due to broken entry, uncooperative and unhelpful management, inaccessible storage units during non-office hours
starting at
$52
per month
Not affiliated with Neighbor
Storage Express
Indianapolis, IN
3.5 mi
2950 S Lynhurst Dr Indianapolis, IN
4.4
Pros: secure facility with good lighting, affordable for smaller units, 24/7 access availableCons: reports of rodent infestations, some incidents of theft, difficult parking area to navigate, high prices for some units
starting at
$30
per month
Not affiliated with Neighbor
CubeSmart Self Storage
Indianapolis, IN
4.1 mi
2135 N Illinois St Indianapolis, IN
4.7
Pros: clean and well-maintained facility, high security measures in placeCons: customer service is inconsistent, limited number of carts available, some high service costs
starting at
$64
per month
Not affiliated with Neighbor
SecurCare Self Storage
Indianapolis, IN
4.7 mi
4115 Heiney Rd Indianapolis, IN
4.1
Pros: excellent and friendly management, clean and well-maintained facility, great for answering all questionsCons: frequent rent increases, lack of long-term pricing stability
starting at
$48
per month
Not affiliated with Neighbor
SecurCare Self Storage
Indianapolis, IN
4.8 mi
3912 N Glen Arm Rd Indianapolis, IN
4.7
Pros: friendly and attentive customer service., very clean and well-kept facility., quick and easy rental process., highly recommended by users.
starting at
$16
per month
Not affiliated with Neighbor
Store Space Self Storage
Indianapolis, IN
4.9 mi
2715 Madison Ave Indianapolis, IN
4.4
Pros: secure and climate controlled units, friendly and helpful staff, easy unit rental process, competitive pricingCons: locked out of unit by mistake, reports of cockroaches in the facility, possible break-ins at facility units, unable to find assistance for cart return
starting at
$28
per month
Basement
12×12
Beech Grove, IN
5.0 mi
Near 3706 E Sumner Ave
5.0
No Stairs
Private Entrance
starting at
$54
per month
Not affiliated with Neighbor
Storage Express
Indianapolis, IN
5.2 mi
4822 Mann Rd Indianapolis, IN
4.2
Pros: easy to lease and access, secure with surveillance cameras, clean and well-maintained units, friendly and helpful staffCons: price increases over time, no 24-hour access available, issues with gate access limits, difficulty with online systems and kiosks
starting at
$70
per month
Self Storage Unit
20×10
Indianapolis, IN
5.5 mi
5030 N Keystone Ave Indianapolis, Indiana
5.0
Pet Free
No Stairs
starting at
$196
per month
Self Storage Unit
20×10
Indianapolis, IN
5.8 mi
749 Beachway Dr Indianapolis, Indiana
5.0
Pet Free
No Stairs
"They’re simply the best."－ Verified review
starting at
$99
per month
Not affiliated with Neighbor
Storage Express
Indianapolis, IN
5.9 mi
9201 W Washington St Indianapolis, IN
4.6
Pros: very clean and well-maintained units, easy and smooth rental process, helpful and friendly customer service, units are secure with good surveillanceCons: some users report higher-than-expected rents, issues with billing inaccuracies and overcharges, concerns about security in certain areas
starting at
$78
per month
Self Storage Unit
20×10
Indianapolis, IN
6.4 mi
2230 N High School Road Indianapolis, Indiana
5.0
Pet Free
No Stairs
starting at
$102
per month
Self Storage Unit
24×10
Indianapolis, IN
6.4 mi
5151 Pike Plaza Indianapolis, Indiana
5.0
Attendant or Security
Pet Free
"She’s amazing. Appreciate it, Michelle, you’re the best."－ Verified review
starting at
$169
per month
Not affiliated with Neighbor
Storage Express
Indianapolis, IN
6.5 mi
6110 Belmont Ave Indianapolis, IN
4.6
Pros: convenient and easy access, clean and well-maintained facility, good customer service experiencesCons: limited access hours for entry, no on-site personnel during certain times, high pricing compared to expectations, inconsistent handling of gate code issues
starting at
$35
per month
Not affiliated with Neighbor
Storage Express
Indianapolis, IN
6.6 mi
510 E Thompson Rd Indianapolis, IN
4.2
Pros: conveniently located with 24-hour access., facility clean and well-maintained., easy to get move-in code., helpful and friendly staff.Cons: presence of mice and pests., unorganized customer service., hidden fees or surprise charges., too expensive for unit sizes.
starting at
$71
per month
Not affiliated with Neighbor
Storage of America
Indianapolis, IN
6.8 mi
4225 W 62nd St Indianapolis, IN
4.4
Pros: clean facilities, security in place allows safety, can access the unit anytime, easily accessible for moving in/outCons: reports of mice and rat infestation, complaints of occasional rate increases, multiple incidents of unhelpful customer service, issues with self-service kiosk and unit assignment
starting at
$89
per month
Self Storage Unit
20×10
Indianapolis, IN
7.1 mi
7435 Rockville Road Indianapolis, Indiana
5.0
Pet Free
No Stairs
starting at
$112
per month
Cheap prices: Starting at $10
Average price for affordable storage units: $29; average size: 25 sq ft.
