Self storage units in Central Islip, NY
Neighbor reviews near Central Islip, NY
5.0 (8,115 reviews)
Based on 8,115 verified reviews, renters rated Neighbor's service for finding self storage units in Central Islip 5.0 out of 5 on average
Closest units to my location
Search your zip code:
- 11722
- 11752
Not affiliated with Neighbor
Extra Space Storage
Islandia, NY
1.7 mi
3016 Express Dr S Islandia, NY
4.8
Pros: professional and friendly staff, clean facilityCons: multiple unit break-ins reported, frequent and substantial rate increases, delays in communication during emergencies, locks and security deemed inadequate
starting at
$71
per month
Not affiliated with Neighbor
Simply Self Storage
Hauppauge, NY
2.7 mi
745 Old Willets Path Hauppauge, NY
Pros: clean and well-maintained premises, excellent and helpful staff, secure facility with multiple security codes, close to residential areasCons: frequent rate increases, rates can double within a year, acquired by a less favorable company
starting at
$77
per month
Not affiliated with Neighbor
Life Storage - Bay Shore
Bay Shore, NY
3.7 mi
110 Saxon Ave Bay Shore, NY
starting at
$139
per month
Not affiliated with Neighbor
Prime Storage
Bay Shore, NY
4.0 mi
99 Pine Aire Dr Bay Shore, NY
4.1
Pros: great customer service from staff, clean and accessible storage units, competitive and good pricing, convenient and easy locationCons: price increases occur annually, untimely rent hikes noted by customers
starting at
$89
per month
Self Storage Unit
20×10
Lake Ronkonkoma, NY
5.9 mi
363 Portion Road Lake Ronkonkoma, New York
5.0
Attendant or Security
Pet Free
$383
per month
Not affiliated with Neighbor
Prime Storage
Bohemia, NY
5.9 mi
868 Lincoln Ave Bohemia, NY
4.5
Pros: clean units and convenient access, location is easy to get to, service is knowledgeable and courteousCons: fees for additional services are high, complaints about rude staff members, facility lacks proper snow clearing, misinformation about mandatory insurance requirements
starting at
$76
per month
Garage
20×10
Saint James, NY
6.4 mi
Near 237 7th St
Private Entrance
No Stairs
$365
per month
Storage space
83×65
Commack, NY
6.4 mi
Near 19 Cameo Rd
Private Entrance
An outdoor fenced backyard on 1/4 acre is also available for rent.
$1,601
per month
Not affiliated with Neighbor
CubeSmart Self Storage
Deer Park, NY
6.4 mi
999 Long Island Ave Deer Park, NY
4.6
Pros: clean and well-lit facility, easy sign-up and reservation process, friendly and helpful staffCons: rents increase every six to seven months, lack of proper security measures, office often closed during business hours, price considered too high by some users
starting at
$74
per month
Not affiliated with Neighbor
CubeSmart Self Storage
Holbrook, NY
6.7 mi
640 Broadway Ave Holbrook, NY
4.7
Pros: helpful and accommodating staff, ease of renting process, facility is clean and well-managed, location is convenient, generally reasonable pricingCons: payment options can be inconvenient, issues with card payment fees, concerns about security and break-ins, price complaints
starting at
$110
per month
Not affiliated with Neighbor
Extra Space Storage
Centereach, NY
6.9 mi
2626 Middle Country Rd Centereach, NY
4.8
Pros: clean and secure facility, convenient and easy to access, polite and knowledgeable staff, offers online booking discounts
starting at
$172
per month
Not affiliated with Neighbor
CubeSmart Self Storage
North Babylon, NY
6.9 mi
240 Bay Shore Rd North Babylon, NY
4.8
Pros: friendly and helpful staff, clean and well-maintained facility, easy and smooth check-in process, reasonable and knowledgeable customer serviceCons: units prone to mold and water damage, presence of rat feces and traps, significant rent increases over time, charges full month despite early move-out
starting at
$39
per month
Not affiliated with Neighbor
