Self storage units in Oyster Bay, NY

Self storage units in Oyster Bay, NY

60 locations available

12×8 Bedroom in Melville, NY near Bioscience Park Dr
12×8 Bedroom in Melville, NY near Bioscience Park Dr 2
12×8 Bedroom in Melville, NY near Bioscience Park Dr 3

Bedroom

12×8

Melville, NY

5.0 mi

Near Bioscience Park Dr

5.0

7 months rented

$129

per month

20×10 Attic in Melville, NY near Bioscience Park Dr
20×10 Attic in Melville, NY near Bioscience Park Dr 2
20×10 Attic in Melville, NY near Bioscience Park Dr 3

Attic

20×10

Melville, NY

5.0 mi

Near Bioscience Park Dr

5.0

7 months rented

$129

per month

22×12 Basement in Levittown, NY near 352 Kensington la
22×12 Basement in Levittown, NY near 352 Kensington la 2
22×12 Basement in Levittown, NY near 352 Kensington la 3

Basement

22×12

Levittown, NY

4.3 mi

Near 352 Kensington la

5.0

10 months rented

Looking for a secure and private space to store your belongings?

50% off1st month

$239

per month

8×4 Shed in Williamsbridge, NY near 776 Bartholdi St

Shed

8×4

Williamsbridge, NY

19.3 mi

Near 776 Bartholdi St

5.0

17 months rented

$35

per month

33×11 Basement in Bethpage, NY near 98 Cherry Ave
33×11 Basement in Bethpage, NY near 98 Cherry Ave 2
33×11 Basement in Bethpage, NY near 98 Cherry Ave 3

Basement

33×11

Bethpage, NY

3.5 mi

Near 98 Cherry Ave

5.0

17 months rented

50% off1st month

$285

per month

6×3 Closet in Albertson, NY near 108 Meldon Ave
6×3 Closet in Albertson, NY near 108 Meldon Ave 2

Closet

6×3

Albertson, NY

7.2 mi

Near 108 Meldon Ave

4.5

25 months rented

50% off1st month

$75

per month

20×10 Basement in Woodbury, NY near 4 Meadow Ln
20×10 Basement in Woodbury, NY near 4 Meadow Ln 2
20×10 Basement in Woodbury, NY near 4 Meadow Ln 3

Basement

20×10

Woodbury, NY

1.8 mi

Near 4 Meadow Ln

50% off1st month

$147

per month

26×15 Basement in Merrick, NY near Meadowbrook State Pkwy
26×15 Basement in Merrick, NY near Meadowbrook State Pkwy 2
26×15 Basement in Merrick, NY near Meadowbrook State Pkwy 3

Basement

26×15

Merrick, NY

7.9 mi

Near Meadowbrook State Pkwy

5.0

35 months rented

50% off1st month

$300

per month

20×10 Shed in Roosevelt, NY near 13 John St
20×10 Shed in Roosevelt, NY near 13 John St 2
20×10 Shed in Roosevelt, NY near 13 John St 3

Shed

20×10

Roosevelt, NY

8.3 mi

Near 13 John St

5.0

9 months rented

$171

per month

6×4 Closet in Rosedale, NY near 148-68 262nd Pl
6×4 Closet in Rosedale, NY near 148-68 262nd Pl 2
6×4 Closet in Rosedale, NY near 148-68 262nd Pl 3

Closet

6×4

Rosedale, NY

15.0 mi

Near 148-68 262nd Pl

50% off1st month

$39

per month

40×8 Shipping Container in Centereach, NY near 216 W Hills Rd

Shipping Container

40×8

Centereach, NY

5.8 mi

Near 216 W Hills Rd

$360

per month

Top Host

15×4 Shed in Jamaica, NY near 751 Lincoln Ave
15×4 Shed in Jamaica, NY near 751 Lincoln Ave 2
15×4 Shed in Jamaica, NY near 751 Lincoln Ave 3

Shed

15×4

Jamaica, NY

19.9 mi

Near 751 Lincoln Ave

4.9

112 months rented

Open shed for personal use with shade to prevent summer heat.