First month discount available on 17% of lowest priced units.
Closest average distance to units: 5.1 miles; most under $50.
Storage space
6×6
Daleville, IN
39.1 mi
Near I-69
Pet Free
No Stairs
$10
per month
Attic
10×12
Carmel, IN
12.7 mi
Near 5001 W 106th St
Smoke Free
Private Space
Very ideal for Rubbermaid storage, but renters have used it for anything from lumber and hardware to electronics.
50% off first month
$25
per month
Basement
9×7
Cincinnati, OH
99.6 mi
Near Transpark Dr
5.0
Smoke Free
Smoke Detectors
50% off first month
$29
per month
Attic
3×15
Carmel, IN
12.7 mi
Near 5001 W 106th St
Smoke Free
Pet Free
We will put them up and bring them down.
50% off first month
$35
per month
Shed
8×8
Oxford, OH
79.2 mi
Near 3960 Harris Rd
Smoke Free
Security Camera
50% off first month
$35
per month
Shed
10×10
Middletown, OH
95.5 mi
Near 1701 Run Way
Pet Free
Smoke Free
$39
per month
Not affiliated with Neighbor
Downtown Indy Self Storage
Indianapolis, IN
2.8 mi
1233 W 18th St Indianapolis, IN
4.0
Pros: affordable unit prices, convenient downtown location, clean and well-kept facility, good customer serviceCons: occasional refund issues or delays, reports of unprofessional staff, instances of adding unwanted charges, rat infestations reported by users
starting at
$45
per month
Storage space
8×8
Fountaintown, IN
21.0 mi
Near 649 E County Road 1100 N
5.0
Instant book
$49
per month
Basement
10×10
Cincinnati, OH
94.1 mi
Near 29 Deerhill Ln
5.0
Climate Controlled
Smoke Free
50% off first month
$50
per month
Self Storage Unit
5×10
Terre Haute, IN
67.1 mi
Near 1600 N Fruitridge Ave
1.0
Security Camera
Private Entrance
$50
per month
Basement
12×12
Beech Grove, IN
5.0 mi
Near 3706 E Sumner Ave
5.0
No Stairs
Private Entrance
starting at
$54
per month
Basement
10×10
Burlington, KY
91.8 mi
Near 6034 S Orient St
Smoke Free
Pet Free
50% off first month
starting at
$54
per month
Bedroom
10×10
Bloomington, IN
44.9 mi
Near 2651 E Discovery Pkwy
4.0
Smoke Free
Smoke Detectors
$57
per month
Garage
20×10
Shelbyville, IN
27.1 mi
Near 2403 Overlook Dr
Smoke Free
Private Entrance
$58
per month
Storage space
10×8
Brownsburg, IN
15.5 mi
Near 10706 N County Road 800 E
Instant book
Security Camera
Private Entrance
starting at
$59
per month
Basement
17×10
Beech Grove, IN
4.7 mi
Near 3706 E Sumner Ave
5.0
Climate Controlled
Smoke Free
50% off first month
$68
per month
Not affiliated with Neighbor
Wanamaker Self Storage
Indianapolis, IN
12.0 mi
3730 Cindy Ln Indianapolis, IN
4.8
Pros: well-kept and clean facility, free box truck rental, secure storage service, friendly and helpful staff
starting at
$69
per month
Not affiliated with Neighbor
SecurCare Self Storage
Indianapolis, IN
4.8 mi
3912 N Glen Arm Rd Indianapolis, IN
4.7
Pros: friendly and attentive customer service., very clean and well-kept facility., quick and easy rental process., highly recommended by users.
starting at
$71
per month
Shed
15×15
Guilford, IN
73.6 mi
Near 23599 Chapel Thorne Dr
Private Space
Pet Free
$74
per month
Larger units: 10x15 and above
Average price $126 per month for large units in Indianapolis.
67% of listings offer security cameras for added safety.
50% have "Top Host" status, ensuring reliable hosts.
