Car storage in Central Islip, NY
ft
Neighbor reviews near Central Islip, NY
5.0 (8,172 reviews)
Based on 8,172 verified reviews, renters rated Neighbor's service for finding car storage in Central Islip 5.0 out of 5 on average
Jennylee C.
-
Jamaica, NY
Mar 20, 2025
Verified Review
K
Khaalid A.
-
Brentwood, NY
Aug 18, 2024
Verified Review
James A.
-
Farmingville, NY
Aug 27, 2022
Verified Review
A
Aqeel A.
-
Elmont, NY
Feb 27, 2024
Verified Review
T
Tom A.
-
St James, NY
Mar 9, 2025
Verified Review
Now showing 1-5 of 8,172 reviews for Central Islip, NY
Cheap prices: Starting at $47
67% of spaces are Driveways with an average rate of $96.
50% of spaces offer a first month discount; lowest price is $75.
Driveways have the highest average rating of 5.0 across all types.
Storage space
20×10
Bridgeport, CT
26.3 mi
Near 52 Gregory St
5.0
Security Camera
No Stairs
$47
per month
Driveway
20×10
Milford, CT
29.1 mi
Near 20 Opal St
5.0
No Stairs
Private Space
50% off first month
$59
per month
Parking Lot
20×10
Milford, CT
31.3 mi
143 Cherry St Milford, Connecticut
4.7
Instant book
No Stairs
$65
per month
Unpaved Lot
20×10
East Haven, CT
35.6 mi
Near 727 Silver Sands Rd
5.0
Instant book
Security Camera
50% off first month
$70
per month
Parking Lot
17×8
Bridgeport, CT
26.1 mi
299 Wordin Ave Bridgeport, Connecticut
5.0
Attendant or Security
Keyless Entry
$74
per month
Driveway
20×10
Deer Park, NY
5.6 mi
65 E Jefryn Blvd Deer Park, New York
Instant book
$85
per month
Driveway
10×20
Central Islip, NY
0.4 mi
Near 9 Sunwood Cir
Security Camera
Private Space
$89
per month
Unpaved Lot
40×10
Deer Park, NY
6.3 mi
Near 92 Rhoda Ave
5.0
Locked Area
Security Camera
starting at
$89
per month
Driveway
20×10
New Haven, CT
38.2 mi
Near 1568 Ella T Grasso Blvd
5.0
Security Camera
Fenced Property
50% off first month
$89
per month
Parking Lot
15×8
Coram, NY
11.2 mi
550 Middle Country Road Coram, New York
5.0
Attendant or Security
Keyless Entry
$92
per month
Parking Lot
20×10
Medford, NY
12.7 mi
Near 43 David Overton Rd
5.0
Security Camera
$94
per month
Driveway
30×10
Central Islip, NY
1.2 mi
Near 70 Casement Ave
5.0
Private Space
50% off first month
$95
per month
Driveway
20×10
Commack, NY
4.4 mi
Near 25 Apple Ln
5.0
Keyless Entry
50% off first month
$95
per month
Parking Lot
16×8
Commack, NY
6.6 mi
5052 Jericho Turnpike Commack, New York
5.0
Keyless Entry
Private Entrance
$96
per month
Driveway
20×10
Brentwood, NY
3.9 mi
Near 93 Heartland Blvd
4.6
Security Camera
50% off first month
$98
per month
Parking Lot
10×20
Deer Park, NY
6.6 mi
Near 86 W 1st St
4.5
Locked Area
No Stairs
$99
per month
Parking Lot
20×10
Lake Ronkonkoma, NY
7.1 mi
821-835 Portion Rd Lake Ronkonkoma, New York
Instant book
$99
per month
Indoor or covered parking spaces
Garage
20×10
Nesconset, NY
4.8 mi
770 Nesconset Hwy Nesconset, New York
5.0
Keyless Entry
Private Entrance
$326
per month
Garage
30×10
Lake Ronkonkoma, NY
6.0 mi
363 Portion Road Lake Ronkonkoma, New York
5.0
Attendant or Security
Keyless Entry
"The property was tidy and the workers were sincere."－ Verified review
$289
per month
Garage
20×10
Patchogue, NY
8.5 mi
601 W Sunrise Highway Patchogue, New York
5.0
Attendant or Security
Keyless Entry
starting at
$198
per month
Parking Garage
20×10
Stamford, CT
25.0 mi
695 Atlantic St Stamford, Connecticut
5.0
Instant book
EV charging Available
Wheelchair Accessible
$150
per month
Garage
20×10
East Patchogue, NY
11.1 mi
Near 12 Beatrice Ct
4.7
Private Entrance
Locked Area
$110
per month
Parking Garage
20×10
Elmhurst, NY
35.5 mi
86-55 Queens Blvd Elmhurst, New York
4.6
Instant book
$175
per month
Parking Garage
18×9
New Rochelle, NY
31.4 mi
55 Clinton Pl New Rochelle, New York
4.6
Instant book
EV charging Available
Wheelchair Accessible
$125
per month
Parking Garage
20×10
Southside, NY
39.3 mi
40 Varet St Southside, New York
4.6
Instant book
Wheelchair Accessible
$225
per month
Parking Garage
20×10
Far Rockaway, NY
31.6 mi