Extra Space Storage
Kings Park, NY
6.9 mi
281 Indian Head Rd Kings Park, NY
4.9
Pros: helpful and friendly staff, clean and well-maintained unitsCons: significant rent increases after a short time, online signup can lead to duplicate charges
starting at
$98
per month
Not affiliated with Neighbor
Extra Space Storage
North Babylon, NY
7.1 mi
1251 Deer Park Ave North Babylon, NY
5.0
Pros: clean and well-maintained facility, polite and professional staff, rental process is quick and easy, secure buildingCons: facility ownership changes frequently, difficult to reach customer service, frequent and significant price increases, complicated procedures due to office closures
starting at
$98
per month
Bedroom
9×9
Bayport, NY
7.5 mi
Near 1598 Lakeview Ave
Smoke Free
Smoke Detectors
50% off first month
starting at
$54
per month
Self Storage Unit
20×10
Holbrook, NY
7.7 mi
15 Andrea Rd Holbrook, New York
5.0
Pet Free
No Stairs
"Dan was really helpful."－ Verified review
starting at
$216
per month
Not affiliated with Neighbor
iStorage Self Storage
Bayport, NY
7.9 mi
709 Church St Bayport, NY
4.8
Pros: clean and secure facility, convenient location, friendly and helpful staffCons: difficult to contact staff, staff can be unavailable
starting at
$88
per month
Cheap prices: Starting at $54
Not affiliated with Neighbor
Extra Space Storage
North Babylon, NY
7.1 mi
1251 Deer Park Ave North Babylon, NY
5.0
Pros: clean and well-maintained facility, polite and professional staff, rental process is quick and easy, secure buildingCons: facility ownership changes frequently, difficult to reach customer service, frequent and significant price increases, complicated procedures due to office closures
starting at
$241
per month
Not affiliated with Neighbor
CubeSmart Self Storage
Deer Park, NY
6.4 mi
999 Long Island Ave Deer Park, NY
4.6
Pros: clean and well-lit facility, easy sign-up and reservation process, friendly and helpful staffCons: rents increase every six to seven months, lack of proper security measures, office often closed during business hours, price considered too high by some users
starting at
$359
per month
Not affiliated with Neighbor
CubeSmart Self Storage
North Babylon, NY
6.9 mi
240 Bay Shore Rd North Babylon, NY
4.8
Pros: friendly and helpful staff, clean and well-maintained facility, easy and smooth check-in process, reasonable and knowledgeable customer serviceCons: units prone to mold and water damage, presence of rat feces and traps, significant rent increases over time, charges full month despite early move-out
starting at
$437
per month
Not affiliated with Neighbor
Extra Space Storage
Kings Park, NY
6.9 mi
281 Indian Head Rd Kings Park, NY
4.9
Pros: helpful and friendly staff, clean and well-maintained unitsCons: significant rent increases after a short time, online signup can lead to duplicate charges
starting at
$458
per month
Not affiliated with Neighbor
Extra Space Storage
Centereach, NY
6.9 mi
2626 Middle Country Rd Centereach, NY
4.8
Pros: clean and secure facility, convenient and easy to access, polite and knowledgeable staff, offers online booking discounts
starting at
$493
per month
Not affiliated with Neighbor
iStorage Self Storage
Bayport, NY
7.9 mi
709 Church St Bayport, NY
4.8
Pros: clean and secure facility, convenient location, friendly and helpful staffCons: difficult to contact staff, staff can be unavailable
starting at
$503
per month
Not affiliated with Neighbor
Extra Space Storage
Islandia, NY
1.7 mi
3016 Express Dr S Islandia, NY
4.8
Pros: professional and friendly staff, clean facilityCons: multiple unit break-ins reported, frequent and substantial rate increases, delays in communication during emergencies, locks and security deemed inadequate
starting at
$557
per month
Not affiliated with Neighbor
Life Storage - Bay Shore
Bay Shore, NY
3.7 mi