Not affiliated with Neighbor
SecurCare Self Storage
Indianapolis, IN
4.8 mi
3912 N Glen Arm Rd Indianapolis, IN
4.7
Pros: friendly and attentive customer service., very clean and well-kept facility., quick and easy rental process., highly recommended by users.
starting at
$194
per month
Not affiliated with Neighbor
SecurCare Self Storage
Avon, IN
8.4 mi
71 Vista Park Way Avon, IN
4.8
Pros: clean and organized storage spaces, friendly and helpful staff, affordable storage unit options, easy to find and access unitsCons: no significant complaints listed
starting at
$225
per month
Not affiliated with Neighbor
Storage Express
Indianapolis, IN
6.5 mi
6110 Belmont Ave Indianapolis, IN
4.6
Pros: convenient and easy access, clean and well-maintained facility, good customer service experiencesCons: limited access hours for entry, no on-site personnel during certain times, high pricing compared to expectations, inconsistent handling of gate code issues
starting at
$107
per month
Self Storage Unit
20×12
Indianapolis, IN
8.9 mi
6901 Hawthorn Park Dr Indianapolis, Indiana
5.0
Pet Free
No Stairs
starting at
$142
per month
Not affiliated with Neighbor
Extra Space Storage
Indianapolis, IN
5.8 mi
2255 S Raceway Rd Indianapolis, IN
4.8
Pros: clean and well-maintained units, friendly and helpful staff, quick and easy rental process, good customer serviceCons: reports of mice in some units, prices increase over time, high administration and hidden fees
starting at
$133
per month
Medium sized units: 5x5 - 10x15
Average price of medium storage units is $102, with a distance of 5.5 miles.
Fast host responses, within 2 minutes, are available in 50% of listings.
75% of listings offer security features like cameras for added protection.
Storage space
8×8
Fountaintown, IN
21.0 mi
Near 649 E County Road 1100 N
5.0
Instant book
$49
per month
Garage
15×5
Cincinnati, OH
93.2 mi
Near 1977 Sylved Ln
5.0
Smoke Free
Smoke Detectors
$100
per month
Storage space
10×8
Brownsburg, IN
15.5 mi
Near 10706 N County Road 800 E
Instant book
Security Camera
Private Entrance
starting at
$59
per month
Basement
10×10
Cincinnati, OH
94.1 mi
Near 29 Deerhill Ln
5.0
Climate Controlled
Smoke Free
50% off first month
$50
per month
Self Storage Unit
5×10
Terre Haute, IN
67.1 mi
Near 1600 N Fruitridge Ave
1.0
Security Camera
Private Entrance
$50
per month
Not affiliated with Neighbor
Storage Express
Indianapolis, IN
3.5 mi
2950 S Lynhurst Dr Indianapolis, IN
4.4
Pros: secure facility with good lighting, affordable for smaller units, 24/7 access availableCons: reports of rodent infestations, some incidents of theft, difficult parking area to navigate, high prices for some units
starting at
$30
per month
Bedroom
10×10
Bloomington, IN
44.9 mi
Near 2651 E Discovery Pkwy
4.0
Smoke Free
Smoke Detectors
$57
per month
Shed
10×10
Middletown, OH
95.5 mi
Near 1701 Run Way
Pet Free
Smoke Free
$39
per month
Basement
10×10
Burlington, KY
91.8 mi
Near 6034 S Orient St
Smoke Free
Pet Free
50% off first month
starting at
$54
per month
Not affiliated with Neighbor
Extra Space Storage
Indianapolis, IN
5.8 mi
2255 S Raceway Rd Indianapolis, IN
4.8
Pros: clean and well-maintained units, friendly and helpful staff, quick and easy rental process, good customer serviceCons: reports of mice in some units, prices increase over time, high administration and hidden fees
starting at
$133
per month
Smaller units: 5x5 and below
Average price of 5x5 units: $36. Cheapest unit: $21.
Distance to storage: 4.4 miles. Fast host response time: 28 minutes.
75% of listings with climate control. Most units outdoor access.
