Self storage units in Mastic Beach, NY

Lowest price: Starting at $45

  • Find a space or unit that can store your personal items at the lowest cost. Save 32%, on average, by booking with Neighbor compared to traditional storage facilities.

istorage.com

iStorage Self Storage

60 sizes available

4.7

257 Waverly Ave Patchogue, NY

8.9 mi

31% more expensive

Pros:

  • Friendly and helpful staff

  • Good location

  • Clean facility

  • Affordable pricing

Cons:

  • Hidden fees (ratings support user perception)

3'×5'

starting at

 

$45/ mo

3'×8'

starting at

 

$52/ mo

4'×5'

starting at

 

$35/ mo

4'×8'

starting at

 

$45/ mo

5'×5'

starting at

 

$56/ mo

5'×6'

starting at

 

$60/ mo

5'×7'

starting at

 

$66/ mo

5'×8'

starting at

 

$80/ mo

5'×9'

starting at

 

$90/ mo

6'×6'

starting at

 

$49/ mo

6'×7'

starting at

 

$56/ mo

6'×8'

starting at

 

$60/ mo

6'×9'

starting at

 

$66/ mo

7'×7'

starting at

 

$96/ mo

7'×8'

starting at

 

$66/ mo

8'×8'

starting at

 

$117/ mo

8'×9'

starting at

 

$76/ mo

10'×3'

starting at

 

$45/ mo

10'×4'

starting at

 

$56/ mo

10'×5'

starting at

 

$96/ mo

10'×6'

starting at

 

$111/ mo

10'×7'

starting at

 

$121/ mo

10'×8'

starting at

 

$127/ mo

10'×10'

starting at

 

$162/ mo

10'×11'

starting at

 

$172/ mo

10'×12'

starting at

 

$127/ mo

10'×13'

starting at

 

$137/ mo

10'×15'

starting at

 

$203/ mo

10'×16'

starting at

 

$223/ mo

10'×18'

starting at

 

$243/ mo

10'×20'

starting at

 

$264/ mo

10'×23'

starting at

 

$315/ mo

10'×25'

starting at

 

$407/ mo

11'×8'

starting at

 

$137/ mo

12'×5'

starting at

 

$70/ mo

12'×6'

starting at

 

$76/ mo

12'×13'

starting at

 

$141/ mo

12'×14'

starting at

 

$147/ mo

12'×16'

starting at

 

$162/ mo

12'×18'

starting at

 

$188/ mo

13'×4'

starting at

 

$66/ mo

13'×8'

starting at

 

$121/ mo

13'×13'

starting at

 

$147/ mo

13'×14'

starting at

 

$152/ mo

13'×16'

starting at

 

$182/ mo

13'×17'

starting at

 

$198/ mo

13'×18'

starting at

 

$366/ mo

14'×7'

starting at

 

$141/ mo

15'×7'

starting at

 

$168/ mo

15'×8'

starting at

 

$178/ mo

15'×16'

starting at

 

$631/ mo

15'×23'

starting at

 

$774/ mo

16'×5'

starting at

 

$127/ mo

16'×6'

starting at

 

$141/ mo

16'×8'

starting at

 

$182/ mo

18'×5'

starting at

 

$86/ mo

18'×6'

starting at

 

$121/ mo

20'×8'

starting at

 

$223/ mo

20'×20'

starting at

 

$815/ mo

30'×7'

starting at

 

$274/ mo

10'×3' starting at

$45


publicst...rage.com

Public Storage

7 sizes available

4.6

15 Andrea Rd Holbrook, NY

9.9 mi

36% more expensive

Pros:

  • Facility generally well maintained and clean

  • Helpful and friendly staff

  • Quick and efficient rental process

Cons:

  • High late fee charges

  • Issues with security doors and access codes

  • Infrequent staffing at front desk

  • Unpleasant customer service experiences

  • Unexpected substantial price increases

5'×5'

starting at

 

$46/ mo

5'×7'

starting at

 

$51/ mo

10'×5'

starting at

 

$58/ mo

10'×7'

starting at

 

$94/ mo

10'×10'

starting at

 

