Self storage units in Oyster Bay, NY

101 spaces near Oyster Bay

    20 x 10 Shed in Huntington Station, New York Bioscience Park Dr, Melville, NY 11747, United States

    Shed


    20’ × 10

    5.0

    Huntington Station, NY

    5 mi

    near Bioscience Park Dr

    Smoke Free

    Private Entrance

    Security Camera

    $85/ mo


    20 x 10 Basement in Woodbury, New York 4 Meadow Ln, Syosset, NY 11791-4125, United States

    Basement


    20’ × 10

    Woodbury, NY

    1.8 mi

    near 4 Meadow Ln

    Smoke Free

    Private Space

    Pet Free

    $73.50

      1st month

    $147/ mo


    33 x 11 Basement in Bethpage, New York 98 Cherry Ave, Bethpage, NY 11714-1501, United States

    Basement


    33’ × 11

    5.0

    Bethpage, NY

    3.5 mi

    near 98 Cherry Ave

    Climate Controlled

    Private Space

    Smoke Detectors

    $142.50

      1st month

    $285/ mo



      Street view of Life Storage

      Life Storage

      6 sizes available

      65 W John St Hicksville, NY

      1.9 mi

      similarly priced

      Pros:

      • Cleanliness is consistently praised by users.

      • Staff is friendly and attentive.

      • Facility open 24/7 for convenience.

      • Secure environment for stored items.

        5'×5'

        starting at

         

        $62/ mo

        10'×5'

        starting at

         

        $130/ mo

        10'×15'

        starting at

         

        $295/ mo

        15'×5'

        starting at

         

        $149/ mo

        15'×7'

        starting at

         

        $205/ mo

        15'×9'

        starting at

         

        $244/ mo

        5'×5' starting at

        $62


        Street view of Extra Space Storage

        Extra Space Storage

        8 sizes available

        4.9

        151 Sunnyside Blvd Plainview, NY

        2 mi

        similarly priced

        Pros:

        • Regularly maintained and clean facility.

        • Highly secure with good lighting.

        • Easy access to loading docks.

        • Supplies available for boxing/packaging.

        Cons:

        • Sudden and significant price increases.

        • Reports of bait and switch pricing.

        4'×5'

        starting at

         

        $68/ mo

        5'×5'

        starting at

         

        $81/ mo

        10'×5'

        starting at

         

        $115/ mo

        10'×8'

        starting at

         

        $177/ mo

        10'×10'

        starting at

         

        $246/ mo

        10'×15'

        starting at

         

        $305/ mo

        15'×5'

        starting at

         

        $196/ mo

        15'×8'

        starting at

         

        $256/ mo

        4'×5' starting at

        $68


        35 x 18 Storage space in Levittown, New York 14 Pelican Rd, Levittown, NY 11756-3202, United States

        Storage space


        35’ × 18

        Levittown, NY

        3.6 mi

        near 14 Pelican Rd

        Security Camera

        No Stairs

        $300/ mo


          Street view of StorQuest Self Storage

          StorQuest Self Storage

          10 sizes available

          4.9

          401 Railroad Ave Westbury, NY

          4.7 mi

          2.3x more expensive

          Pros:

          • Convenient location next to train

          • Very clean storage facility

            5'×5'

            starting at

             

            $103/ mo

            5'×6'

            starting at

             

            $116/ mo

            5'×7'

            starting at

             

            $90/ mo

            10'×5'

            starting at

             

            $202/ mo

            10'×6'

            starting at

             

            $306/ mo

            10'×7'

            starting at

             

            $244/ mo

            10'×10'

            starting at

             

            $402/ mo

            10'×12'

            starting at

             

            $345/ mo

            10'×15'

            starting at

             

            $501/ mo

            10'×20'

            starting at

             

            $727/ mo

            5'×7' starting at

            $90


            Street view of CubeSmart Self Storage

            CubeSmart Self Storage

            9 sizes available

            4.8

            909 Stewart Ave Bethpage, NY

            2.3 mi

            2.3x more expensive

            Pros:

            • Facility is very clean and organized.