1725 Village Ln Far Rockaway, New York
4.6
Instant book
Wheelchair Accessible
$149
per month
Parking Garage
18×9
White Plains, NY
33.8 mi
250 Main St White Plains, New York
4.6
Instant book
Wheelchair Accessible
$175
per month
Garage
20×10
Farmingville, NY
9.8 mi
951 HorseBlock Road Farmingville, New York
5.0
Keyless Entry
Private Entrance
$322
per month
Garage
30×10
West Babylon, NY
8.7 mi
821 Sunrise Hwy West Babylon, New York
5.0
Keyless Entry
Private Entrance
$477
per month
Top-rated: 4+ star reviews
83% of listings have an average rating of 5 stars.
42% of top rated listings include a camera feature for added security.
Average host response time is 56 minutes for top rated listings.
Parking Lot
16×8
Commack, NY
6.6 mi
5052 Jericho Turnpike Commack, New York
5.0
Keyless Entry
Private Entrance
$96
per month
Parking Lot
20×8
Patchogue, NY
8.5 mi
601 W Sunrise Highway Patchogue, New York
5.0
Attendant or Security
Keyless Entry
$131
per month
Parking Lot
15×8
Coram, NY
11.2 mi
550 Middle Country Road Coram, New York
5.0
Attendant or Security
Keyless Entry
$92
per month
Parking Lot
17×8
Bridgeport, CT
26.1 mi
299 Wordin Ave Bridgeport, Connecticut
5.0
Attendant or Security
Keyless Entry
$74
per month
Parking Lot
20×7
Miller Place, NY
16.2 mi
922 Route 25A Miller Place, New York
5.0
Attendant or Security
Keyless Entry
$102
per month
Parking Lot
17×8
Melville, NY
11.2 mi
965 Walt Whitman Road Melville, New York
5.0
Keyless Entry
Private Entrance
$228
per month
Garage
20×10
Farmingville, NY
9.8 mi
951 HorseBlock Road Farmingville, New York
5.0
Keyless Entry
Private Entrance
$322
per month
Garage
30×10
West Babylon, NY
8.7 mi
821 Sunrise Hwy West Babylon, New York
5.0
Keyless Entry
Private Entrance
$477
per month
Not affiliated with Neighbor
Extra Space Storage
Hauppauge, NY
3.0 mi
730 Old Willets Path Hauppauge, NY
4.9
Pros: excellent customer service with friendly staff, clean and secure facility, affordable rates for initial rental, convenient and quick rental processCons: rates increase regularly over time, some units are hard to find initially
starting at
$300
per month
Not affiliated with Neighbor
Extra Space Storage
East Northport, NY
7.7 mi
4057 Jericho Tpke East Northport, NY
4.9
Pros: easily accessible storage units, clean and well-lit facilities, highly knowledgeable and helpful staff, good value for clean units
starting at
$323
per month
Not affiliated with Neighbor
Extra Space Storage
Stamford, CT
26.5 mi
1934 W Main St Stamford, CT
4.9
Pros: customer service is consistently praised, facility is well-maintained and clean, range of storage options available
starting at
$509
per month
Not affiliated with Neighbor
CubeSmart Self Storage
North Babylon, NY
7.7 mi
240 Bay Shore Rd North Babylon, NY
4.8
Pros: friendly and helpful staff, clean and well-maintained facility, easy and smooth check-in process, reasonable and knowledgeable customer serviceCons: units prone to mold and water damage, presence of rat feces and traps, significant rent increases over time, charges full month despite early move-out
starting at
$387
per month
Not affiliated with Neighbor
iStorage Self Storage
Patchogue, NY
8.3 mi
257 Waverly Ave Patchogue, NY
4.7
Pros: friendly and helpful staff, good location, clean facility, affordable pricingCons: hidden fees (ratings support user perception)
starting at
$179
per month
Not affiliated with Neighbor
Metro Self Storage - Oakdale
Oakdale, NY
4.0 mi
4038 Sunrise Hwy Oakdale, NY
4.4
Pros: clean and well-maintained facility, reasonable and stable pricing, quick and efficient service, easy and local accessCons: online payment issues unresolved, terrible experience with climate control maintenance, private information divulgence recurring, break-ins and poor on-site supervision, unpragmatic desking inhibiting first impressions
starting at
$188
per month
Top Host
Driveway
20×10
Jamaica, NY
30.3 mi
Near 147-40 184th St
5.0
Keyless Entry
Fenced Property
50% off first month