$134/ mo

10'×15'

starting at

 

$219/ mo

10'×20'

starting at

 

$279/ mo

10'×5' starting at

$58


istorage.com

iStorage Self Storage

10 sizes available

4.8

709 Church St Bayport, NY

9.9 mi

2.2x more expensive

Pros:

  • Clean and secure facility

  • Convenient location

  • Friendly and helpful staff

Cons:

  • Difficult to contact staff

  • Staff can be unavailable

5'×5'

starting at

 

$82/ mo

10'×3'

starting at

 

$62/ mo

10'×5'

starting at

 

$196/ mo

10'×10'

starting at

 

$329/ mo

10'×12'

starting at

 

$468/ mo

10'×15'

starting at

 

$517/ mo

10'×20'

starting at

 

$747/ mo

10'×25'

starting at

 

$729/ mo

10'×30'

starting at

 

$856/ mo

20'×20'

starting at

 

$1223/ mo

10'×3' starting at

$62


Closest to my location

  • Find self storage closest to you. You could find storage within a few blocks.

storquest.com

StorQuest Self Storage

13 sizes available

4.4

393 Smith Rd Shirley, NY

1.7 mi

78% more expensive

Pros:

  • Helpful and courteous staff

  • Clean property and storage units

  • Good customer service

  • Quick and easy process

Cons:

  • Rates regularly increase

  • Some items got mildew

  • Broken gate for almost 9 months

  • Misleading promotional offers

  • Elevator malfunctioned, causing inconvenience

3'×5'

starting at

 

$17/ mo

3'×17'

starting at

 

$150/ mo

4'×5'

starting at

 

$122/ mo

5'×5'

starting at

 

$84/ mo

5'×8'

starting at

 

$135/ mo

10'×5'

starting at

 

$135/ mo

10'×10'

starting at

 

$280/ mo

10'×15'

starting at

 

$371/ mo

10'×20'

starting at

 

$389/ mo

10'×25'

starting at

 

$497/ mo

12'×8'

starting at

 

$99/ mo

15'×5'

starting at

 

$126/ mo

25'×5'

starting at

 

$303/ mo

3'×5' starting at

$17


storager...east.com

Storage R Us

8 sizes available

3.9

192 Frowein Rd East Moriches, NY

4.9 mi

32% more expensive

Pros:

  • Fairly priced

  • Convenient automatic billing

Cons:

  • Poor customer service experiences

  • Reservation issues causing delays

  • Inconsistent equipment availability

  • Limited pick up and return times

5'×5'

starting at

 

$85/ mo

10'×5'

starting at

 

$109/ mo

10'×10'

starting at

 

$159/ mo

10'×15'

starting at

 

$209/ mo

10'×20'

starting at

 

$269/ mo

10'×30'

starting at

 

$349/ mo

15'×5'

starting at

 

$135/ mo

20'×5'

starting at

 

$149/ mo

5'×5' starting at

$85


60 x 30 Basement in Yaphank, New York near 275 E Main St, Yaphank, NY 11980-9628, United States

Basement


60’ × 30

Yaphank, NY

5.1 mi

near 275 E Main St

Climate Controlled

Smoke Free

Smoke Detectors

$500/ mo


Medium sized units: 5x5 - 10x15

  • Find medium to large self storage spaces that can fit items like furniture, beds, TVs, etc. Save up to 34% when booking on Neighbor compared to traditional storage facilities.

7 x 5 Self Storage Unit in Medford, New York near 810 Long Island Ave, Medford, NY 11763-2541, United States

Self Storage Unit


7’ × 5

Medford, NY

5.6 mi

near 810 Long Island Ave

Security Camera

Smoke Detectors

Smoke Free

$75/ mo


12 x 10 Shed in Patchogue, New York near 73 N Summit Ave, Patchogue, NY 11772-2226, United States

Shed


12’ × 10

Patchogue, NY

9 mi

near 73 N Summit Ave

Private Entrance

$44.50

  1st month

$89/ mo


devonsel...rage.com

Extra Space Storage

10 sizes available

4.9

84 Long Island Ave Yaphank, NY

5.3 mi

62% more expensive

Pros:

  • Facility is clean and well maintained

  • Safe and secure environment

  • Climate-controlled storage options available

    5'×5'

    starting at

     

    $50/ mo

    10'×5'

    starting at

     

    $89/ mo

    10'×7'

    starting at

     

    $133/ mo

    10'×10'

    starting at

     

    $177/ mo

    10'×14'

    starting at

     

    $157/ mo

    10'×15'

    starting at

     

    $219/ mo

    10'×20'

    starting at

     

    $370/ mo

    10'×25'

    starting at

     

    $454/ mo

    10'×30'

    starting at

     

    $474/ mo

    15'×15'

    starting at

     

    $349/ mo

    10'×14' starting at

    $157


    Drive-up access with your vehicle

    • Find spaces where you can drive up to load and unload items from a vehicle or truck.

    cubesmart.com

    Cubesmart Self Storage

    5 sizes available

    4.7

    120 River Ave Patchogue, NY

    8.7 mi

    67% more expensive

    Pros:

    • Fair and reasonable prices

    • Clean and well-maintained units

    • Easy and quick setup process

    • Safe and secure facility

      10'×5'

      starting at

       

      $139/ mo

      10'×15'

      starting at

       

      $287/ mo

      10'×20'

      starting at

       

      $247/ mo

      10'×25'

      starting at

       

      $424/ mo

      10'×30'

      starting at

       

      $444/ mo

      10'×5' starting at

      $139


      devonsel...rage.com

      Extra Space Storage

      10 sizes available

      4.9

      84 Long Island Ave Yaphank, NY

      5.3 mi

      62% more expensive

      5'×5'

      starting at

       

      $50/ mo

      10'×5'

      starting at

       

      $89/ mo

      10'×7'

      starting at

       

      $133/ mo

      10'×10'

      starting at

       

      $177/ mo

      10'×14'

      starting at

       

      $157/ mo

      10'×15'

      starting at

       

      $219/ mo

      10'×20'

      starting at

       

      $370/ mo

      10'×25'

      starting at

       

      $454/ mo

      10'×30'

      starting at

       

      $474/ mo

      15'×15'

      starting at

       

      $349/ mo

      5'×5' starting at

      $50


      istorage.com

      iStorage Self Storage

      60 sizes available

      4.7

      257 Waverly Ave Patchogue, NY

      8.9 mi

      31% more expensive

      3'×5'

      starting at

       

      $45/ mo

      3'×8'

      starting at

       

      $52/ mo

      4'×5'

      starting at

       

      $35/ mo

      4'×8'

      starting at

       

      $45/ mo

      5'×5'

      starting at

       

      $56/ mo

      5'×6'

      starting at

       

      $60/ mo

      5'×7'

      starting at

       

      $66/ mo

      5'×8'

      starting at

       

      $80/ mo

      5'×9'

      starting at

       

      $90/ mo

      6'×6'

      starting at

       

      $49/ mo

      6'×7'

      starting at

       

      $56/ mo

      6'×8'

      starting at

       

      $60/ mo

      6'×9'

      starting at

       

      $66/ mo

      7'×7'

      starting at

       

      $96/ mo

      7'×8'

      starting at

       

      $66/ mo

      8'×8'

      starting at

       

      $117/ mo

      8'×9'

      starting at

       

      $76/ mo

      10'×3'

      starting at

       

      $45/ mo

      10'×4'

      starting at

       

      $56/ mo

      10'×5'

      starting at

       

      $96/ mo

      10'×6'

      starting at

       

      $111/ mo

      10'×7'

      starting at

       

      $121/ mo

      10'×8'

      starting at

       

      $127/ mo

      10'×10'

      starting at

       

      $162/ mo

      10'×11'

      starting at

       

      $172/ mo

      10'×12'

      starting at

       

      $127/ mo

      10'×13'

      starting at

       

      $137/ mo

      10'×15'

      starting at

       

      $203/ mo

      10'×16'

      starting at

       

      $223/ mo

      10'×18'

      starting at

       

