Self storage units in Middle Island, NY
Neighbor reviews near Middle Island, NY
5.0 (6,876 reviews)
Based on 6,876 verified reviews, renters rated Neighbor's service for finding self storage units in Middle Island 5.0 out of 5 on average
Closest units to my location
Closest units average 3.5 miles away with host response time within 24 minutes.
Storage unit prices range from $18 to $500 with average $284.
64% of units have climate control, 73% have drive-up access.
Search your zip code:
- 11953
Not affiliated with Neighbor
Extra Space Storage
Yaphank, NY
4.7 mi
84 Long Island Ave Yaphank, NY
4.9
Pros: facility is clean and well maintained, safe and secure environment, climate-controlled storage options available
starting at
$74
per month
Not affiliated with Neighbor
Prime Storage
Port Jefferson Station, NY
4.8 mi
1184 Route 112 Port Jefferson Station, NY
4.3
Pros: clean and well-maintained facility, very secure with security measures, friendly and helpful staff, convenient location and accessible unitsCons: frequent and significant price increases, some units not the advertised size, difficulties with online payment processing, inconsistent promotion and discount policies
starting at
$69
per month
Not affiliated with Neighbor
U-Haul Moving & Storage Of Medford
Medford, NY
5.0 mi
3118 Horseblock Rd Medford, NY
Pros: plenty of parking space, clean and organized facility, 24-hour storage access available, convenient after-hours returnsCons: poor communication about storage unit auctions, frequent trouble with u-box delivery scheduling, often hard to reach customer service, inconvenience caused by engrossed staff
starting at
$75
per month
Not affiliated with Neighbor
Prime Storage
Centereach, NY
6.6 mi
21 Hammond Rd Centereach, NY
4.3
Pros: clean and well-organized facility, easy access and secure location, helpful and professional staff, reasonable pricingCons: inconsistent invoicing and due dates, confusing insurance requirements, poor customer service experiences, quick freezes on unit access
starting at
$56
per month
Self Storage Unit
20×10
Port Jefferson, NY
6.9 mi
225 Sheep Pasture Rd Port Jefferson, New York
5.0
Pet Free
No Stairs
starting at
$338
per month
Attic
24×11
Centereach, NY
7.4 mi
Near 93 Forest Rd
Smoke Free
Private Entrance
$150
per month
Not affiliated with Neighbor
StorQuest Self Storage
Shirley, NY
7.4 mi
393 Smith Rd Shirley, NY
4.4
Pros: helpful and courteous staff, clean property and storage units, good customer service, quick and easy processCons: rates regularly increase, some items got mildew, broken gate for almost 9 months, misleading promotional offers, elevator malfunctioned, causing inconvenience
starting at
$25
per month
Garage
20×20
Setauket- East Setauket, NY
8.0 mi
Near 54 N Belle Mead Rd
5.0
Pet Free
No Stairs
$249
per month
Not affiliated with Neighbor
Extra Space Storage
Coram, NY
3.1 mi
2025 Route 112 Coram, NY
4.8
Pros: units are clean and well-maintained., location is safe and secure., helpful and friendly staff., conveniently located with a variety of unit sizes.Cons: website and online process can be confusing., high curbs at some units., some units smaller than listed dimensions.
starting at
$29
per month
Not affiliated with Neighbor
Extra Space Storage
Ridge, NY
3.9 mi
14 Francis Mooney Dr Ridge, NY
4.8
Pros: good customer service and friendly staff, smooth and efficient rental process, competitive pricing for storage units
starting at
$106
per month
Not affiliated with Neighbor
Extra Space Storage
Holtsville, NY
7.4 mi
970 Waverly Ave Holtsville, NY
4.8
Pros: clean units and overall property, user-friendly online rental management, well-lit and secure facilityCons: significant price increase after a few months
starting at
$66
per month
Cheap prices: Starting at $40
Average price of lowest options is $143; smallest unit costs $17.
75% of units are under $200; great deals for budget shoppers.
50% of units offer convenient 24-hour access; drive-up units available.
Not affiliated with Neighbor
StorQuest Self Storage
Shirley, NY
7.4 mi
393 Smith Rd Shirley, NY
4.4
Pros: helpful and courteous staff, clean property and storage units, good customer service, quick and easy processCons: rates regularly increase, some items got mildew, broken gate for almost 9 months, misleading promotional offers, elevator malfunctioned, causing inconvenience
starting at
$111
per month
Not affiliated with Neighbor
Extra Space Storage
Coram, NY
3.1 mi
2025 Route 112 Coram, NY
4.8
Pros: units are clean and well-maintained., location is safe and secure., helpful and friendly staff., conveniently located with a variety of unit sizes.Cons: website and online process can be confusing., high curbs at some units., some units smaller than listed dimensions.
starting at
$142
per month
Not affiliated with Neighbor
Extra Space Storage
Ridge, NY
3.9 mi
14 Francis Mooney Dr Ridge, NY
4.8
Pros: good customer service and friendly staff, smooth and efficient rental process, competitive pricing for storage units
starting at
$148
per month
Not affiliated with Neighbor
Extra Space Storage
Holtsville, NY
7.4 mi
970 Waverly Ave Holtsville, NY
4.8
Pros: clean units and overall property, user-friendly online rental management, well-lit and secure facilityCons: significant price increase after a few months
starting at
$591
per month
How Neighbor compares to traditional storage facilities
Neighbor
Neighbor
Traditional facilities
Traditional facilities
Wide variety of sizes
Wide variety of sizes
Lowest prices
Lowest prices
Highest safety rating
Highest safety rating
Protection plans
Protection plans
Nationwide availability
Nationwide availability
Verified hosts
Verified hosts
Manage rental online
Manage rental online
Storage facility cost comparison
5×5 | 10×10 | 10×20 | 10×30 | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
Average storage facility Middle Island, NY | $94 | $239 | $371 | $577 |
Neighbor 28 storage spaces nearby | ||||
Extra Space Storage Coram, NY (3 miles) | $61 | $336 | $338 | -- |
Extra Space Storage Ridge, NY (4 miles) | $106 | $235 | $412 | -- |
Extra Space Storage Yaphank, NY (5 miles) | $74 | $227 | $377 | $683 |
Storage for Rent in Middle Island, NY
Select storage type
What’s the best self storage option for you?
Compare the pros and cons of renting from various storage unit options, including drive-up and interior units
Drive-up Exterior Units
Enclosed drive-up storage units, like garages, have an outdoor entrance
18% of storage spaces in Middle Island have security cameras as an amenity provided by the host
Interior-Access Storage Units
Indoor spaces like vacant offices or residential rooms offer increased protection
In Middle Island, 100% of listings do not have stairs leading to the storage space, allowing for easy access
Vehicle Storage Units
Indoor storage units that allow vehicles provide protection over outdoor parking
Residential indoor parking in Middle Island is typically a similar price to surrounding areas
Additional New York self storage locations
Alternative Self Storage Facilities near Middle Island
Middle Island offers many different traditional self storage companies for self storage. Traditional self storage, however, are usually more expensive, less safe, and typically farther way than Neighbor.com.
Reference the list of self storage facilities for details:
Need self storage in Middle Island?
Neighbor is the world’s largest storage marketplace. Call for rates or search online for the cheapest, closest, and safest storage units.
(844) 448-0855