            • Some staff are courteous and helpful.

            • Move in process is clear and easy.

            • Units available in various sizes.

            Cons:

            • Price increases happen every few months.

            • Some staff are unhelpful or rude.

            • Visible moisture issues in certain areas.

            • Incidents of break-ins and poor security.

            • Residents living in storage units spotted.

            5'×5'

            starting at

             

            $64/ mo

            6'×7'

            starting at

             

            $129/ mo

            10'×5'

            starting at

             

            $111/ mo

            10'×7'

            starting at

             

            $143/ mo

            10'×10'

            starting at

             

            $300/ mo

            10'×15'

            starting at

             

            $585/ mo

            10'×20'

            starting at

             

            $651/ mo

            10'×24'

            starting at

             

            $652/ mo

            12'×7'

            starting at

             

            $199/ mo

            10'×5' starting at

            $111


            22 x 12 Basement in Levittown, New York 352 Kensington la, Bethpage, NY 11714, United States

            Basement


            22’ × 12

            5.0

            Levittown, NY

            4.3 mi

            near 352 Kensington la

            Security Camera

            Smoke Detectors

            Private Entrance

            Looking for a secure and private space to store your belongings?

            $122.50

              1st month

            $245/ mo


              40 x 8 Shipping Container in Centereach, New York 216 W Hills Rd, Huntington Station, NY 11746-3143, United States

              Shipping Container


              40’ × 8

              Centereach, NY

              5.8 mi

              near 216 W Hills Rd

              Security Camera

              Private Space

              $360/ mo


              20 x 10 Garage in Farmingdale, New York 610 Broad Hollow Rd, Melville, NY 11747, United States

              Garage


              20’ × 10

              Farmingdale, NY

              5.5 mi

              near 610 Broad Hollow Rd

              Climate Controlled

              Smoke Free

              Smoke Detectors

              $495/ mo


              Street view of Extra Space Storage

              Extra Space Storage

              8 sizes available

              4.9

              789 S Broadway Hicksville, NY

              2.7 mi

              96% more expensive

              Pros:

              • Friendly and helpful staff

              • Clean storage units

              • Easy and smooth transition

                5'×5'

                starting at

                 

                $62/ mo

                10'×5'

                starting at

                 

                $98/ mo

                10'×10'

                starting at

                 

                $189/ mo

                10'×15'

                starting at

                 

                $317/ mo

                10'×20'

                starting at

                 

                $419/ mo

                10'×25'

                starting at

                 

                $455/ mo

                10'×30'

                starting at

                 

                $520/ mo

                15'×5'

                starting at

                 

                $141/ mo

                10'×30' starting at

                $520


                  Street view of Life Storage - Garden City

                  Life Storage

                  30 sizes available

                  1 South St Garden City, NY

                  6.4 mi

                  65% more expensive

                  Pros:

                  • Reasonable pricing for storage units

                  • Clean and well-maintained facility

                  • Secure environment for stored items

                  • Efficient and courteous staff

                    4'×5'

                    starting at

                     

                    $43/ mo

                    4'×9'

                    starting at

                     

                    $69/ mo

                    5'×5'

                    starting at

                     

                    $47/ mo

                    5'×6'

                    starting at

                     

                    $70/ mo

                    5'×9'

                    starting at

                     

                    $97/ mo

                    9'×21'

                    starting at

                     

                    $312/ mo

                    10'×4'

                    starting at

                     

                    $75/ mo

                    10'×5'

                    starting at

                     

                    $105/ mo

                    10'×6'

                    starting at

                     

                    $103/ mo

                    10'×9'

                    starting at

                     

                    $166/ mo

                    10'×10'

                    starting at

                     

                    $190/ mo

                    10'×11'

                    starting at

                     

                    $165/ mo

                    10'×12'

                    starting at

                     

                    $177/ mo

                    10'×14'

                    starting at

                     

                    $246/ mo

                    10'×15'

                    starting at

                     

                    $221/ mo

                    10'×16'

                    starting at

                     

                    $233/ mo

                    10'×18'

                    starting at

                     

