Self storage units in Oyster Bay, NY

Recommended

Best price, quality and distance

Closest to me

Enter your zip for nearby units

Cheap prices

Storage units as low as $90/mo

Large units

Large bedroom size; 10x15 & up

Medium units

Bedroom size; 5x5 to 10x15

Small units

Closet size; 5x5 and smaller

101 spaces near Oyster Bay

Shed

20’ × 10’

5.0

Huntington Station, NY

5 mi

near Bioscience Park Dr

Smoke Free

Private Entrance

Security Camera

No Stairs

Locked Area

$85/ mo

Basement

20’ × 10’

Woodbury, NY

1.8 mi

near 4 Meadow Ln

Smoke Free

Private Space

Pet Free

No Stairs

Climate Controlled

$73.50

1st month

$147/ mo

Basement

33’ × 11’

5.0

Bethpage, NY

3.5 mi

near 98 Cherry Ave

Climate Controlled

Private Space

Smoke Detectors

$142.50

1st month

$285/ mo

Life Storage

6 sizes available

65 W John St Hicksville, NY

1.9 mi

similarly priced

Pros:

Cleanliness is consistently praised by users.
Staff is friendly and attentive.
Facility open 24/7 for convenience.
Secure environment for stored items.

5'×5'

starting at

$62/ mo

10'×5'

starting at

$130/ mo

10'×15'

starting at

$295/ mo

15'×5'

starting at

$149/ mo

15'×7'

starting at

$205/ mo

15'×9'

starting at

$244/ mo

5'×5' starting at

$62

Extra Space Storage

8 sizes available

4.9

151 Sunnyside Blvd Plainview, NY

2 mi

similarly priced

Pros:

Regularly maintained and clean facility.
Highly secure with good lighting.
Easy access to loading docks.
Supplies available for boxing/packaging.

Cons:

Sudden and significant price increases.
Reports of bait and switch pricing.

4'×5'

starting at

$68/ mo

5'×5'

starting at

$81/ mo

10'×5'

starting at

$115/ mo

10'×8'

starting at

$177/ mo

10'×10'

starting at

$246/ mo

10'×15'

starting at

$305/ mo

15'×5'

starting at

$196/ mo

15'×8'

starting at

$256/ mo

4'×5' starting at

$68

Storage space

35’ × 18’

Levittown, NY

3.6 mi

near 14 Pelican Rd

Security Camera

No Stairs

$300/ mo

StorQuest Self Storage

10 sizes available

4.9

401 Railroad Ave Westbury, NY

4.7 mi

2.3x more expensive

Pros:

Convenient location next to train
Very clean storage facility

5'×5'

starting at

$103/ mo

5'×6'

starting at

$116/ mo

5'×7'

starting at

$90/ mo

10'×5'

starting at

$202/ mo

10'×6'

starting at

$306/ mo

10'×7'

starting at

$244/ mo

10'×10'

starting at

$402/ mo

10'×12'

starting at

$345/ mo

10'×15'

starting at

$501/ mo

10'×20'

starting at

$727/ mo

5'×7' starting at

$90

CubeSmart Self Storage

9 sizes available

4.8

909 Stewart Ave Bethpage, NY

2.3 mi

2.3x more expensive

Pros:

Facility is very clean and organized.
Some staff are courteous and helpful.
Move in process is clear and easy.
Units available in various sizes.

Cons:

Price increases happen every few months.
Some staff are unhelpful or rude.
Visible moisture issues in certain areas.
Incidents of break-ins and poor security.
Residents living in storage units spotted.

5'×5'

starting at

$64/ mo

6'×7'

starting at

$129/ mo

10'×5'

starting at

$111/ mo

10'×7'

starting at

$143/ mo

10'×10'

starting at

$300/ mo

10'×15'

starting at

$585/ mo

10'×20'

starting at

$651/ mo

10'×24'

starting at

$652/ mo

12'×7'

starting at

$199/ mo

10'×5' starting at

$111

Basement

22’ × 12’

5.0

Levittown, NY

4.3 mi

near 352 Kensington la

Security Camera

Smoke Detectors

Private Entrance

Looking for a secure and private space to store your belongings?

$122.50

1st month

$245/ mo

Shipping Container

40’ × 8’

Centereach, NY

5.8 mi

near 216 W Hills Rd

Security Camera

Private Space

$360/ mo

Garage

20’ × 10’

Farmingdale, NY

5.5 mi

near 610 Broad Hollow Rd

Climate Controlled

Smoke Free

Smoke Detectors

Private Entrance

Pet Free

$495/ mo

Extra Space Storage

8 sizes available

4.9

789 S Broadway Hicksville, NY

2.7 mi

96% more expensive

Pros:

Friendly and helpful staff
Clean storage units
Easy and smooth transition

5'×5'

starting at

$62/ mo

10'×5'

starting at

$98/ mo

10'×10'

starting at

$189/ mo

10'×15'

starting at

$317/ mo

10'×20'

starting at

$419/ mo

10'×25'

starting at

$455/ mo

10'×30'

starting at

$520/ mo

15'×5'

starting at

$141/ mo

10'×30' starting at

$520

Life Storage

30 sizes available

1 South St Garden City, NY

6.4 mi

65% more expensive

Pros:

Reasonable pricing for storage units
Clean and well-maintained facility
Secure environment for stored items
Efficient and courteous staff

