Self storage units in Holtsville, NY
Neighbor reviews near Holtsville, New York
4.9 (1,266 reviews)
Based on 1,266 verified reviews, renters rated Neighbor's service for finding self storage units in Holtsville 4.9 out of 5 on average
O
Otto H.
-
Dedham, MA
Mar 22, 2022
Verified Review
will rent storage again
J
Jennifer H.
-
Easton, CT
Apr 29, 2024
Verified Review
J
Jeffrey G.
-
Weston, CT
Aug 31, 2024
Verified Review
Ace H.
-
Bridgeport, CT
Apr 25, 2024
Verified Review
B
Brian K.
-
Easton, CT
Jun 28, 2022
Verified Review
C
Chris L.
-
Yaphank, NY
Jun 3, 2024
Verified Review
Now showing 1-6 of 1,266 reviews for Holtsville, NY
Closest units to my location
Closest units average 2.5 miles away with 90% of them under 3.5 miles.
Average price of units: $177; 83% have security cameras.
Fast response time: average of 30.5 minutes for all units.
Search your zip code:
- 00544
- 00501
- 11742
Not affiliated with Neighbor
U-Haul Moving & Storage Of Medford
Medford, NY
2.7 mi
3118 Horseblock Rd Medford, NY
Pros: plenty of parking space, clean and organized facility, 24-hour storage access available, convenient after-hours returnsCons: poor communication about storage unit auctions, frequent trouble with u-box delivery scheduling, often hard to reach customer service, inconvenience caused by engrossed staff
starting at
$75
per month
Not affiliated with Neighbor
Public Storage
Patchogue, NY
3.2 mi
601 Sunrise Hwy Patchogue, NY
4.9
Pros: helpful and friendly customer service, assistance with locks and payments, knowledgeable and attentive staff, smooth overall experience, reasonably priced unitsCons: reports of stolen items, roach infestation, dampness and spider webs, dysfunctional lighting in units
starting at
$69
per month
Not affiliated with Neighbor
Life Storage
Patchogue, NY
3.2 mi
500 Sunrise Hwy Patchogue, NY
Pros: friendly and helpful staff, facility is very clean, great prices and deals, fast and easy rental processCons: reduced availability of carts, rent increases after new ownership transition, possible decrease in cleanliness after changes
starting at
$52
per month
Not affiliated with Neighbor
Public Storage
Holbrook, NY
3.3 mi
15 Andrea Rd Holbrook, NY
4.6
Pros: facility generally well maintained and clean, helpful and friendly staff, quick and efficient rental processCons: high late fee charges, issues with security doors and access codes, infrequent staffing at front desk, unpleasant customer service experiences, unexpected substantial price increases
starting at
$65
per month
Cheap prices: Starting at $49
Average price is $136; 58% of units offer first month discounts.
Sizes range from 5x5 to 20x20 feet; average distance is 4.4 miles.
75% of units include drive-up access; 67% are climate-controlled.
Not affiliated with Neighbor
iStorage Self Storage
Patchogue, NY
3.4 mi
257 Waverly Ave Patchogue, NY
4.7
Pros: friendly and helpful staff, good location, clean facility, affordable pricingCons: hidden fees (ratings support user perception)
starting at
$90
per month
Not affiliated with Neighbor
U-Haul Moving & Storage of Smithtown
Smithtown, NY
6.8 mi
771 Nesconset Hwy Smithtown, NY
starting at
$110
per month
Not affiliated with Neighbor
Bayport Mini Storage
Bayport, NY
5.1 mi
915 Montauk Hwy Bayport, NY
4.9
Pros: very clean and spacious units, grounds are well maintained, great 24-hour access, affordable rates
starting at
$110
per month
Not affiliated with Neighbor
Extra Space Storage
Bohemia, NY
4.5 mi
510 Johnson Ave Bohemia, NY
4.9
Pros: convenient and accessible location, safe and clean propertyCons: slow digital gate access system
starting at
$112
per month
Larger units: 10x15 and above
Average price of large storage in Holtsville: $341, average size: 55 square feet.