Closet
4×3
Cincinnati, OH
99.0 mi
Near 2050 E Seymour Ave
Security Camera
Smoke Detectors
50% off first month
starting at
$15
per month
Not affiliated with Neighbor
Signature Self Storage
Brownsburg, IN
8.5 mi
8050 Ortho Ln Brownsburg, IN
4.9
Pros: clean and well-maintained facility, easy to reserve and access units, excellent customer service, temperature-controlled storage optionsCons: office hours can be inconsistent, rental rates increase significantly after initial months, fees for purchasing mandatory locks
starting at
$39
per month
Not affiliated with Neighbor
SecurCare Self Storage
Indianapolis, IN
4.7 mi
4115 Heiney Rd Indianapolis, IN
4.1
Pros: excellent and friendly management, clean and well-maintained facility, great for answering all questionsCons: frequent rent increases, lack of long-term pricing stability
starting at
$48
per month
Not affiliated with Neighbor
Store Space Self Storage
Indianapolis, IN
4.9 mi
2715 Madison Ave Indianapolis, IN
4.4
Pros: secure and climate controlled units, friendly and helpful staff, easy unit rental process, competitive pricingCons: locked out of unit by mistake, reports of cockroaches in the facility, possible break-ins at facility units, unable to find assistance for cart return
starting at
$28
per month
Not affiliated with Neighbor
Extra Space Storage
Indianapolis, IN
3.2 mi
6231 Crawfordsville Rd Indianapolis, IN
4.8
Pros: great customer service consistently praised, polite and helpful staff interaction, efficient and knowledgeable assistanceCons: several hidden fees including admin fee, storage door broken during visit
starting at
$25
per month
Drive-up access with your vehicle
Garage space available at $300, 6.4 miles from you.
Climate-controlled units, 4.5 miles average distance, $136 average price.
5x5 storage units at $25, 4.5 miles away.
Garage
20×10
Indianapolis, IN
9.5 mi
Near 4939 E 72nd St
5.0
No Stairs
Climate Controlled
$160
per month
Garage
10×20
Lebanon, IN
25.6 mi
Near 805 Sorrell Ct
5.0
Locked Area
$100
per month
Garage
20×10
Shelbyville, IN
27.1 mi
Near 2403 Overlook Dr
Smoke Free
Private Entrance
$58
per month
Garage
35×15
Paoli, IN
91.5 mi
Near 5730 S State Road 37
Security Camera
Climate Controlled
$325
per month
Warehouse
30×15
Paoli, IN
91.5 mi
Near 5730 S State Road 37
Climate Controlled
Smoke Free
$325
per month
Not affiliated with Neighbor
SecurCare Self Storage
Avon, IN
8.4 mi
71 Vista Park Way Avon, IN
4.8
Pros: clean and organized storage spaces, friendly and helpful staff, affordable storage unit options, easy to find and access unitsCons: no significant complaints listed
starting at
$39
per month
Garage
30×50
Bloomington, IN
54.6 mi
Near 8778 S Old IN-37
Security Camera
Private Entrance
$300
per month
Garage
60×30
Hamilton, OH
84.0 mi
Near 2955 Old Oxford Rd
Smoke Free
Private Entrance
$290
per month
Not affiliated with Neighbor
Storage Express
Indianapolis, IN
6.5 mi
6110 Belmont Ave Indianapolis, IN
4.6
Pros: convenient and easy access, clean and well-maintained facility, good customer service experiencesCons: limited access hours for entry, no on-site personnel during certain times, high pricing compared to expectations, inconsistent handling of gate code issues
starting at
$35
per month
Not affiliated with Neighbor
Storage Express
Indianapolis, IN
3.5 mi
2950 S Lynhurst Dr Indianapolis, IN
4.4
Pros: secure facility with good lighting, affordable for smaller units, 24/7 access availableCons: reports of rodent infestations, some incidents of theft, difficult parking area to navigate, high prices for some units
starting at
$30
per month
Not affiliated with Neighbor
Extra Space Storage
Indianapolis, IN
5.8 mi
2255 S Raceway Rd Indianapolis, IN
4.8
Pros: clean and well-maintained units, friendly and helpful staff, quick and easy rental process, good customer serviceCons: reports of mice in some units, prices increase over time, high administration and hidden fees
starting at
$47
per month
Climate controlled storage
Average price of listings: $107. Average rating: 5 stars.
Host response time: within 23 minutes. Average distance: 7.7 miles.
Top hosts in 100% of listings. First month discount available.