$149
per month
Driveway
30×12
Jamaica, NY
30.9 mi
Near 150th Rd
5.0
Security Camera
$153
per month
Driveway
20×10
Jamaica, NY
30.3 mi
Near 226-03 137th Ave
5.0
Instant book
Security Camera
No Stairs
$130
per month
Parking Lot
20×10
New York, NY
37.8 mi
3976 10th Ave New York, New York
4.7
Instant book
Security Camera
Attendant or Security
$199
per month
Parking for multiple vehicles
Average driveway cost is $105; average response time is 13 hours.
50% of listings offer outdoor, uncovered storage; 20% have cameras.
Top host response within 12 minutes; 82% rated 5 stars.
Not affiliated with Neighbor
Extra Space Storage
Hauppauge, NY
3.0 mi
730 Old Willets Path Hauppauge, NY
4.9
Pros: excellent customer service with friendly staff, clean and secure facility, affordable rates for initial rental, convenient and quick rental processCons: rates increase regularly over time, some units are hard to find initially
starting at
$300
per month
Not affiliated with Neighbor
Metro Self Storage - Oakdale
Oakdale, NY
4.0 mi
4038 Sunrise Hwy Oakdale, NY
4.4
Pros: clean and well-maintained facility, reasonable and stable pricing, quick and efficient service, easy and local accessCons: online payment issues unresolved, terrible experience with climate control maintenance, private information divulgence recurring, break-ins and poor on-site supervision, unpragmatic desking inhibiting first impressions
starting at
$188
per month
Parking Lot
20×10
Deer Park, NY
5.7 mi
152 The Arches Cir Deer Park, New York
4.9
Security Camera
Private Space
starting at
$135
per month
Unpaved Lot
40×10
Deer Park, NY
6.3 mi
Near 92 Rhoda Ave
5.0
Locked Area
Security Camera
starting at
$89
per month
Not affiliated with Neighbor
Extra Space Storage
East Northport, NY
7.7 mi
4057 Jericho Tpke East Northport, NY
4.9
Pros: easily accessible storage units, clean and well-lit facilities, highly knowledgeable and helpful staff, good value for clean units
starting at
$323
per month
Unpaved Lot
20×10
St James, NY
6.1 mi
Near 10 Glenrich Dr
5.0
Private Space
Gravel parking lot right in front of my office.
starting at
$184
per month
Unpaved Lot
20×10
Brentwood, NY
3.8 mi
Near 93 Heartland Blvd
Fenced Property
Private Space
starting at
$275
per month
Garage
20×10
Patchogue, NY
8.5 mi
601 W Sunrise Highway Patchogue, New York
5.0
Attendant or Security
Keyless Entry
starting at
$198
per month
Not affiliated with Neighbor
iStorage Self Storage
Patchogue, NY
8.3 mi
257 Waverly Ave Patchogue, NY
4.7
Pros: friendly and helpful staff, good location, clean facility, affordable pricingCons: hidden fees (ratings support user perception)
starting at
$179
per month
Unpaved Lot
20×10
Yaphank, NY
15.3 mi
Near 252 River Rd
4.9
Instant book
Fenced Property
Gravel
starting at
$100
per month
Parking Lot
20×10
Ansonia, CT
38.4 mi
Near 200 Emmett Ave
5.0
Security Camera
No Stairs
50% off first month
starting at
$100
per month
Unpaved Lot
30×10
Medford, NY
10.8 mi
Near 1900 Medford Ave
5.0
Instant book
Security Camera
starting at
$180
per month
Not affiliated with Neighbor
CubeSmart Self Storage
North Babylon, NY
7.7 mi
240 Bay Shore Rd North Babylon, NY
4.8
Pros: friendly and helpful staff, clean and well-maintained facility, easy and smooth check-in process, reasonable and knowledgeable customer serviceCons: units prone to mold and water damage, presence of rat feces and traps, significant rent increases over time, charges full month despite early move-out
starting at
$387
per month
Top Host
Parking Lot
31×12
Branford, CT
39.0 mi
Near 52 Oak Ridge Rd
5.0
Electricity Available
50% off first month
$149
per month
Driveway
30×12
Jamaica, NY
30.9 mi
Near 150th Rd
5.0
Security Camera
$153
per month
Parking Lot
33×10
Port Jefferson, NY
11.9 mi
225 Sheep Pasture Rd Port Jefferson, New York
5.0
Keyless Entry
Private Entrance
starting at
$182
per month
Closest units to my location
33% of listings within 0.3 miles. Average distance of all listings: 1.1 miles.
