Self storage units in East Setauket, NY

Self storage units in East Setauket, NY

24 locations available

7×7 Closet in Port Jefferson Station, NY near 1504 RT-112
7×7 Closet in Port Jefferson Station, NY near 1504 RT-112 2
7×7 Closet in Port Jefferson Station, NY near 1504 RT-112 3

Closet

7×7

Port Jefferson Station, NY

3.0 mi

Near 1504 RT-112

$49

per month

20×20 Garage in Setauket- East Setauket, NY near 54 N Belle Mead Rd
20×20 Garage in Setauket- East Setauket, NY near 54 N Belle Mead Rd 2

Garage

20×20

Setauket- East Setauket, NY

0.8 mi

Near 54 N Belle Mead Rd

$249

per month

24×11 Attic in Centereach, NY near 93 Forest Rd
24×11 Attic in Centereach, NY near 93 Forest Rd 2
24×11 Attic in Centereach, NY near 93 Forest Rd 3

Attic

24×11

Centereach, NY

2.6 mi

Near 93 Forest Rd

It is smoke-free.

$150

per month

9×9 Bedroom in Bayport, NY near 1598 Lakeview Ave

Bedroom

9×9

Bayport, NY

10.2 mi

Near 1598 Lakeview Ave

50% off1st month

starting at

$69

per month

7×5 Self Storage Unit in Medford, NY near 810 Long Island Ave
7×5 Self Storage Unit in Medford, NY near 810 Long Island Ave 2
7×5 Self Storage Unit in Medford, NY near 810 Long Island Ave 3

Self Storage Unit

7×5

Medford, NY

9.6 mi

Near 810 Long Island Ave

All units can be brought to your location for loading and unloading.

$75

per month

10×10 Storage space in Medford, NY near 22 Locust Ave N
10×10 Storage space in Medford, NY near 22 Locust Ave N 2
10×10 Storage space in Medford, NY near 22 Locust Ave N 3

Storage space

10×10

Medford, NY

8.7 mi

Near 22 Locust Ave N

50% off1st month

$135

per month

10×10 Attic in Medford, NY near 22 Locust Ave N

Attic

10×10

Medford, NY

8.7 mi

Near 22 Locust Ave N

50% off1st month

$135

per month

12×10 Shed in Patchogue, NY near 73 N Summit Ave
12×10 Shed in Patchogue, NY near 73 N Summit Ave 2
12×10 Shed in Patchogue, NY near 73 N Summit Ave 3

Shed

12×10

Patchogue, NY

9.9 mi

Near 73 N Summit Ave

50% off1st month

$89

per month

15×15 Shed in Medford, NY near 810 Long Island Ave
15×15 Shed in Medford, NY near 810 Long Island Ave 2
15×15 Shed in Medford, NY near 810 Long Island Ave 3

Shed

15×15

Medford, NY

8.9 mi

Near 810 Long Island Ave

50% off1st month

$138

per month

10×10 Warehouse in Ronkonkoma, NY near 28 17th Ave

Warehouse

10×10

Ronkonkoma, NY

8.4 mi

Near 28 17th Ave

$139

per month

20×10 Garage in Bridgeport, CT near 20 Rutland Ave
20×10 Garage in Bridgeport, CT near 20 Rutland Ave 2
20×10 Garage in Bridgeport, CT near 20 Rutland Ave 3

Garage

20×10

Bridgeport, CT

19.2 mi

Near 20 Rutland Ave

5.0

19 months rented

50% off1st month

$175

per month

19×13 Basement in Commack, NY near 19 Cameo Rd

Basement

19×13

Commack, NY

10.6 mi

Near 19 Cameo Rd

$156

per month

20×10 Garage in Stratford, CT near 35 Lenox Ave
20×10 Garage in Stratford, CT near 35 Lenox Ave 2
20×10 Garage in Stratford, CT near 35 Lenox Ave 3

Garage

20×10

Stratford, CT

19.7 mi

Near 35 Lenox Ave

5.0

41 months rented

$330

per month

10×8 Self Storage Unit in Stratford, CT near 71 Access Rd
10×8 Self Storage Unit in Stratford, CT near 71 Access Rd 2
10×8 Self Storage Unit in Stratford, CT near 71 Access Rd 3

Self Storage Unit

10×8

Stratford, CT

17.4 mi

Near 71 Access Rd

$135

per month

30×10 Garage in Deer Park, NY near August Rd
30×10 Garage in Deer Park, NY near August Rd 2
30×10 Garage in Deer Park, NY near August Rd 3

Garage

30×10

Deer Park, NY

17.4 mi

Near August Rd

4 months rented

$178

per month

See all 24 storage options in East Setauket

Neighbor reviews near East Setauket, New York

4.9 (1,402 reviews)

Based on 1,402 verified reviews, renters rated Neighbor's service for finding self storage units in East Setauket 4.9 out of 5 on average

K

Kevin K.