$80

per month

30×10 Garage in Deer Park, NY near August Rd
30×10 Garage in Deer Park, NY near August Rd 2
30×10 Garage in Deer Park, NY near August Rd 3

Garage

30×10

Deer Park, NY

9.0 mi

Near August Rd

4 months rented

$178

per month

20×7 Storage space in Jamaica, NY near 135 Dr

Storage space

20×7

Jamaica, NY

19.2 mi

Near 135 Dr

5.0

38 months rented

$103

per month

20×7 Attic in Lindenhurst, NY near 137 Inlet Dr
20×7 Attic in Lindenhurst, NY near 137 Inlet Dr 2
20×7 Attic in Lindenhurst, NY near 137 Inlet Dr 3

Attic

20×7

Lindenhurst, NY

10.9 mi

Near 137 Inlet Dr

50% off1st month

$95

per month

See all 60 storage options in Oyster Bay

Neighbor reviews near Oyster Bay, New York

4.9 (1,639 reviews)

Based on 1,639 verified reviews, renters rated Neighbor's service for finding self storage units in Oyster Bay 4.9 out of 5 on average

O

Otto H.

-

Dedham, MA

Mar 22, 2022

Verified Review

will rent storage again

A

Alicia W.

-

Clinton Hill, NY

Sep 19, 2020

Verified Review

profile

Arlene C.

-

East New York, NY

Jul 4, 2023

Verified Review

H

Hyun S.

-

Jamaica, NY

Feb 25, 2024

Verified Review

J

Jessi A.

-

Jamaica, NY

May 20, 2024

Verified Review

profile

Erin R.

-

New York, NY

Nov 15, 2022

Verified Review

Now showing 1-6 of 1,639 reviews for Oyster Bay, NY

Closest units to my location
  • Search your zip code:

    • 11547
    • 11804
    • 11545
    • 11560
    • 11771
    • 11548
    • 11714
    • 11709
    • 11758
    • 11737
    • 11732
    • 11765
    • 11568
    • 11762
    • 11579
    • 11773
    • 11791
    • 11797
    • 11735
    • 11753

Not affiliated with Neighbor

Men On The Move Self Storage in Woodbury, NY

Men On The Move Self Storage

Woodbury, NY

1.6 mi

150 Crossways Park Dr W Woodbury, NY

4.9

Pros: clean and organized facility, helpful and friendly staff, easy and quick check-in process, safe and comfortable environmentCons: security guard coverage limited to 9 pm, some outdoor units prone to water leaks

starting at

$51

per month

Not affiliated with Neighbor

Public Storage in Hicksville, NY

Public Storage

Hicksville, NY

1.7 mi

40 E Old Country Rd Hicksville, NY

starting at

$84

per month

Not affiliated with Neighbor

Public Storage in Hicksville, NY

Public Storage

Hicksville, NY

1.8 mi

800 S Oyster Bay Rd Hicksville, NY

starting at

$45

per month

Not affiliated with Neighbor

Syosset Self-Storage in Syosset, NY

Syosset Self-Storage

Syosset, NY

1.8 mi

475 Underhill Blvd Syosset, NY

4.8

Pros: clean and well-maintained facility, reasonable and competitive prices, friendly and helpful staff, varied unit sizes available, user-friendly storage experience

starting at

$75

per month

View all listings

Cheap prices: Starting at $45

    Not affiliated with Neighbor

    Life Storage - Garden City in Garden City, NY

    Life Storage - Garden City

    Garden City, NY

    6.4 mi

    1 South St Garden City, NY

    Pros: reasonable pricing for storage units, clean and well-maintained facility, secure environment for stored items, efficient and courteous staff

    starting at

    $45

    per month

    Not affiliated with Neighbor

    Public Storage in Melville, NY

    Public Storage

    Melville, NY

    4.8 mi

    965 Walt Whitman Rd Melville, NY

    Pros: clean and well-maintained facility, secure location with key access, wide hallways for easy accessCons: regular price increases issued, limited staff onsite during weekends

    starting at

    $48

    per month

    Not affiliated with Neighbor

    CubeSmart Self Storage in Bethpage, NY

    CubeSmart Self Storage

    Bethpage, NY

    2.3 mi

    909 Stewart Ave Bethpage, NY

    4.8

    Pros: facility is very clean and organized., some staff are courteous and helpful., move in process is clear and easy., units available in various sizes.Cons: price increases happen every few months., some staff are unhelpful or rude., visible moisture issues in certain areas., incidents of break-ins and poor security., residents living in storage units spotted.