67% of listings respond within 24 hours. Fastest response time: 23 minutes.
25% of listings offer first month discounts. Average rating for rated listings: 5.0.
Search your zip code:
- 11722
- 11752
Unpaved Lot
20×10
Brentwood, NY
3.8 mi
Near 93 Heartland Blvd
Security Camera
Electricity Available
50% off first month
$325
per month
Unpaved Lot
20×10
Brentwood, NY
3.8 mi
Near 93 Heartland Blvd
Fenced Property
Private Space
starting at
$275
per month
Parking Lot
10×20
Bohemia, NY
4.3 mi
Near 162 Wilbur Pl
4.0
Instant book
Security Camera
50% off first month
$150
per month
Parking Lot
20×10
St James, NY
5.4 mi
Near 44 Prospect Ave
Locked Area
Private Space
$124
per month
Driveway
10×20
Bay Shore, NY
5.5 mi
Near 41S
Security Camera
$100
per month
Large vehicles (SUVs, trucks, vans)
Average price for large vehicle storage is $256; sizes range from 20 to 40 feet.
50% of listings offer a first month discount; average price per square foot is $1.
Fast host response time, averaging 25 minutes, ideal for securing spaces quickly.
Unpaved Lot
20×10
St James, NY
6.1 mi
Near 10 Glenrich Dr
5.0
Private Space
starting at
$184
per month
Unpaved Lot
20×10
Yaphank, NY
15.3 mi
Near 252 River Rd
4.9
Instant book
Fenced Property
Gravel
starting at
$100
per month
Parking Lot
20×10
Ansonia, CT
38.4 mi
Near 200 Emmett Ave
5.0
Security Camera
No Stairs
50% off first month
starting at
$100
per month
Unpaved Lot
30×10
Medford, NY
10.8 mi
Near 1900 Medford Ave
5.0
Instant book
Security Camera
starting at
$180
per month
Top Host
Parking Lot
31×12
Branford, CT
39.0 mi
Near 52 Oak Ridge Rd
5.0
Electricity Available
50% off first month
$149
per month
Parking Lot
33×10
Port Jefferson, NY
11.9 mi
225 Sheep Pasture Rd Port Jefferson, New York
5.0
Keyless Entry
Private Entrance
starting at
$182
per month
Garage
30×10
West Babylon, NY
8.7 mi
821 Sunrise Hwy West Babylon, New York
5.0
Keyless Entry
Private Entrance
$477
per month
Premium spaces & services
Parking Lot
20×7
Miller Place, NY
16.2 mi
922 Route 25A Miller Place, New York
5.0
Attendant or Security
Keyless Entry
$102
per month
Top Host
Parking Lot
31×12
Branford, CT
39.0 mi
Near 52 Oak Ridge Rd
5.0
Electricity Available
50% off first month
$149
per month
Parking Garage
18×9
New Rochelle, NY
31.4 mi
55 Clinton Pl New Rochelle, New York
4.6
Instant book
EV charging Available
Wheelchair Accessible
$125
per month
Top Host
Driveway
20×10
Jamaica, NY
30.3 mi
Near 147-40 184th St
5.0
Keyless Entry
Fenced Property
50% off first month
$149
per month
Parking Lot
33×10
Port Jefferson, NY
11.9 mi
225 Sheep Pasture Rd Port Jefferson, New York
5.0
Keyless Entry
Private Entrance
starting at
$182
per month
Parking Lot
17×8
Melville, NY
11.2 mi
965 Walt Whitman Road Melville, New York
5.0
Keyless Entry
Private Entrance
$228
per month
Garage
20×10
Farmingville, NY
9.8 mi
951 HorseBlock Road Farmingville, New York
5.0
Keyless Entry
Private Entrance
$322
per month
Garage
30×10
West Babylon, NY
8.7 mi
821 Sunrise Hwy West Babylon, New York
5.0
Keyless Entry
Private Entrance
$477
per month
Storage facility cost comparison
10×20 | 10×30 | 10×40 | |
|---|---|---|---|
Average storage facility Central Islip, NY | $306 | $945 | -- |
Neighbor 100+ storage spaces nearby | |||
Extra Space Storage Hauppauge, NY (3 miles) | $403 | -- | -- |
Extra Space Storage East Northport, NY (8 miles) | $329 | -- | -- |
CubeSmart Self Storage North Babylon, NY (8 miles) | $387 | -- | -- |
Vehicle storage size estimator
Enter your car information below to see what size storage unit you need for your car.