                    $255/ mo

                    10'×19'

                    starting at

                     

                    $266/ mo

                    10'×20'

                    starting at

                     

                    $326/ mo

                    10'×21'

                    starting at

                     

                    $288/ mo

                    10'×25'

                    starting at

                     

                    $387/ mo

                    11'×4'

                    starting at

                     

                    $81/ mo

                    11'×5'

                    starting at

                     

                    $96/ mo

                    11'×20'

                    starting at

                     

                    $309/ mo

                    14'×9'

                    starting at

                     

                    $194/ mo

                    14'×20'

                    starting at

                     

                    $309/ mo

                    14'×24'

                    starting at

                     

                    $416/ mo

                    15'×20'

                    starting at

                     

                    $380/ mo

                    16'×9'

                    starting at

                     

                    $214/ mo

                    20'×9'

                    starting at

                     

                    $255/ mo

                    14'×9' starting at

                    $194


                    Street view of Prime Storage

                    Prime Storage

                    10 sizes available

                    4.4

                    2091 New Hwy Farmingdale, NY

                    5.3 mi

                    80% more expensive

                    Pros:

                    • Clean and well-maintained facility

                    • Easy sign-up and reservation process

                    Cons:

                    • Broken elevator causing inconvenience

                    • Moving costs increase for certain unit changes

                    • No garbage disposal for customers

                    5'×5'

                    starting at

                     

                    $94/ mo

                    5'×6'

                    starting at

                     

                    $104/ mo

                    10'×5'

                    starting at

                     

                    $136/ mo

                    10'×10'

                    starting at

                     

                    $333/ mo

                    10'×15'

                    starting at

                     

                    $340/ mo

                    10'×20'

                    starting at

                     

                    $641/ mo

                    10'×25'

                    starting at

                     

                    $637/ mo

                    10'×30'

                    starting at

                     

                    $668/ mo

                    12'×20'

                    starting at

                     

                    $191/ mo

                    15'×5'

                    starting at

                     

                    $174/ mo

                    10'×5' starting at

                    $136


                    Street view of Extra Space Storage

                    Extra Space Storage

                    10 sizes available

                    4.9

                    380 Oakwood Rd Huntington Station, NY

                    5.4 mi

                    similarly priced

                    Pros:

                    • Excellent customer service noted by multiple users

                    • Clean and maintained facility with available carts

                    • Easy and quick leasing process

                    • Secure storage noted by multiple users

                    Cons:

                    • Rates increase frequently without notice

                    • Facility layout is confusing initially

                    • Insufficient security in some parking areas

                    5'×5'

                    starting at

                     

                    $159/ mo

                    5'×7'

                    starting at

                     

                    $183/ mo

                    10'×5'

                    starting at

                     

                    $241/ mo

                    10'×8'

                    starting at

                     

                    $360/ mo

                    10'×10'

                    starting at

                     

                    $410/ mo

                    10'×11'

                    starting at

                     

                    $347/ mo

                    10'×12'

                    starting at

                     

                    $348/ mo

                    12'×8'

                    starting at

                     

                    $309/ mo

                    15'×7'

                    starting at

                     

                    $410/ mo

                    15'×8'

                    starting at

                     

                    $363/ mo

                    5'×7' starting at

                    $183


                      Street view of Life Storage - Farmingdale

                      Life Storage

                      5 sizes available

                      1 Executive Blvd Farmingdale, NY

                      6.3 mi

                      2.4x more expensive

                      5'×5'

                      starting at

                       

                      $84/ mo

                      10'×15'

                      starting at

                       

                      $393/ mo

                      15'×7'

                      starting at

                       

                      $223/ mo

                      15'×9'

                      starting at

                       

                      $363/ mo

                      15'×25'

                      starting at

                       

                      $858/ mo

                      5'×5' starting at

                      $84


                      Find nearby storage locations

                      Jericho, New York (2 mi)
                      Plainview, New York (2 mi)
                      Syosset, New York (2 mi)
                      Hicksville, New York (2 mi)
                      Bethpage, New York (3 mi)
                      New Cassel, New York (4 mi)
                      Old Bethpage, New York (4 mi)
                      Salisbury, New York (4 mi)
                      West Hills, New York (4 mi)
                      Levittown, New York (4 mi)