-

Fairfield, CT

Dec 17, 2023

Verified Review

Super accommodating and friendly.

O

Otto H.

-

Dedham, MA

Mar 22, 2022

Verified Review

will rent storage again

J

Jennifer H.

-

Easton, CT

Apr 29, 2024

Verified Review

J

Jeffrey G.

-

Weston, CT

Aug 31, 2024

Verified Review

B

Brian K.

-

Easton, CT

Jun 28, 2022

Verified Review

profile

Ace H.

-

Bridgeport, CT

Apr 25, 2024

Verified Review

Now showing 1-6 of 1,402 reviews for East Setauket, NY

Closest units to my location
  • Average distance is 2.6 miles; 25% of listings within 1.6 miles.

  • 50% of listings have climate control and elevators; prices range $18-$787.

  • Fastest response time: 21 minutes; average host response is 24 hours.

  • Search your zip code:

    • 11733

Not affiliated with Neighbor

Prime Storage in Port Jefferson Station, NY

Prime Storage

Port Jefferson Station, NY

2.7 mi

1184 Route 112 Port Jefferson Station, NY

4.3

Pros: clean and well-maintained facility, very secure with security measures, friendly and helpful staff, convenient location and accessible unitsCons: frequent and significant price increases, some units not the advertised size, difficulties with online payment processing, inconsistent promotion and discount policies

starting at

$69

per month

Not affiliated with Neighbor

Prime Storage in Centereach, NY

Prime Storage

Centereach, NY

3.6 mi

21 Hammond Rd Centereach, NY

4.3

Pros: clean and well-organized facility, easy access and secure location, helpful and professional staff, reasonable pricingCons: inconsistent invoicing and due dates, confusing insurance requirements, poor customer service experiences, quick freezes on unit access

starting at

$56

per month

Not affiliated with Neighbor

Extra Space Storage in Centereach, NY

Extra Space Storage

Centereach, NY

3.9 mi

2626 Middle Country Rd Centereach, NY

4.8

Pros: clean and secure facility, convenient and easy to access, polite and knowledgeable staff, offers online booking discounts

starting at

$151

per month

Not affiliated with Neighbor

Public Storage in Coram, NY

Public Storage

Coram, NY

5.0 mi

550 Middle Country Rd Coram, NY

4.8

Pros: easy registration and setup process, staff is very professional and helpful, mobile entry app for easy accessCons: significant rent increases over time, costs could be high for long-term renters

starting at

$63

per month

View all listings

Cheap prices: Starting at $49
  • Average price $49-$238, sizes 16-300 sq ft, 3.1-4.6 miles away.

  • 66% of storage units are climate controlled, drive up, and interior access.

  • Top host response time within 24 hours, average rating of 4.8/5.

Not affiliated with Neighbor

U-Haul Moving & Storage of Smithtown in Smithtown, NY

U-Haul Moving & Storage of Smithtown

Smithtown, NY

5.7 mi

771 Nesconset Hwy Smithtown, NY

starting at

$110

per month

Not affiliated with Neighbor

Public Storage in Miller Place, NY

Public Storage

Miller Place, NY

6.7 mi

922 Route 25A Miller Place, NY

4.7

Pros: clean and well-maintained facility., convenient location with elevators., friendly and knowledgeable staff.Cons: unexpected rate increases within months., issues with communication and refunds., difficulty accessing units rented online.

starting at

$171

per month

Not affiliated with Neighbor

Public Storage in Ronkonkoma, NY

Public Storage

Ronkonkoma, NY

5.8 mi

363 Portion Rd Ronkonkoma, NY

Pros: clean and well-maintained facility., friendly and helpful staff.Cons: rent increases for current tenants., damaged property and poor handling., temperature control issues in storage units., staff availability can be inconsistent.

starting at

$217

per month

Not affiliated with Neighbor

St James Self Storage Inc in St James, NY

St James Self Storage Inc

St James, NY

5.1 mi

75 Arlington Ave St James, NY

4.4

Pros: extremely clean and easy to navigate, very convenient location, great prices for the units

starting at

$290

per month

View all listings

Larger units: 10x15 and above
  • Storage units average 787 square feet with prices starting at $249.

  • 100% of units have multiple access options and outdoor exposure.

  • Units are within 3.6 miles on average and hosts respond within 2.7 minutes.