      $243/ mo

      10'×20'

      starting at

       

      $264/ mo

      10'×23'

      starting at

       

      $315/ mo

      10'×25'

      starting at

       

      $407/ mo

      11'×8'

      starting at

       

      $137/ mo

      12'×5'

      starting at

       

      $70/ mo

      12'×6'

      starting at

       

      $76/ mo

      12'×13'

      starting at

       

      $141/ mo

      12'×14'

      starting at

       

      $147/ mo

      12'×16'

      starting at

       

      $162/ mo

      12'×18'

      starting at

       

      $188/ mo

      13'×4'

      starting at

       

      $66/ mo

      13'×8'

      starting at

       

      $121/ mo

      13'×13'

      starting at

       

      $147/ mo

      13'×14'

      starting at

       

      $152/ mo

      13'×16'

      starting at

       

      $182/ mo

      13'×17'

      starting at

       

      $198/ mo

      13'×18'

      starting at

       

      $366/ mo

      14'×7'

      starting at

       

      $141/ mo

      15'×7'

      starting at

       

      $168/ mo

      15'×8'

      starting at

       

      $178/ mo

      15'×16'

      starting at

       

      $631/ mo

      15'×23'

      starting at

       

      $774/ mo

      16'×5'

      starting at

       

      $127/ mo

      16'×6'

      starting at

       

      $141/ mo

      16'×8'

      starting at

       

      $182/ mo

      18'×5'

      starting at

       

      $86/ mo

      18'×6'

      starting at

       

      $121/ mo

      20'×8'

      starting at

       

      $223/ mo

      20'×20'

      starting at

       

      $815/ mo

      30'×7'

      starting at

       

      $274/ mo

      4'×5' starting at

      $35


      Climate controlled storage

      • Find self storage spaces to keep your belongings dry, temperate, and secure Climate controlled storage costs, on average, $78 more per month than other units in Mastic Beach.

      150 x 50 Basement in Medford, New York near 115 W Bartlett Rd, Middle Island, NY 11953-1818, United States

      Basement


      150’ × 50

      Medford, NY

      7.3 mi

      near 115 W Bartlett Rd

      Smoke Detectors

      Climate Controlled

      Pet Free

      $910

        1st month

      $1,820/ mo


      60 x 30 Basement in Yaphank, New York near 275 E Main St, Yaphank, NY 11980-9628, United States

      Basement


      60’ × 30

      Yaphank, NY

      5.1 mi

      near 275 E Main St

      Climate Controlled

      Smoke Free

      Smoke Detectors

      $500/ mo


      Business storage

      • Find storage for all your Mastic Beach business needs like inventory, equipment, boxes, tools, etc.

      extraspace.com

      Extra Space Storage

      7 sizes available

      4.8

      970 Waverly Ave Holtsville, NY

      10 mi

      59% more expensive

      Pros:

      • Clean units and overall property

      • User-friendly online rental management

      • Well-lit and secure facility

      Cons:

      • Significant price increase after a few months

      10'×5'

      starting at

       

      $131/ mo

      10'×10'

      starting at

       

      $212/ mo

      10'×15'

      starting at

       

      $292/ mo

      10'×20'

      starting at

       

      $348/ mo

      10'×30'

      starting at

       

      $478/ mo

      15'×5'

      starting at

       

      $174/ mo

      20'×9'

      starting at

       

      $142/ mo

      15'×5' starting at

      $174


      cubesmart.com

      Cubesmart Self Storage

      5 sizes available

      4.7

      120 River Ave Patchogue, NY

      8.7 mi

      67% more expensive

      10'×5'

      starting at

       

      $139/ mo

      10'×15'

      starting at

       

      $287/ mo

      10'×20'

      starting at

       

      $247/ mo

      10'×25'

      starting at

       

      $424/ mo

      10'×30'

      starting at

       

      $444/ mo

      10'×5' starting at

      $139


      publicst...rage.com

      Public Storage

      6 sizes available

      4.8

      550 Middle Country Rd Coram, NY

      10 mi

      62% more expensive

      Pros:

      • Easy registration and setup process

      • Staff is very professional and helpful

      • Mobile entry app for easy access

      Cons:

      • Significant rent increases over time

      • Costs could be high for long-term renters

      5'×5'

      starting at

       

      $82/ mo

      10'×5'

      starting at

       

      $120/ mo

      10'×7'

      starting at

       

      $138/ mo

      10'×10'

      starting at

       

      $172/ mo

      10'×15'

      starting at

       

      $246/ mo

      10'×30'

      starting at

       

      $369/ mo

      10'×5' starting at

      $120


      Smaller units: 5x5 and below

      • Find self storage spaces that can fit most items in a bedroom or closet. Mastic Beach spaces on Neighbor are 22% less expensive, on average, than traditional storage facilities.

      publicst...rage.com

      Public Storage

      4 sizes available

      4.9

      601 Sunrise Hwy Patchogue, NY

      9.6 mi

      16% less expensive

      Pros:

      • Helpful and friendly customer service

      • Assistance with locks and payments

      • Knowledgeable and attentive staff

      • Smooth overall experience

      • Reasonably priced units

      Cons:

      • Reports of stolen items

      • Roach infestation

      • Dampness and spider webs

      • Dysfunctional lighting in units

      5'×5'

      starting at

       

      $47/ mo

      10'×5'

      starting at

       

      $74/ mo

      10'×10'

      starting at

       

      $105/ mo

      10'×15'

      starting at

       

      $205/ mo

      5'×5' starting at

      $47


      U-Haul M... Medford

      U-Haul Moving & Storage Of Medford

      7 sizes available

      3118 Horseblock Rd Medford, NY

      7.2 mi

      66% more expensive

      Pros:

      • Plenty of parking space

      • Clean and organized facility

      • 24-hour storage access available

      • Convenient after-hours returns

      Cons:

      • Poor communication about storage unit auctions

      • Frequent trouble with U-Box delivery scheduling

      • Often hard to reach customer service

      • Inconvenience caused by engrossed staff

      5'×5'

      starting at

       

      $75/ mo

      10'×5'

      starting at

       

      $140/ mo

      10'×8'

      starting at

       

      $220/ mo

      10'×10'

      starting at

       

      $240/ mo

      10'×15'

      starting at

       

      $290/ mo

      10'×20'

      starting at

       

      $385/ mo

      15'×5'

      starting at

       

      $215/ mo

      5'×5' starting at

      $75


      storager...east.com

      Storage R Us

      8 sizes available

      3.9

      192 Frowein Rd East Moriches, NY

      4.9 mi

      32% more expensive

      5'×5'

      starting at

       

      $85/ mo

      10'×5'

      starting at

       

      $109/ mo

      10'×10'

      starting at

       

      $159/ mo

      10'×15'

      starting at

       

      $209/ mo

      10'×20'

      starting at

       

      $269/ mo

      10'×30'

      starting at

       

      $349/ mo

      15'×5'

      starting at

       

      $135/ mo

      20'×5'

      starting at

       

      $149/ mo

      5'×5' starting at

      $85


      Larger units: 10x15 and above

      • Find large self storage spaces that can fit several items like furniture, beds, TVs, etc. All in a single unit. Neighbor offers large self storage in Mastic Beach up to 47% cheaper than traditional storage facilities.

      15 x 15 Shed in Medford, New York near 810 Long Island Ave, Medford, NY 11763-2541, United States

      Shed


      15’ × 15

      Medford, NY

      6.2 mi

      near 810 Long Island Ave

      Private Entrance

      No Stairs

      Smoke Free

      $69

        1st month

      $138/ mo


      150 x 50 Basement in Medford, New York near 115 W Bartlett Rd, Middle Island, NY 11953-1818, United States

      Basement


      150’ × 50

      Medford, NY

      7.3 mi

      near 115 W Bartlett Rd

      Smoke Detectors

      Climate Controlled

      Pet Free

      $910

        1st month

      $1,820/ mo


      publicst...rage.com

      Public Storage

      4 sizes available

      4.9

      601 Sunrise Hwy Patchogue, NY

      9.6 mi

      16% less expensive

      5'×5'

      starting at

       

