50% cheaper

14x safer

Right next door

Car storage in Middle Island, NY

Parking Lot

10’ × 20’

Middle Island, New York

0.2 mi

near 99 Fairway Dr

No Stairs

$95/ mo

Unpaved Lot

40’ × 10’

5.0

Middle Island, New York

1.6 mi

near 94 Middle Country Rd

Security Camera

$64.50

1st month

$129/ mo

Unpaved Lot

2 sizes available

5.0

Middle Island, New York

1.6 mi

near 94 Middle Country Rd

Fenced Property

Security Camera

20’ × 10’

$49.50

1st month

$99/ mo

30’ × 10’

$54.50

1st month

$109/ mo

Driveway

20’ × 10’

Selden, New York

4.6 mi

near 151 Skyline Dr

Security Camera

No Stairs

Private Space

$48.50

1st month

$97/ mo

Parking Lot

20’ × 10’

Medford, New York

2.4 mi

near 43 David Overton Rd

Security Camera

$109/ mo

Driveway

20’ × 10’

Miller Place, New York

2.2 mi

near 288 Miller Place Yaphank Rd

No Stairs

$99/ mo

Unpaved Lot

36’ × 20’

Coram, New York

3.4 mi

near 16 Cammann Rd

Private Space

No Stairs

$131/ mo

Driveway

20’ × 10’

Selden, New York

4.5 mi

near 151 Skyline Dr

Security Camera

No Stairs

$49.50

1st month

$99/ mo

Parking Lot

30’ × 10’

Middle Island, New York

2 mi

near 288 Miller Place Yaphank Rd

Security Camera

No Stairs

$57.50

1st month

$115/ mo

Driveway

20’ × 10’

Port Jefferson Station, New York

4.4 mi

near 2 Plymouth Ave

Security Camera

Private Space

No Stairs

$99/ mo

Unpaved Lot

4 sizes available

Medford, New York

2.1 mi

near 43 David Overton Rd

Fenced Property

Locked Area

Private Space

35’ × 20’

$150/ mo

30’ × 10’

$150/ mo

20’ × 10’

$150/ mo

40’ × 10’

$150/ mo

Driveway

30’ × 10’

Medford, New York

4.4 mi

near 440 Expressway Dr S

Security Camera

Private Space

$112/ mo

Unpaved Lot

40’ × 10’

5.0

Yaphank, New York

4.7 mi

near 350 River Rd

Fenced Property

Gravel

Locked Area

Security Camera

Private Space

$74.50

1st month

$149/ mo

20 x 10 Unpaved Lot in Coram, New York near [object Object]

4 sizes available

5.0

Coram, New York

4 mi

near 900 Blue Ridge Dr

Security Camera

Fenced Property

Gravel

Locked Area

Private Space

Unpaved Lot

20’ × 10’

$180/ mo

200’ × 100’

$2,910/ mo

400’ × 100’

$5,820/ mo

Other

400’ × 100’

$245/ mo

Unpaved Lot

70’ × 10’

Medford, New York

4.6 mi

near 810 Long Island Ave

Security Camera

$500/ mo

Unpaved Lot

30’ × 50’

Yaphank, New York

2.8 mi

near 262 Garden Ln

Security Camera

No Stairs

Private Space

$225/ mo

Unpaved Lot

40’ × 20’

Yaphank, New York

2.5 mi

near 74 Mill Rd

Security Camera

$149/ mo

Show more storage units

Find nearby storage locations

Yaphank, New York (4 mi)

Rocky Point, New York (4 mi)

Selden, New York (6 mi)

Port Jefferson, New York (7 mi)

Brookhaven, New York (8 mi)

Patchogue, New York (9 mi)

East Moriches, New York (11 mi)

Sayville, New York (12 mi)

Smithtown, New York (14 mi)

Kings Park, New York (16 mi)

How Neighbor compares to traditional storage facilities

Neighbor

Traditional facilities

Wide variety of sizes

Lowest prices

Highest safety rating

Protection plans

Nationwide availability

Verified hosts

Manage rental online

View reviews for Neighbor

Storage for Rent in Middle Island, NY

Select storage type

Additional New York car storage locations

Carmans Road, Massapequa

Alternative Car Storage Facilities near Middle Island

While Neighbor often features the most affordable, safest, and nearest car storage, traditional self storage options are also a potential option for car storage in Middle Island, NY.

Use the facilities below for information:

Extra Space Storage (3.5 miles)

14 Francis Mooney Dr Ridge, NY

Extra Space Storage (3.5 miles)

2025 Route 112 Coram, NY

Public Storage (3.9 miles)

550 Middle Country Rd Coram, NY

Public Storage (4.4 miles)

922 Route 25A Miller Place, NY

Explore recently added cities

Need car storage in Middle Island?

Neighbor is the world’s largest storage marketplace. Call for rates or search online for the cheapest, closest, and safest storage units.

(844) 449-1099