Recommended storage options by car type
Compact car
10’×15’ storage units
Due to their small size, mini cars can fit in an indoor or outdoor 10’×15’ space. Car examples include Mini Cooper (12.6 feet) and Mazda Miata (12.10 feet).
Small car
10’×15’ storage units
Small car examples include Honda Fit (13.3 feet), Volkswagen Golf (13.8 feet), Kia Soul (13.9 feet), and Kia Rio Hatchback (13.4 feet).
Small SUV
10’×15’ storage units
Small SUVs can be stored indoor, outdoor, and covered spaces. The Toyota Corolla iM (14.2 feet) and Honda CR-V are car examples.
Mid-size car
10’×15’ storage units
Mid-size cars are the largest cars that fit in a 10’×15’ space. Examples include Ford Fiesta (14.5 feet), and Ford Focus (14.4 feet).
Full-size car
10’×20’ storage units
Full-sized cars include Toyota Camry (16.2 feet), Honda Civic (15.27 feet), Ford Fusion (15.9 feet), and Chevrolet Impala (16.7 feet).
Small pickup
10’×20’ storage units
Small pickups can be stored uncovered and outdoor. If storing indoor, make sure the height of the car will work. Toyota Tacoma (17.6 feet) is a small pickup.
Mid-size to large SUV
10’×20’ storage units
Larger SUVs requiring a 10’×20’ unit include Jeep Grand Cherokee (16.13 feet), Toyota RAV4 (15.1 feet), GMC Sierra (19.1 feet), and Ford Explorer (16.5 feet).
Minivan
10’×20’ storage units
Minivans typically fit well in a 10’×20’ unit. For more room, store in a 10’×30’. Car examples include Honda Odyssey (17.1 feet) and Toyota Sienna (16.9 inches).
Large pickup
10’×30’ storage units
Large pickup 10’×30’ storage units Pickup trucks can be store indoor or outdoor. Examples include Chevrolet Silverado (19.4 feet), Ford F-150 (18.97 feet), and the rest of the Ford-F series (20.85 feet).
Deciding what kind of storage is best for you
Seasonal car storage
Choose indoor storage (garage or facility) for protection, or secure outdoor storage with a cover. Maintain battery and tires.
Storing a car while in a large city
Use a secure parking garage, consider car storage services, or park in well-lit areas with anti-theft devices.
Military deployment car storage
Select a long-term storage facility with monitoring, trust friends or family, or consider renting it out for extra use.
Storing a business car or truck
Opt for commercial storage facilities, use on-site storage if available, and perform maintenance pre-storage.
Auto storage during a life change
Options include long-term storage facilities, trusted contacts (friends or family), or renting out the car for extra use.
Parking a car when you travel
Consider airport parking, storage facilities, or car storage services. Ensure your car is well-maintained before departure.
Can’t find what you’re looking for?
Search the nation’s largest storage marketplace to find cheap car storage near you.
See more car storageTips to prepare your car for storage
Properly preparing a car for short- or long-term storage prevents damage, maintains its value, saves on costs and makes pick-up easier
Vehicle Parking and Storage in Central Islip, NY
Select storage type
Additional New York car storage locations
Alternative Car Storage Facilities near Central Islip
While Neighbor often features the most affordable, safest, and nearest car storage, traditional storage facilities are also a potential option for car storage in Central Islip, NY.
Use the list below for information:
Need car storage in Central Islip?
Neighbor is the world’s largest storage marketplace. Call for rates or search online for the cheapest, closest, and safest storage units.
(844) 449-1099