4'×5'

starting at

$43/ mo

4'×9'

starting at

$69/ mo

5'×5'

starting at

$47/ mo

5'×6'

starting at

$70/ mo

5'×9'

starting at

$97/ mo

9'×21'

starting at

$312/ mo

10'×4'

starting at

$75/ mo

10'×5'

starting at

$105/ mo

10'×6'

starting at

$103/ mo

10'×9'

starting at

$166/ mo

10'×10'

starting at

$190/ mo

10'×11'

starting at

$165/ mo

10'×12'

starting at

$177/ mo

10'×14'

starting at

$246/ mo

10'×15'

starting at

$221/ mo

10'×16'

starting at

$233/ mo

10'×18'

starting at

$255/ mo

10'×19'

starting at

$266/ mo

10'×20'

starting at

$326/ mo

10'×21'

starting at

$288/ mo

10'×25'

starting at

$387/ mo

11'×4'

starting at

$81/ mo

11'×5'

starting at

$96/ mo

11'×20'

starting at

$309/ mo

14'×9'

starting at

$194/ mo

14'×20'

starting at

$309/ mo

14'×24'

starting at

$416/ mo

15'×20'

starting at

$380/ mo

16'×9'

starting at

$214/ mo

20'×9'

starting at

$255/ mo

14'×9' starting at

$194

Prime Storage

10 sizes available

4.4

2091 New Hwy Farmingdale, NY

5.3 mi

80% more expensive

Pros:

Clean and well-maintained facility
Easy sign-up and reservation process

Cons:

Broken elevator causing inconvenience
Moving costs increase for certain unit changes
No garbage disposal for customers

5'×5'

starting at

$94/ mo

5'×6'

starting at

$104/ mo

10'×5'

starting at

$136/ mo

10'×10'

starting at

$333/ mo

10'×15'

starting at

$340/ mo

10'×20'

starting at

$641/ mo

10'×25'

starting at

$637/ mo

10'×30'

starting at

$668/ mo

12'×20'

starting at

$191/ mo

15'×5'

starting at

$174/ mo

10'×5' starting at

$136

Extra Space Storage

10 sizes available

4.9

380 Oakwood Rd Huntington Station, NY

5.4 mi

similarly priced

Pros:

Excellent customer service noted by multiple users
Clean and maintained facility with available carts
Easy and quick leasing process
Secure storage noted by multiple users

Cons:

Rates increase frequently without notice
Facility layout is confusing initially
Insufficient security in some parking areas

5'×5'

starting at

$159/ mo

5'×7'

starting at

$183/ mo

10'×5'

starting at

$241/ mo

10'×8'

starting at

$360/ mo

10'×10'

starting at

$410/ mo

10'×11'

starting at

$347/ mo

10'×12'

starting at

$348/ mo

12'×8'

starting at

$309/ mo

15'×7'

starting at

$410/ mo

15'×8'

starting at

$363/ mo

5'×7' starting at

$183

Life Storage

5 sizes available

1 Executive Blvd Farmingdale, NY

6.3 mi

2.4x more expensive

5'×5'

starting at

$84/ mo

10'×15'

starting at

$393/ mo

15'×7'

starting at

$223/ mo

15'×9'

starting at

$363/ mo

15'×25'

starting at

$858/ mo

5'×5' starting at

$84

Find nearby storage locations

Jericho, New York (2 mi)

Plainview, New York (2 mi)

Syosset, New York (2 mi)

Hicksville, New York (2 mi)

Bethpage, New York (3 mi)

New Cassel, New York (4 mi)

Old Bethpage, New York (4 mi)

Salisbury, New York (4 mi)

West Hills, New York (4 mi)

Levittown, New York (4 mi)

How Neighbor compares to traditional storage facilities

Neighbor

Traditional facilities

Wide variety of sizes

Lowest prices

Highest safety rating

Protection plans

Nationwide availability

Verified hosts

Manage rental online

View reviews for Neighbor

Storage facility cost comparison

	10×20	10×30	10×40
Average storage facility Oyster Bay, NY	$440	$612	$800
Neighbor 62 storage spaces nearby	$147	$285	$300
Life Storage Hicksville, NY (2 miles)	--	--	--
Extra Space Storage Plainview, NY (2 miles)	--	--	--
CubeSmart Self Storage Plainview, NY (2 miles)	$376	$901	--

Storage for Rent in Oyster Bay, NY

Select storage type

What’s the best self storage option for you?

Compare the pros and cons of renting from various storage unit options, including drive-up and interior units

Drive-up Exterior Units

Enclosed drive-up storage units, like garages, have an outdoor entrance

33% of storage spaces in Oyster Bay have security cameras as an amenity provided by the host

Find drive-up storage

Interior-Access Storage Units

Indoor spaces like vacant offices or residential rooms offer increased protection

In Oyster Bay, 66% of listings do not have stairs leading to the storage space, allowing for easy access

Find indoor storage units

Vehicle Storage Units

view of a half-closed garage with a car inside

Indoor storage units that allow vehicles provide protection over outdoor parking

Residential indoor parking in Oyster Bay is typically a similar price to surrounding areas

Find car storage units

Alternative Self Storage Facilities near Oyster Bay

Oyster Bay offers many different traditional facilities for self storage. Traditional self storage, however, are often more expensive, less safe, and typically farther way than Neighbor units.

See the facilities below for information:

Extra Space Storage (2.7 miles)

789 S Broadway Hicksville, NY

Extra Space Storage (2 miles)

151 Sunnyside Blvd Plainview, NY

Store Space Self Storage (7.5 miles)

30 Sea Cliff Ave Glen Cove, NY

Extra Space Storage (10.1 miles)

80 Mill Rd Freeport, NY

CubeSmart Self Storage (2.2 miles)

150 Fairchild Ave Plainview, NY

Extra Space Storage (11.5 miles)