Car storage in Brookhaven, NY

Top-rated

Average rating of 4+ stars

Cheapest price

Store your car as low as $75/month

Closest to me

Enter your zip for nearby units

Large vehicles

Oversized units for larger vehicles

Multiple vehicles

Storage for more than one car

Average rating of 5 with prices ranging from $99 to $497
Top hosts and 60% of listings respond within 3 minutes
50% of listings are storage units with features like climate control and drive-up access

StorQuest Self Storage

3 sizes available

4.4

393 Smith Rd Shirley, NY

1.9 mi

2.1x more expensive

Pros:

Helpful and courteous staff
Clean property and storage units
Good customer service
Quick and easy process

Cons:

Rates regularly increase
Some items got mildew
Broken gate for almost 9 months
Misleading promotional offers
Elevator malfunctioned, causing inconvenience

10'×15'

starting at

$371/ mo

10'×20'

starting at

$389/ mo

10'×25'

starting at

$514/ mo

10'×15' starting at

$371

Driveway and unpaved lots: Average price $100, first month discount 33%.
Closest options: 0.4 miles away, average rating 0, price $99.
Outdoor uncovered spaces: 67% of listings, average price $108.

Driveway

20’ × 10’

Bellport, NY

2.6 mi

near 266 Southaven Ave

Security Camera

No Stairs

Private Space

$75/ mo

Driveway

20’ × 10’

Mastic, NY

3 mi

near 1272 Montauk Hwy

Security Camera

$85/ mo

Unpaved Lot

20’ × 10’

Bellport, NY

3 mi

near Sunrise Hwy

Security Camera

Private Space

$95/ mo

Average distance is 2 miles; 58% of listings under 2 miles.
25% of listings respond within 3 minutes; highest average rating is 0.
83% of listings offer outdoor, uncovered parking; 50% have camera security.

Unpaved Lot

3 sizes available

5.0

Yaphank, NY

0.4 mi

near 252 River Rd

Fenced Property

Gravel

Locked Area

"I couldn't ask for a better space to store my RV at a better place."

20’ × 10’

$50

1st month

$99/ mo

30’ × 10’

$60

1st month

$119/ mo

40’ × 10’

$73

1st month

$145/ mo

20’ × 10’ starting at

$99

Driveway

20’ × 10’

Yaphank, NY

0.4 mi

near Horseblock Rd

Security Camera

No Stairs

Private Space

$137.50

1st month

$275/ mo

Average price for large vehicle storage is $204, with 1.6 miles average distance.
Spaces range up to 50 feet wide, ideal for trucks and vans.
80% of listings offer a first month discount and fast response times.

Unpaved Lot

30’ × 14’

Shirley, NY

2.2 mi

near 32 River Rd

Electricity Available

$400/ mo

Unpaved Lot

30’ × 50’

Yaphank, NY

2.6 mi

near 262 Garden Ln

Security Camera

No Stairs

Private Space

$225/ mo

Majority of listings are unpaved lots, averaging $194 monthly and 22 minutes response time.
Average size: 26x21 feet, ideal for multiple cars. 33% offer camera security.
50% of listings near 2 miles; accessible within 24 hours. Response times mostly under 60 minutes.

Unpaved Lot

40’ × 20’

Yaphank, NY

2.7 mi

near 74 Mill Rd

Security Camera

$149/ mo

Find nearby storage locations

Yaphank, New York (2 mi)

Middle Island, New York (6 mi)

Patchogue, New York (7 mi)

East Moriches, New York (8 mi)

Selden, New York (8 mi)

Rocky Point, New York (9 mi)

Sayville, New York (10 mi)

Port Jefferson, New York (12 mi)

Islandia, New York (14 mi)

How Neighbor compares to traditional storage facilities

Neighbor

Traditional facilities

Wide variety of sizes

Lowest prices

Highest safety rating

Protection plans

Nationwide availability

Verified hosts

Manage rental online

View reviews for Neighbor

Storage facility cost comparison

	10×20	10×30	10×40
Average storage facility Brookhaven, NY	$389	--	--
Neighbor 100+ storage spaces nearby	$105	$119	$161
StorQuest Self Storage Shirley, NY (2 miles)	$389	--	--

Storage for Rent in Brookhaven, NY

Select storage type

What type of vehicle storage is best for you?

Choose whether to store your vehicle using uncovered parking, covered parking, or an indoor storage unit. Each offers their own benefits and downsides.

Uncovered Parking

three cars parked together next to a field

Parking spaces are affordable options at commercial lots & residential properties.

Uncovered storage is more expensive than covered storage by Infinity% on average in Brookhaven

Find outdoor parking

Covered Parking

boat on trailer with fabric cover in outdoor covered area

Covered parking provides a roof or partial enclosure around your car.

There are NaN% more hosts in Brookhaven that are part of our Top Host program than surrounding cities

Find covered parking

Indoor Storage

Shared & private storage includes drive-up storage units, private garages & warehouses.

Indoor storage in Brookhaven is typically a similar price to surrounding areas

Find indoor storage

Additional New York car storage locations

131 Akron Street, Lindenhurst

Upper Whitfield Road, Accord

145 88 180th Street, Queens

2907 Rte 9w, New Windsor

377 Ocean Ave, Islip

Alternative Car Storage Facilities near Brookhaven

Although traditional storage options are available in Brookhaven, New York, Neighbor storage features affordable, close by and secure car storage.

If you'd like information about traditional storage facilities nearby, see the below list for more information:

StorQuest Self Storage (1.9 miles)

393 Smith Rd Shirley, NY

Explore recently added cities

Need car storage in Brookhaven?

Neighbor is the world’s largest storage marketplace. Call for rates or search online for the cheapest, closest, and safest storage units.

(844) 449-1099