Not affiliated with Neighbor

Public Storage in Port Jefferson, NY

Public Storage

Port Jefferson, NY

1.6 mi

225 Sheep Pasture Rd Port Jefferson, NY

4.8

Pros: staff provides excellent service, facility is clean and maintains wellCons: severe mold issue in units, poor air quality and pest problems, limited staff availability affects service

starting at

$290

per month

Not affiliated with Neighbor

Extra Space Storage in Coram, NY

Extra Space Storage

Coram, NY

4.6 mi

2025 Route 112 Coram, NY

4.8

Pros: units are clean and well-maintained., location is safe and secure., helpful and friendly staff., conveniently located with a variety of unit sizes.Cons: website and online process can be confusing., high curbs at some units., some units smaller than listed dimensions.

starting at

$260

per month

Not affiliated with Neighbor

Public Storage in Nesconset, NY

Public Storage

Nesconset, NY

5.5 mi

72 Southern Blvd Nesconset, NY

Pros: clean facilities and well maintained, good central location, provides excellent access to main roadsCons: parking lot a little small, rental amounts can increase significantly, issues with incorrect billing and payments, poor customer service reported on several occasions

starting at

$398

per month

View all listings

Find nearby storage locations

Port Jefferson Station, New York (2 mi)
Stony Brook, New York (2 mi)
Terryville, New York (2 mi)
Port Jefferson, New York (3 mi)
Centereach, New York (3 mi)
Selden, New York (4 mi)
Lake Grove, New York (4 mi)
Mount Sinai, New York (4 mi)
Coram, New York (5 mi)
Miller Place, New York (5 mi)

How Neighbor compares to traditional storage facilities

badge w/star

Neighbor

Traditional facilities

Wide variety of sizes

Lowest prices

Highest safety rating

Protection plans

Nationwide availability

Verified hosts

Manage rental online

Storage facility cost comparison

5×5

10×20

10×40

Average storage facility

East Setauket, NY

$75

$329

$440

Neighbor

24 storage spaces nearby

Public Storage

Port Jefferson, NY (2 miles)

$47

--

--

Prime Storage

Port Jefferson Station, NY (3 miles)

$98

$242

$292

Prime Storage

Centereach, NY (4 miles)

$92

$362

--

Storage for Rent in East Setauket, NY

Select storage type

self storage
car storage
garages
truck parking
RV storage
boat storage
monthly parking

What’s the best self storage option for you?

Compare the pros and cons of renting from various storage unit options, including drive-up and interior units

Drive-up Exterior Units
open view of an empty garage

Enclosed drive-up storage units, like garages, have an outdoor entrance

None of the currently available storage spaces in East Setauket have security cameras as an amenity

Find drive-up storage
Interior-Access Storage Units
row of indoor storage lockers

Indoor spaces like vacant offices or residential rooms offer increased protection

In East Setauket, 66% of listings do not have stairs leading to the storage space, allowing for easy access

Find indoor storage units
Vehicle Storage Units
view of a half-closed garage with a car inside

Indoor storage units that allow vehicles provide protection over outdoor parking

Residential indoor parking in East Setauket is 150% more expensive than nearby areas

Find car storage units

Alternative Self Storage Facilities near East Setauket

While traditional storage facilities are commonly available in East Setauket, New York, Neighbor.com usually has the more cost-effective, safest, and closest self storage.

Check out the facilities below for information:

Public Storage (1.6 miles)

225 Sheep Pasture Rd Port Jefferson, NY

Extra Space Storage (4.6 miles)

2025 Route 112 Coram, NY

Public Storage (5 miles)

550 Middle Country Rd Coram, NY

Extra Space Storage (9 miles)

1960 Veterans Memorial Hwy Islandia, NY

Bayport Mini Storage (11.5 miles)

915 Montauk Hwy Bayport, NY

Extra Space Storage (9.8 miles)

84 Long Island Ave Yaphank, NY

Extra Space Storage (12.8 miles)

200 Express Dr S Brentwood, NY

Extra Space Storage (8.8 miles)

3016 Express Dr S Islandia, NY

St James Self Storage Inc (5.1 miles)

75 Arlington Ave St James, NY

Public Storage (9.8 miles)

601 Sunrise Hwy Patchogue, NY

iStorage Self Storage (10.1 miles)

257 Waverly Ave Patchogue, NY

Extra Space Storage (7.2 miles)

970 Waverly Ave Holtsville, NY

Public Storage (6.7 miles)

922 Route 25A Miller Place, NY

Extra Space Storage (9.5 miles)

510 Johnson Ave Bohemia, NY

Extra Space Storage (13.3 miles)

1775 5th Ave Bay Shore, NY

Need self storage in East Setauket?

Neighbor is the world’s largest storage marketplace. Call for rates or search online for the cheapest, closest, and safest storage units.

(844) 448-0855