      $47/ mo

      10'×5'

      starting at

       

      $74/ mo

      10'×10'

      starting at

       

      $105/ mo

      10'×15'

      starting at

       

      $205/ mo

      10'×15' starting at

      $205


      Find nearby storage locations

      Brookhaven, New York (3 mi)
      Patchogue, New York (9 mi)
      Lake Grove, New York (14 mi)

      How Neighbor compares to traditional storage facilities

      badge w/star

      Neighbor

      Traditional facilities

      Wide variety of sizes

      Lowest prices

      Highest safety rating

      Protection plans

      Nationwide availability

      Verified hosts

      Manage rental online

      View reviews for Neighbor

      Storage facility cost comparison

      5×5

      5×10

      10×10

      10×20

      10×30

      10×40

      Average storage facility

      Mastic Beach, NY

      $81

      $115

      $201

      $363

      $495

      --

      Neighbor

      6 storage spaces nearby

      StorQuest Self Storage

      Shirley, NY (2 miles)

      $84

      $99

      $280

      $389

      --

      --

      Storage R Us

      East Moriches, NY (5 miles)

      $85

      $109

      $159

      $269

      $349

      --

      Extra Space Storage

      Yaphank, NY (5 miles)

      $50

      $89

      $157

      $370

      $474

      --

      Storage for Rent in Mastic Beach, NY

      Select storage type

      truck parking
      boat storage
      car storage
      RV storage
      long term parking
      monthly parking

      What’s the best self storage option for you?

      Compare the pros and cons of renting from various storage unit options, including drive-up and interior units

      Drive-up Exterior Units
      open view of an empty garage

      Enclosed drive-up storage units, like garages, have an outdoor entrance

      61% of storage spaces in Mastic Beach have security cameras as an amenity provided by the host

      Find drive-up storage
      Interior-Access Storage Units
      row of indoor storage lockers

      Indoor spaces like vacant offices or residential rooms offer increased protection

      In Mastic Beach, 53% of listings do not have stairs leading to the storage space, allowing for easy access

      Find indoor storage units
      Vehicle Storage Units
      view of a half-closed garage with a car inside

      Indoor storage units that allow vehicles provide protection over outdoor parking

      Residential indoor parking in Mastic Beach is typically a similar price to surrounding areas

      Find car storage units

      Alternative Self Storage Facilities near Mastic Beach

      Although Neighbor usually features the most cost-friendly, most secure, and nearest self storage, storage facilities may also be another choice for self storage in Mastic Beach, NY.

      If you'd like information about traditional storage facilities in Mastic Beach, NY, look at the below list for more information:

      Extra Space Storage (5.3 miles)

      84 Long Island Ave Yaphank, NY

      Public Storage (9.6 miles)

      601 Sunrise Hwy Patchogue, NY

      iStorage Self Storage (8.9 miles)

      257 Waverly Ave Patchogue, NY

      Storage R Us (4.9 miles)

      192 Frowein Rd East Moriches, NY

      Cubesmart Self Storage (8.7 miles)

      120 River Ave Patchogue, NY

      StorQuest Self Storage (1.7 miles)

      393 Smith Rd Shirley, NY

      Public Storage (9.9 miles)

      15 Andrea Rd Holbrook, NY

      U-Haul Moving & Storage Of Medford (7.2 miles)

      3118 Horseblock Rd Medford, NY

      Extra Space Storage (10 miles)

      970 Waverly Ave Holtsville, NY

      Public Storage (10 miles)

      550 Middle Country Rd Coram, NY

      Life Storage (9.1 miles)

      500 Sunrise Hwy Patchogue, NY

      iStorage Self Storage (9.9 miles)

      709 Church St Bayport, NY

      U-Haul Moving & Storage of Coram (9.9 miles)

      532 Middle Country Rd Coram, NY

      Need self storage in Mastic Beach?

      Neighbor is the world’s largest storage marketplace. Call for rates or search online for the cheapest, closest, and safest storage units.

      (844) 448-0855