Top Host rating for 100% of listings; 80% offer security cameras.
Average distance from users: 3.5 miles, 60% respond within 20 minutes.
Not affiliated with Neighbor
Public Storage
Coram, NY
3.4 mi
550 Middle Country Rd Coram, NY
4.8
Pros: easy registration and setup process, staff is very professional and helpful, mobile entry app for easy accessCons: significant rent increases over time, costs could be high for long-term renters
starting at
$424
per month
Not affiliated with Neighbor
Extra Space Storage
Coram, NY
4.4 mi
2025 Route 112 Coram, NY
4.8
Pros: units are clean and well-maintained., location is safe and secure., helpful and friendly staff., conveniently located with a variety of unit sizes.Cons: website and online process can be confusing., high curbs at some units., some units smaller than listed dimensions.
starting at
$260
per month
Smaller units: 5x5 and below
Small storage units average $36 monthly; 5x5 units average $31, 4x4 units $16.
All units within 4.5 miles; average distance 3.4 miles.
50% of units have climate control; response time averages 10 minutes.
Not affiliated with Neighbor
Extra Space Storage
Yaphank, NY
4.9 mi
84 Long Island Ave Yaphank, NY
4.9
Pros: facility is clean and well maintained, safe and secure environment, climate-controlled storage options available
starting at
$54
per month
Not affiliated with Neighbor
iStorage Self Storage
Bayport, NY
4.1 mi
709 Church St Bayport, NY
4.8
Pros: clean and secure facility, convenient location, friendly and helpful staffCons: difficult to contact staff, staff can be unavailable
starting at
$66
per month
Not affiliated with Neighbor
Extra Space Storage
Holtsville, NY
0.8 mi
970 Waverly Ave Holtsville, NY
4.8
Pros: clean units and overall property, user-friendly online rental management, well-lit and secure facilityCons: significant price increase after a few months
starting at
$75
per month
Find nearby storage locations
How Neighbor compares to traditional storage facilities
Neighbor
Neighbor
Traditional facilities
Traditional facilities
Wide variety of sizes
Wide variety of sizes
Lowest prices
Lowest prices
Highest safety rating
Highest safety rating
Protection plans
Protection plans
Nationwide availability
Nationwide availability
Verified hosts
Verified hosts
Manage rental online
Manage rental online
Storage facility cost comparison
5×5 | 5×10 | 10×10 | |
|---|---|---|---|
Average storage facility Holtsville, NY | $76 | $119 | $205 |
Neighbor 18 storage spaces nearby | |||
Extra Space Storage Holtsville, NY (1 miles) | $75 | $130 | $212 |
U-Haul Moving & Storage Of Medford Medford, NY (3 miles) | $75 | $140 | $240 |
Public Storage Patchogue, NY (3 miles) | $69 | $105 | $215 |
Storage for Rent in Holtsville, NY
Select storage type
What’s the best self storage option for you?
Compare the pros and cons of renting from various storage unit options, including drive-up and interior units
Drive-up Exterior Units
Enclosed drive-up storage units, like garages, have an outdoor entrance
78% of storage spaces in Holtsville have security cameras as an amenity provided by the host
Interior-Access Storage Units
Indoor spaces like vacant offices or residential rooms offer increased protection
In Holtsville, 78% of listings do not have stairs leading to the storage space, allowing for easy access
Vehicle Storage Units
Indoor storage units that allow vehicles provide protection over outdoor parking
Residential indoor parking in Holtsville is typically a similar price to surrounding areas
Alternative Self Storage Facilities near Holtsville
Despite the fact that traditional storage options are common in Holtsville, New York, Neighbor storage often has lower-priced, close by and secure self storage.
If you'd like information about self storage facilities nearby, reference the below facilities for more details:
Need self storage in Holtsville?
Neighbor is the world’s largest storage marketplace. Call for rates or search online for the cheapest, closest, and safest storage units.
(844) 448-0855