    starting at

    $60

    per month

    Not affiliated with Neighbor

    Safeguard Self Storage in Plainview, NY

    Safeguard Self Storage

    Plainview, NY

    3.0 mi

    1522 Old Country Rd Plainview, NY

    4.9

    Pros: clean and well-maintained facility, friendly and helpful staff, secure and safe environment, easy access and efficient processCons: poor communication during emergencies, restroom access may be restricted

    starting at

    $63

    per month

    View all listings

    Larger units: 10x15 and above

      Not affiliated with Neighbor

      Extra Space Storage in Plainview, NY

      Extra Space Storage

      Plainview, NY

      2.0 mi

      151 Sunnyside Blvd Plainview, NY

      4.9

      Pros: regularly maintained and clean facility., highly secure with good lighting., easy access to loading docks., supplies available for boxing/packaging.Cons: sudden and significant price increases., reports of bait and switch pricing.

      starting at

      $298

      per month

      20×10 Garage in Farmingdale, NY

      Garage

      20×10

      Farmingdale, NY

      5.5 mi

      Near 610 Broad Hollow Rd

      Climate Controlled

      Smoke Free

      $495

      per month

      Not affiliated with Neighbor

      Extra Space Storage in Hicksville, NY

      Extra Space Storage

      Hicksville, NY

      2.7 mi

      789 S Broadway Hicksville, NY

      4.9

      Pros: friendly and helpful staff, clean storage units, easy and smooth transition

      starting at

      $370

      per month

      Not affiliated with Neighbor

      Life Storage in Hicksville, NY

      Life Storage

      Hicksville, NY

      1.9 mi

      65 W John St Hicksville, NY

      Pros: cleanliness is consistently praised by users., staff is friendly and attentive., facility open 24/7 for convenience., secure environment for stored items.

      starting at

      $318

      per month

      View all listings

      Medium sized units: 5x5 - 10x15

        Not affiliated with Neighbor

        Public Storage in Syosset, NY

        Public Storage

        Syosset, NY

        1.5 mi

        18 W Jericho Tpke Syosset, NY

        starting at

        $49

        per month

        View all listings

        Drive-up access with your vehicle

          Not affiliated with Neighbor

          StorQuest Self Storage in Westbury, NY

          StorQuest Self Storage

          Westbury, NY

          4.7 mi

          401 Railroad Ave Westbury, NY

          4.9

          Pros: convenient location next to train, very clean storage facility

          starting at

          $90

          per month

          Not affiliated with Neighbor

          Public Storage in Farmingdale, NY

          Public Storage

          Farmingdale, NY

          6.5 mi

          305 Del Dr Farmingdale, NY

          Pros: facility is very clean and tidy, fair and competitive pricing, courteous and helpful staff, ground floor units available for easy accessCons: issues with climate control ruining personal items, rodent infestations cause significant damage, unreliable elevator and cart access, managers are often unresponsive and inaccessible

          starting at

          $71

          per month

          Not affiliated with Neighbor

          Prime Storage in Farmingdale, NY

          Prime Storage

          Farmingdale, NY

          5.3 mi

          2091 New Hwy Farmingdale, NY

          4.4

          Pros: clean and well-maintained facility, easy sign-up and reservation processCons: broken elevator causing inconvenience, moving costs increase for certain unit changes, no garbage disposal for customers

          starting at

          $94

          per month

          Not affiliated with Neighbor

          Public Storage in Garden City, NY

          Public Storage

          Garden City, NY

          5.9 mi

          1055 Stewart Ave Garden City, NY

          Pros: facility is clean and well-kept, conveniently located storage units, staff is extremely helpfulCons: loading from back of building only

          starting at

          $77

          per month

          View all listings

          Find nearby storage locations

          Jericho, New York (2 mi)
          Plainview, New York (2 mi)
          Syosset, New York (2 mi)
          Hicksville, New York (2 mi)
          Bethpage, New York (3 mi)
          New Cassel, New York (4 mi)
          Old Bethpage, New York (4 mi)
          Salisbury, New York (4 mi)
          West Hills, New York (4 mi)
          Levittown, New York (4 mi)

