1-15 of 18 self-storage locations near Shirley
Prime Storage
235 William Floyd Pkwy, Shirley, NY 11967
Shirley, NY
1.4 mi
4.3
Prime Storage
3220 Horseblock Rd., Medford, NY 11763
Medford, NY
6.2 mi
4.3
Public Storage
601 W Sunrise Highway
Holbrook, NY
8.6 mi
5.0
Prime Storage
21 Hammond Rd., Centereach, NY 11720
Centereach, NY
11.7 mi
4.3
Public Storage
15 Andrea Rd
Holbrook, NY
9.0 mi
5.0
Public Storage
951 HorseBlock Road
Farmingville, NY
8.5 mi
4.9
Prime Storage
868 Lincoln Ave, Bohemia, NY 11716
Sayville, NY
10.9 mi
4.3
Prime Storage
1184 Route 112, Port Jefferson, NY 11776
Port Jefferson Station, NY
12.8 mi
4.3
Public Storage
363 Portion Road
Ronkonkoma, NY
12.1 mi
4.9
Prime Storage
98 Depot Rd
Westhampton, NY
12.3 mi
4.3
Public Storage
225 Sheep Pasture Rd
East Setauket, NY
14.8 mi
5.0
Prime Storage
625 Eastview Dr, Central Islip, NY 11722
Central Islip, NY
16.5 mi
4.3
Public Storage
122 Saxon Ave
Islip, NY
18.7 mi
5.0
Neighbor reviews in Shirley
4.7
(2,207 reviews)
Andrew P.
September 2025
Verified Review
M
Muhammad R.
September 2025
Verified Review
S
Silvia S.
February 2026
Verified Review
C
Chris L.
June 2024
Verified Review
M
Marshall A.
December 2024
Verified Review
Bret H.
April 2025
Verified Review
The Neighbor rating for self storage hosts in Shirley is a rating based on verified reviews from our comunity of renters who have booked with these hosts to meet their storage needs. Last updated February 2026
All the storage. One search.
Neighbor is the only self-storage marketplace that brings every option in Shirley together in one search - traditional storage units, local garages, and unique spaces you won’t find anywhere else. No more calling around or guessing if you’ve found the right fit. See all 18 options side by side, book instantly online, and get the space you need, right where you need it.
Other types of storage in Shirley
Looking for something beyond self-storage? Choose from RV storage, boat storage, monthly parking, and more.
Shirley self-storage units by size
Explore our most common unit sizes. Not sure which size you need? Check out our storage unit size guide to find out which size storage unit is your best fit.
Popular sizes
Which self-storage unit type is right for you?
Find the perfect fit by comparing all of our options, including climate-controlled units, 24-hour access, drive-up access, vehicle storage, and indoor storage units.
Climate-controlled units
Climate controlled storage keeps a stable temperature and humidity year‑round. Ideal for electronics, furniture, documents, and other sensitive items.
Protects sensitive items
Prevents damage & mold
Year‑round temperature control
24‑hour access
Storage units with 24‑hour access let you access your belongings anytime, when it’s most convenient for you. Great for busy schedules, or small businesses needing flexibility.
Access anytime
Perfect for moving
Fits busy schedules
Drive‑up access
Garages and certain ground‑level storage spaces that let you pull right up to your unit for easy loading and unloading.
Easy loading & unloading
No stairs, no elevators, or hallways
Great for bulky or heavy items
Vehicle storage & parking
Enclosed, covered outdoor, or uncovered outdoor vehicle storage spaces. Also great for boats, RVs, trailers, and more.
Cars, boats, RVs, & more
Vehicle storage for business
Enclosed, covered, or outdoor
Indoor storage units
Also called interior storage units, these units have a secure entrance that is located within a building, creating an extra layer of security and protection from the outdoors.
Enhanced security
Protection from weather and pests
Comfortable access
Other self-storage facilities near Shirley
Neighbor is the largest storage and parking marketplace in the U.S., making it easy to compare trusted facilities and neighborhood options in Shirley. Below are more self-storage facilities in your area you might like.
Extra Space Storage
84 Long Island Ave, NY
4.7 mi
Bayport Mini Storage
915 Montauk Hwy, NY
9.2 mi
iStorage Self Storage
257 Waverly Ave, NY
7.9 mi
Storage R Us Inc
10 Frowein Rd, NY
5.5 mi
StorQuest Self Storage
393 Smith Rd, NY
1.5 mi
Extra Space Storage
14 Francis Mooney Dr, NY
8.2 mi
Extra Space Storage
970 Waverly Ave, NY
9.2 mi
iStorage Self Storage
709 Church St, NY
9.0 mi
Metro Self Storage - Westhampton Beach
105 Old Riverhead Rd, NY
12.4 mi