Storage space
20×11
Greenwood, IN
13.9 mi
Near 210 S Harvey Rd
5.0
Instant book
Climate Controlled
Smoke Free
$155
per month
Self Storage Unit
18×10
Zionsville, IN
12.4 mi
4628 Northwestern Dr Zionsville, Indiana
5.0
Pet Free
No Stairs
starting at
$160
per month
Bedroom
20×20
Cincinnati, OH
98.6 mi
Near 7754 Vine St
Security Camera
Smoke Detectors
50% off first month
$85
per month
Bedroom
34×10
Cincinnati, OH
98.9 mi
Near 2050 E Seymour Ave
Security Camera
Smoke Detectors
50% off first month
$102
per month
Bedroom
12×5
Cincinnati, OH
97.9 mi
Near 23 Thill St
Climate Controlled
Smoke Free
$300
per month
Garage
35×15
Paoli, IN
91.5 mi
Near 5730 S State Road 37
Security Camera
Climate Controlled
$325
per month
Warehouse
30×15
Paoli, IN
91.5 mi
Near 5730 S State Road 37
Climate Controlled
Smoke Free
$325
per month
Garage
30×50
Bloomington, IN
54.6 mi
Near 8778 S Old IN-37
Security Camera
Private Entrance
$300
per month
Business storage
33% of listings offer 24/7 access; 50% have security cameras.
Average price with security cameras: $128; market price for 20x10 space: $137.
Most common space type: Storage Unit; average host response time: 45 minutes.
Warehouse
30×15
Paoli, IN
91.5 mi
Near 5730 S State Road 37
Climate Controlled
Smoke Free
$325
per month
Garage
30×50
Bloomington, IN
54.6 mi
Near 8778 S Old IN-37
Security Camera
Private Entrance
$300
per month
Garage
60×30
Hamilton, OH
84.0 mi
Near 2955 Old Oxford Rd
Smoke Free
Private Entrance
$290
per month
Not affiliated with Neighbor
Extra Space Storage
Indianapolis, IN
5.8 mi
2255 S Raceway Rd Indianapolis, IN
4.8
Pros: clean and well-maintained units, friendly and helpful staff, quick and easy rental process, good customer serviceCons: reports of mice in some units, prices increase over time, high administration and hidden fees
starting at
$133
per month
24-hour access
Average price of 24/7 access storage units is $130.6. Minimum price $54.
83% of units are climate-controlled. Distance averages 4.6 miles.
Most common size is 50 sq ft. 50% of units are drive-up accessible.
Self Storage Unit
10×10
Whiteland, IN
14.6 mi
Near 6420 N County Road 75 W
Instant book
Private Space
Private Entrance
$75
per month
Shed
29×9
New Palestine, IN
15.0 mi
Near 4467 Preserve Valley Ln W
No Stairs
Smoke Free
50% off first month
$82
per month
Self Storage Unit
100×70
Carmel, IN
15.1 mi
13610 N Meridian St Carmel, Indiana
Instant book
No Stairs
$5,175
per month
How Neighbor compares to traditional storage facilities
Neighbor
Neighbor
Traditional facilities
Traditional facilities
Wide variety of sizes
Wide variety of sizes
Lowest prices
Lowest prices
Highest safety rating
Highest safety rating
Protection plans
Protection plans
Nationwide availability
Nationwide availability
Verified hosts
Verified hosts
Manage rental online
Manage rental online
Storage facility cost comparison
5×5 | 5×10 | 10×10 | 10×20 | 10×30 | 10×40 | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Average storage facility Indianapolis, IN | $46 | $60 | $108 | $179 | $245 | $299 |
Neighbor 100+ storage spaces nearby | ||||||
Downtown Indy Self Storage Indianapolis, IN (3 miles) | $37 | $65 | $120 | $399 | -- | -- |
Extra Space Storage Indianapolis, IN (3 miles) | $52 | $86 | $159 | $319 | $403 | -- |
Store Space Self Storage Indianapolis, IN (3 miles) | $52 | $56 | $119 | $238 | $481 | -- |
Storage for Rent in Indianapolis, IN
Select storage type
What’s the best self storage option for you?
Compare the pros and cons of renting from various storage unit options, including drive-up and interior units
Drive-up Exterior Units
Enclosed drive-up storage units, like garages, have an outdoor entrance
2% of storage spaces in Indianapolis have security cameras as an amenity provided by the host
Interior-Access Storage Units
Indoor spaces like vacant offices or residential rooms offer increased protection
In Indianapolis, 87% of listings do not have stairs leading to the storage space, allowing for easy access
Vehicle Storage Units
Indoor storage units that allow vehicles provide protection over outdoor parking
Residential indoor parking in Indianapolis is 17% cheaper than nearby areas
Alternative Self Storage Facilities near Indianapolis
Even though self storage on Neighbor.com has the lower-priced, more secure, and nearest self storage, traditional self storage units could also be a potential option for self storage in Indianapolis, IN.
Look at the list of self storage facilities for details:
Need self storage in Indianapolis?
Neighbor is the world’s largest storage marketplace. Call for rates or search online for the cheapest, closest, and safest storage units.
(844) 448-0855