•  50% cheaper
  •  14x safer
  •  Right next door

Self storage units in Bay Shore, NY

How Neighbor compares to traditional storage facilities

badge w/star


Traditional facilities

Wide variety of sizes

Lowest prices

Highest safety rating

Protection plans

Nationwide availability

Verified hosts

Helpful reviews from renters in Bay Shore, New York

6 x 3 Self Storage Unit in Brooklyn, New York

Verified Review

"I absolutely loved everything about the contact free sign up and personal touch of the super friendly staff at Stuuf, where I acquired a clean and large self-storage unit hassle-free. It's conveniently located and incredibly secure. I enjoyed every bit of my move in date which was just ONE DAY after I purchased it. Nothing has ever been easier or painless. I highly recommend this site as well as the team at Stuuf self storage. Thank you to you all!"

Alicia W.

Brooklyn, NY

Sep 19, 2020

7 x 1 Closet in Manhattan, New York

Verified Review

"Very friendly, clean, and accommodating! So grateful I found Irisa through this app. 🙏💖"

Erin's profile

Erin R.

Manhattan, NY

Nov 15, 2022

11 x 7 Basement in Brooklyn, New York

Verified Review

"Good place, Chris was helpful in moving in stuff!"

Carter C.

Brooklyn, NY

Sep 25, 2021

10 x 5 Self Storage Unit in Brooklyn, New York

Verified Review

"Storing with Stuf was super easy. I live in the area and wanted extra space at home so I moved some belongings into this beautiful facility, both inside and out (I can’t believe I’m saying that about self-storage). There are a few self-storage providers in the area but none of them had very inviting spaces; plus, Stuf was pretty competitive in rate and had amazing customer service from the first interaction. The team even met me on site to lend a helping hand and gave me some swag to take home (a mask which was very appreciated)."

Alex B.

Brooklyn, NY

Apr 21, 2021

15 x 10 Bedroom in New York, New York

Verified Review

"very spacious room, so I was able to store my things perfectly! Richie was very responsive whenever I need to grab my things and was always accommodating when I had to pop in and grab some stuff/store some stuff."

Sally C.

New York, NY

Aug 13, 2023

12 x 22 Garage in Englewood Cliffs, New Jersey

Verified Review

"This place is clean and well taken care of. Jay and his family are friendly, helpful and always available whenever I need to pick up my car. Highly recommended!! "

Frank L.

Englewood Cliffs, NJ

May 9, 2022

6 x 6 Self Storage Unit in Brooklyn, New York

Verified Review

"Best storage unit I’ve dealt with so far. Convenient And generous pricing. Great customer service as well, I highly recommend giving this place a shot to anyone "

Tauren A.

Brooklyn, NY

Feb 10, 2021

9 x 5 Self Storage Unit in Brooklyn, New York

Verified Review

"Love Stuf! I'm really happy with moving my storage unit to Stuf. Very easy reservation process, done virtually and Katrina was SO kind and helpful on the phone. They are just a phone call away if you run into any issues. I only had one, I couldn't open my unit initially, but I just had to jiggle the handle/lock and viola! "

Katrina's profile

Katrina R.

Brooklyn, NY

Mar 24, 2021

5 x 10 Garage in The Bronx, New York

Verified Review

"Great communication, very responsive and friendly. Made storing my items a breeze. A+ service. "

Devin's profile

Devin H.

The Bronx, NY

May 15, 2022

28 x 18 Garage in East Rutherford, New Jersey

Verified Review

"Clean, large space. Very friendly and accommodating while we were moving into the city. Overall great space "

Olivia's profile

Olivia T.

East Rutherford, NJ

Aug 29, 2023

See available listings

Discover more Bay Shore, NY storage by type

Select storage type

RV storage
boat storage
long term parking
parking spaces
monthly parking
24 hour storage
car storage
truck parking

Browse similar storage listings nearby

Browse nearby cities

Lindenhurst, New York (7 mi)
Ronkonkoma, New York (8 mi)
Amityville, New York (10 mi)
Farmingdale, New York (10 mi)
Centereach, New York (12 mi)
Patchogue, New York (12 mi)
Medford, New York (14 mi)
Coram, New York (16 mi)
Westbury, New York (18 mi)
Freeport, New York (18 mi)
Woman sitting next to storage boxes

Types of Storage

Renting a storage unit is a great way to keep your belongings safe and secure. It can also be a cost-effective way to store items out of the way without taking up extra room in your home. Here are some of the benefits of different types of storage units:

  • Drive-up: These units provide easy access to your items, making it easier to move them in and out.
  • Interior without climate control: These units offer extra security and protection from the elements.
  • Interior with climate control: These units offer additional protection from the elements, as well as climate control to protect sensitive items.
  • Outdoor parking: These units provide a great option for storing vehicles and other large items.
  • Specialty self storage units: These units are designed to store items of special size and shape, like boats, RVs, and ATVs. They can also be used for commercial storage needs.
Woman with stack of storage boxes