                      How Neighbor compares to traditional storage facilities

                      badge w/star

                      Neighbor

                      Traditional facilities

                      Wide variety of sizes

                      Lowest prices

                      Highest safety rating

                      Protection plans

                      Nationwide availability

                      Verified hosts

                      Manage rental online

                      View reviews for Neighbor

                      Storage facility cost comparison

                      10×20

                      10×30

                      10×40

                      Average storage facility

                      Oyster Bay, NY

                      $440

                      $612

                      $800

                      Neighbor

                      62 storage spaces nearby

                      Life Storage

                      Hicksville, NY (2 miles)

                      --

                      --

                      --

                      Extra Space Storage

                      Plainview, NY (2 miles)

                      --

                      --

                      --

                      CubeSmart Self Storage

                      Plainview, NY (2 miles)

                      $376

                      $901

                      --

                      Storage for Rent in Oyster Bay, NY

                      Select storage type

                      self storage
                      boat storage
                      garages
                      RV storage
                      truck parking

                      What’s the best self storage option for you?

                      Compare the pros and cons of renting from various storage unit options, including drive-up and interior units

                      Drive-up Exterior Units
                      open view of an empty garage

                      Enclosed drive-up storage units, like garages, have an outdoor entrance

                      33% of storage spaces in Oyster Bay have security cameras as an amenity provided by the host

                      Find drive-up storage
                      Interior-Access Storage Units
                      row of indoor storage lockers

                      Indoor spaces like vacant offices or residential rooms offer increased protection

                      In Oyster Bay, 66% of listings do not have stairs leading to the storage space, allowing for easy access

                      Find indoor storage units
                      Vehicle Storage Units
                      view of a half-closed garage with a car inside

                      Indoor storage units that allow vehicles provide protection over outdoor parking

                      Residential indoor parking in Oyster Bay is typically a similar price to surrounding areas

                      Find car storage units

                      Alternative Self Storage Facilities near Oyster Bay

                      Oyster Bay offers many different traditional facilities for self storage. Traditional self storage, however, are often more expensive, less safe, and typically farther way than Neighbor units.

                      See the facilities below for information:

                      Extra Space Storage (2.7 miles)

                      789 S Broadway Hicksville, NY

                      Extra Space Storage (2 miles)

                      151 Sunnyside Blvd Plainview, NY

                      Store Space Self Storage (7.5 miles)

                      30 Sea Cliff Ave Glen Cove, NY

                      Extra Space Storage (10.1 miles)

                      80 Mill Rd Freeport, NY

                      CubeSmart Self Storage (2.2 miles)

                      150 Fairchild Ave Plainview, NY

                      Extra Space Storage (11.5 miles)

                      200 Express Dr S Brentwood, NY

                      Safeguard Self Storage (3 miles)

                      1522 Old Country Rd Plainview, NY

                      CubeSmart Self Storage (2.3 miles)

                      909 Stewart Ave Bethpage, NY

                      Life Storage (1.9 miles)

                      65 W John St Hicksville, NY

                      Life Storage - Garden City (6.4 miles)

                      1 South St Garden City, NY

                      Extra Space Storage (10.5 miles)

                      1251 Deer Park Ave North Babylon, NY

                      CubeSmart Self Storage (5.1 miles)

                      2087 Hempstead Tpke East Meadow, NY

                      Storage Post Self Storage (7.5 miles)

                      88 Hazel St Glen Cove, NY

                      Extra Space Storage (10.6 miles)

                      4057 Jericho Tpke East Northport, NY

                      Extra Space Storage (14.3 miles)

                      730 Old Willets Path Hauppauge, NY

                      Need self storage in Oyster Bay?

                      Neighbor is the world’s largest storage marketplace. Call for rates or search online for the cheapest, closest, and safest storage units.

                      (844) 448-0855