110 Saxon Ave Bay Shore, NY
starting at
$571
per month
Not affiliated with Neighbor
Prime Storage
Bohemia, NY
5.9 mi
868 Lincoln Ave Bohemia, NY
4.5
Pros: clean units and convenient access, location is easy to get to, service is knowledgeable and courteousCons: fees for additional services are high, complaints about rude staff members, facility lacks proper snow clearing, misinformation about mandatory insurance requirements
starting at
$609
per month
Not affiliated with Neighbor
CubeSmart Self Storage
Holbrook, NY
6.7 mi
640 Broadway Ave Holbrook, NY
4.7
Pros: helpful and accommodating staff, ease of renting process, facility is clean and well-managed, location is convenient, generally reasonable pricingCons: payment options can be inconvenient, issues with card payment fees, concerns about security and break-ins, price complaints
starting at
$616
per month
Storage space
83×65
Commack, NY
6.4 mi
Near 19 Cameo Rd
Private Entrance
$1,601
per month
Larger units: 10x15 and above
Storage space
83×65
Commack, NY
6.4 mi
Near 19 Cameo Rd
Private Entrance
$1,601
per month
Not affiliated with Neighbor
Extra Space Storage
Centereach, NY
6.9 mi
2626 Middle Country Rd Centereach, NY
4.8
Pros: clean and secure facility, convenient and easy to access, polite and knowledgeable staff, offers online booking discounts
starting at
$493
per month
Not affiliated with Neighbor
Prime Storage
Bohemia, NY
5.9 mi
868 Lincoln Ave Bohemia, NY
4.5
Pros: clean units and convenient access, location is easy to get to, service is knowledgeable and courteousCons: fees for additional services are high, complaints about rude staff members, facility lacks proper snow clearing, misinformation about mandatory insurance requirements
starting at
$609
per month
Smaller units: 5x5 and below
How Neighbor compares to traditional storage facilities
Neighbor
Neighbor
Traditional facilities
Traditional facilities
Wide variety of sizes
Wide variety of sizes
Lowest prices
Lowest prices
Highest safety rating
Highest safety rating
Protection plans
Protection plans
Nationwide availability
Nationwide availability
Verified hosts
Verified hosts
Manage rental online
Manage rental online
Storage facility cost comparison
10×10 | 10×20 | |
|---|---|---|
Average storage facility Central Islip, NY | $231 | $410 |
Neighbor 48 storage spaces nearby | ||
Extra Space Storage Islandia, NY (2 miles) | $224 | $557 |
Simply Self Storage Hauppauge, NY (3 miles) | $153 | $344 |
Life Storage Bay Shore, NY (4 miles) | $432 | $571 |
Storage for Rent in Central Islip, NY
Select storage type
What’s the best self storage option for you?
Compare the pros and cons of renting from various storage unit options, including drive-up and interior units
Drive-up Exterior Units
Enclosed drive-up storage units, like garages, have an outdoor entrance
11% of storage spaces in Central Islip have security cameras as an amenity provided by the host
Interior-Access Storage Units
Indoor spaces like vacant offices or residential rooms offer increased protection
In Central Islip, 100% of listings do not have stairs leading to the storage space, allowing for easy access
Vehicle Storage Units
Indoor storage units that allow vehicles provide protection over outdoor parking
Residential indoor parking in Central Islip is typically a similar price to surrounding areas
Additional New York self storage locations
Alternative Self Storage Facilities near Central Islip
Even though storage facilities are offered in Central Islip, New York, Neighbor.com typically features the least expensive, more secure, and nearest self storage.
Reference the list of self storage facilities for details:
Need self storage in Central Islip?
Neighbor is the world’s largest storage marketplace. Call for rates or search online for the cheapest, closest, and safest storage units.
(844) 448-0855