Choosing a Storage Unit

Choosing a storage unit in Bay Shore, New York can be a challenge with the right considerations. Here are a few factors to think about when selecting a storage unit:

  • Proximity to your home or business: Consider the distance and ease of access of the storage unit from your property.
  • Size of the unit: Make sure that the unit is big enough to fit all of your belongings.
  • Protection from the elements: Look for storage units that have protection from the weather and pests.
  • Security features: Consider the security measures the storage unit offers, such as locks, cameras, and access control.
  • On-site staff: Make sure to inquire about any on-site staff that can provide additional security and assistance.
Neighbors greeting each other while moving storage boxes

Climate Considerations

When looking to rent a storage unit in Bay Shore, New York, it is important to consider the climate and weather of the area. During the peak summer months, the average high temperature is around 83°F, while the average low temperature in peak winter months is around 29°F. Climate-controlled storage is beneficial for items that require a consistent temperature year-round, such as electronics, photographs, or any item that might be damaged by extreme temperatures. Non-climate-controlled storage is beneficial for items that are not as vulnerable to temperature fluctuations, such as furniture, books, or metal items.

To protect items stored in non-climate-controlled storage, it is important to take precautions such as using airtight boxes for sensitive items like books or documents to prevent damage from moisture. Additionally, make sure to leave a space between the storage unit wall and the items you are storing, as this will help prevent condensation.

Overall, climate-controlled storage can help protect certain items that are sensitive to extreme temperatures and moisture, while non-climate-controlled storage is beneficial for items that are not as vulnerable. By taking certain precautions and understanding the climate and weather of Bay Shore, New York, you can be sure to store your items safely and effectively.

About Bay Shore

Bay Shore, New York is a charming small city located on Long Island in the Town of Islip. Bay Shore offers an abundance of recreation and leisure activities, making it an attractive place to live. The city is bordered by the Great South Bay on the south and the Town of Islip on the north. Bay Shore offers residents with access to some of the best local beaches and parks, including Southward Ho Country Club, Fire Island National Seashore, and Robert Moses State Park.

Bay Shore is home to several well-regarded medical facilities, including Brookhaven Memorial Hospital Medical Center, Good Samaritan Hospital Medical Center, and Southside Hospital. The city also boasts a variety of educational opportunities, from its public schools and private schools to its higher education institutions, such as Dowling College, Suffolk County Community College, and St. Joseph’s College.

Residents of Bay Shore enjoy a variety of shopping and dining options, ranging from unique boutiques and restaurants to larger chains and stores. Bay Shore is also home to numerous cultural and entertainment venues, including the Bay Shore Arts & Culture Council, the Bay Shore Historical Society, and the Fire Island Dance Festival.

Bay Shore is a wonderful city offering a variety of activities and attractions to its residents. With its proximity to major cities and its range of local amenities, Bay Shore is an ideal place to call home.

FAQs About self storage in Bay Shore, New York

Several factors affect the pricing of self storage in Bay Shore, including unit size, location, facility amenities, demand, and duration of stay. Comparing rates and features of different storage facilities in the area can help you find the most cost-effective option.

To select the right size of a storage unit in Bay Shore, consider the number and dimensions of items you plan to store and allow some room for future storage needs. You can also consult with storage facility staff for their expertise in determining the appropriate unit size based on your belongings.

When preparing your belongings for long-term self storage in Bay Shore, make sure to clean and dry items thoroughly, and use appropriate packing materials to protect them from damage. It is recommended to use climate-controlled storage units for sensitive items, disassemble large furniture, and store items in clear, labeled containers. Additionally, keep a detailed inventory of the stored items for easy reference.

Alternative Self Storage Options near Bay Shore

Even though Neighbor has the lower-priced, more secure, and nearest self storage, storage facilities could also be a potential option for self storage in Bay Shore, NY.

Look at the list of self storage facilities for details:

Extra Space Storage (0 miles)

1775 5th Ave

Bay Shore, NY

Prime Storage (0.6 miles)

99 Pine Aire Dr

Bay Shore, NY

Public Storage (2.7 miles)

122 Saxon Ave

Bay Shore, NY

Life Storage - Bay Shore (2.7 miles)

110 Saxon Ave

Bay Shore, NY

Extra Space Storage (2.7 miles)

200 Express Dr S

Brentwood, NY

Public Storage (7.8 miles)

775 Nesconset Hwy

Nesconset, NY

Simply Self Storage (8 miles)

1070 Route 109

Lindenhurst, NY

U-Haul Moving & Storage of Huntington Station (8.7 miles)

85 E Jericho Tpke

Huntington Station, NY

Life Storage - Farmingdale (9.4 miles)

1 Executive Blvd

Farmingdale, NY

Public Storage (11.5 miles)

601 Sunrise Hwy

Patchogue, NY

iStorage Self Storage (12.2 miles)

257 Waverly Ave

Patchogue, NY

Life Storage (14.1 miles)

65 W John St

Hicksville, NY