•  50% cheaper
  •  14x safer
  •  Right next door

Self storage units in Bay Shore, NY

19 x 19 Garage in Islip, New York near [object Object]

Garage

|

19’ × 19

Islip, New York

1.8 mi

near 25 Bay 3rd St

Electricity Available

Security Camera

Locked Area

$135

  1st month

$270/ mo


20 x 7 Attic in Lindenhurst, New York near [object Object]

Attic

|

20’ × 7

Lindenhurst, New York

7.3 mi

near 137 Inlet Dr

Private Space

Security Camera

Locked Area

$49

  1st month

$98/ mo


20 x 10 Garage in St James, New York near [object Object]

Garage

|

20’ × 10

5.0

St James, New York

12.1 mi

near 440 Nissequogue River Rd

Electricity Available

Private Entrance

Security Camera

$110

  1st month

$220/ mo


9 x 5 Basement in Massapequa, New York near [object Object]

Basement

6 sizes available

Massapequa, New York

10.3 mi

near 64 Roosevelt Blvd

Private Entrance

Security Camera

Locked Area


30 x 10 Garage in Deer Park, New York near [object Object]

Garage

|

30’ × 10

Deer Park, New York

5.3 mi

near August Rd

Locked Area

Smoke Free

No Stairs

$178/ mo


20 x 20 Basement in Lindenhurst, New York near [object Object]

Basement

|

20’ × 20

Lindenhurst, New York

7.5 mi

near 668 N Indiana Ave

Private Entrance

Security Camera

Locked Area

$156.50

  1st month

$313/ mo


9 x 9 Bedroom in Bayport, New York near [object Object]

Bedroom

2 sizes available

Bayport, New York

10.5 mi

near 1598 Lakeview Ave

Private Space

Locked Area

Smoke Free


16 x 10 Garage in North Babylon, New York near [object Object]

Garage

|

16’ × 10

North Babylon, New York

5.2 mi

near August Rd

Private Entrance

Smoke Free

$49

  1st month

$98/ mo


12 x 10 Shed in Patchogue, New York near [object Object]

Shed

|

12’ × 10

Patchogue, New York

11.8 mi

near 73 N Summit Ave

Private Entrance

$46

  1st month

$92/ mo



19 x 13 Basement in Commack, New York near [object Object]

2 sizes available

Commack, New York

8.9 mi

near 19 Cameo Rd

Private Entrance

Smoke Free

Climate Controlled


33 x 11 Basement in Bethpage, New York near [object Object]

Basement

|

33’ × 11

5.0

Bethpage, New York

12.1 mi

near 98 Cherry Ave

Private Space

Climate Controlled

Smoke Detectors

$175

  1st month

$350/ mo




20 x 10 Garage in Farmingdale, New York near [object Object]

Garage

|

20’ × 10

Farmingdale, New York

8.9 mi

near 610 Broadhollow Rd

Private Entrance

Security Camera

Locked Area

$495/ mo


10 x 6 Garage in Massapequa, New York near [object Object]

Garage

|

10’ × 6

Massapequa, New York

10.5 mi

near 87 Nassau Rd

Private Entrance

Locked Area

Smoke Free

$175/ mo


35 x 35 Other in Massapequa, New York near [object Object]

Other

|

35’ × 35

Massapequa, New York

9.9 mi

near 908 Carmans Rd

$1,000/ mo


100 x 100 Warehouse in Farmingdale, New York near [object Object]

Warehouse

|

100’ × 100

Farmingdale, New York

9 mi

near 610 Broadhollow Rd

Security Camera

Locked Area

Smoke Free

$1,144.50

  1st month

$2,289/ mo

View more options

Browse similar storage listings nearby

Wyandanch, New York (6 mi)
Lindenhurst, New York (7 mi)
North Lindenhurst, New York (7 mi)
Lake Grove, New York (11 mi)
Huntington Station, New York (12 mi)
Patchogue, New York (12 mi)

How Neighbor compares to traditional storage facilities

badge w/star

Neighbor

Traditional facilities

Wide variety of sizes

Lowest prices

Highest safety rating

Protection plans

Nationwide availability

Verified hosts

View reviews for Neighbor

Discover more Bay Shore, NY storage by type

Select storage type

24 hour storage
monthly parking
RV storage
boat storage
long term parking
car storage
truck parking
parking spaces

FAQs About self storage in Bay Shore, New York

Several factors affect the pricing of self storage in Bay Shore, including unit size, location, facility amenities, demand, and duration of stay. Comparing rates and features of different storage facilities in the area can help you find the most cost-effective option.

To select the right size of a storage unit in Bay Shore, consider the number and dimensions of items you plan to store and allow some room for future storage needs. You can also consult with storage facility staff for their expertise in determining the appropriate unit size based on your belongings.

When preparing your belongings for long-term self storage in Bay Shore, make sure to clean and dry items thoroughly, and use appropriate packing materials to protect them from damage. It is recommended to use climate-controlled storage units for sensitive items, disassemble large furniture, and store items in clear, labeled containers. Additionally, keep a detailed inventory of the stored items for easy reference.

Alternative Self Storage Options near Bay Shore

Even though Neighbor has the lower-priced, more secure, and nearest self storage, storage facilities could also be a potential option for self storage in Bay Shore, NY.

Look at the list of self storage facilities for details:

Prime Storage (0 miles)

99 Pine Aire Dr Bay Shore, NY

Extra Space Storage (0.6 miles)

1775 5th Ave Bay Shore, NY

StorQuest Self Storage (1.9 miles)

960 Grand Blvd Deer Park, NY

Extra Space Storage (2.2 miles)

200 Express Dr S Brentwood, NY

CubeSmart Self Storage (2.4 miles)

999 Long Island Ave Deer Park, NY

Life Storage (2.5 miles)

715 Grand Blvd Deer Park, NY

Manor Park Mini Warehousing (2.9 miles)

308 Commack Rd Deer Park, NY

Simply Self Storage (3 miles)

745 Old Willets Path Hauppauge, NY

Extra Space Storage (3 miles)

730 Old Willets Path Hauppauge, NY

CubeSmart Self Storage (3.1 miles)

240 Bay Shore Rd North Babylon, NY

Life Storage - Bay Shore (3.3 miles)

110 Saxon Ave Bay Shore, NY

Public Storage (3.3 miles)

122 Saxon Ave Bay Shore, NY

America Safe & Sound (3.4 miles)

1800 Prime Pl Hauppauge, NY

Extra Space Storage (3.5 miles)

1251 Deer Park Ave North Babylon, NY

CubeSmart Self Storage (3.7 miles)

59 Orinoco Dr Brightwaters, NY