          How Neighbor compares to traditional storage facilities

          badge w/star

          Neighbor

          Traditional facilities

          Wide variety of sizes

          Lowest prices

          Highest safety rating

          Protection plans

          Nationwide availability

          Verified hosts

          Manage rental online

          Storage facility cost comparison

          10×20

          10×30

          Average storage facility

          Oyster Bay, NY

          $436

          $730

          Neighbor

          60 storage spaces nearby

          Public Storage

          Syosset, NY (2 miles)

          $386

          --

          Men On The Move Self Storage

          Woodbury, NY (2 miles)

          $422

          --

          Public Storage

          Hicksville, NY (2 miles)

          $417

          $666

          Storage for Rent in Oyster Bay, NY

          Select storage type

          self storage
          RV storage
          truck parking
          boat storage
          garages

          What’s the best self storage option for you?

          Compare the pros and cons of renting from various storage unit options, including drive-up and interior units

          Drive-up Exterior Units
          open view of an empty garage

          Enclosed drive-up storage units, like garages, have an outdoor entrance

          None of the currently available storage spaces in Oyster Bay have security cameras as an amenity

          Find drive-up storage
          Interior-Access Storage Units
          row of indoor storage lockers

          Indoor spaces like vacant offices or residential rooms offer increased protection

          In Oyster Bay, 50% of listings do not have stairs leading to the storage space, allowing for easy access

          Find indoor storage units
          Vehicle Storage Units
          view of a half-closed garage with a car inside

          Indoor storage units that allow vehicles provide protection over outdoor parking

          Residential indoor parking in Oyster Bay is typically a similar price to surrounding areas

          Find car storage units

          Alternative Self Storage Facilities near Oyster Bay

          Oyster Bay offers many different traditional facilities for self storage. Traditional self storage, however, are often more expensive, less safe, and typically farther way than Neighbor units.

          See the facilities below for information:

          Men On The Move Self Storage (1.6 miles)

          150 Crossways Park Dr W Woodbury, NY

          Extra Space Storage (2 miles)

          151 Sunnyside Blvd Plainview, NY

          Extra Space Storage (2.7 miles)

          789 S Broadway Hicksville, NY

          Store Space Self Storage (7.5 miles)

          30 Sea Cliff Ave Glen Cove, NY

          Safeguard Self Storage (3 miles)

          1522 Old Country Rd Plainview, NY

          Life Storage (1.9 miles)

          65 W John St Hicksville, NY

          Public Storage (1.5 miles)

          18 W Jericho Tpke Syosset, NY

          Public Storage (4.8 miles)

          965 Walt Whitman Rd Melville, NY

          Storage Quarters: Paper Shredding and Scanning, Self-Storage (6 miles)

          999 Stewart Ave Garden City, NY

          Public Storage (1.8 miles)

          800 S Oyster Bay Rd Hicksville, NY

          Life Storage - Garden City (6.4 miles)

          1 South St Garden City, NY

          Public Storage (1.7 miles)

          40 E Old Country Rd Hicksville, NY

          CubeSmart Self Storage (5.1 miles)

          2087 Hempstead Tpke East Meadow, NY

          Life Storage - East Meadow (5.8 miles)

          1640 Hempstead Tpke East Meadow, NY

          Extra Space Storage (10.1 miles)

          80 Mill Rd Freeport, NY

          Need self storage in Oyster Bay?

          Neighbor is the world’s largest storage marketplace. Call for rates or search online for the cheapest, closest, and safest storage units.

          (844) 448-0855