Extra Space Storage in Bay Shore, NY

1775 5th Ave, Bay Shore, NY 11706

(631) 210-6603

  • Monday

    9:30 am - 6:00 pm

  • Tuesday

    9:30 am - 6:00 pm

  • Wednesday

    9:30 am - 6:00 pm

  • Thursday

    9:30 am - 6:00 pm

  • Friday

    9:30 am - 6:00 pm

  • Saturday

    9:00 am - 5:30 pm

  • Sunday

    Closed

Storage facility cost comparison

5×5

5×10

10×10

10×20

10×30

10×40

Extra Space Storage

Bay Shore, NY

$64

$83

$146

$146

--

--

Neighbor

100+ storage spaces nearby

Prime Storage

Bohemia, NY (10 miles)

$69

$99

$187

$330

$503

$644

Bayport Mini Storage

Bayport, NY (12 miles)

$69

$110

$180

$250

$250

$250

Life Storage

Patchogue, NY (12 miles)

$89

$145

$207

$341

$341

$341

About Extra Space Storage

Amenities & Features

Climate

  • Climate Controlled
  • Interior units
  • Exterior units

Access

  • Allows RV storage
  • Elevator

Security

  • N/A

Available Sizes

  • 5x5
  • 5x8
  • 10x5
  • 10x10
  • 10x20

Facility Overview

Extra Space Storage, located on 5th Avenue in Bay Shore, New York, provides a variety of storage options for customers seeking secure, well-maintained units. Bay Shore is a known community on the south shore of Long Island, offering easy access for residents in nearby areas like Brightwaters, Islip, and West Islip.

The facility features climate-controlled units, an essential feature for preserving sensitive items that could be affected by extreme temperatures. The availability of elevator access ensures ease of moving items to units on higher floors. Interior storage units provide an additional layer of protection from outdoor elements. The multi-door feature ensures several points of entry and exit, increasing convenience for customers. However, potential clients are encouraged to gather more information before deciding on a storage unit.

How Neighbor compares to traditional storage facilities

Neighbor is an online marketplace that connects those who have extra space with those in need of storage.
Learn more about why people loving storing with their Neighbors.

badge w/star

Neighbor

Traditional facilities

Wide variety of sizes

Lowest prices

Highest safety rating

Protection plans

Nationwide availability

Verified hosts

Manage rental online

Units available at nearby locations

10'×20' and up

starting at $157

See available units

10'×10' and up

starting at $43

See available units

5'×5' and up

starting at $35

See available units

Recommended storage units near Bay Shore

19 x 19 Garage in Islip, New York

19×19 Garage

Islip, New York

3.6 miles

Mike's profile

Mike T.

Verified Host

20 x 10 Garage in St James, New York

20×10 Garage

5.0

St James, New York

9.4 miles

David's profile

David Q.

Verified Host

16 x 10 Garage in North Babylon, New York

16×10 Garage

North Babylon, New York

4.8 miles

Geraldine's profile

Geraldine S.

Verified Host

20 x 7 Attic in Lindenhurst, New York

20×7 Attic

Lindenhurst, New York

8.8 miles

Jorge's profile

Jorge R.

Verified Host

7 x 3 Basement in Massapequa, New York

7×3 Basement

Massapequa, New York

11.1 miles

Michael's profile

Michael S.

Verified Host

30 x 10 Garage in Deer Park, New York

30×10 Garage

Deer Park, New York

4.5 miles

Steven's profile

Steven P.

Verified Host

9 x 5 Basement in Massapequa, New York

9×5 Basement

Massapequa, New York

11.1 miles

Michael's profile

Michael S.

Verified Host

11 x 5 Basement in Massapequa, New York

11×5 Basement

Massapequa, New York

11 miles

Michael's profile

Michael S.

Verified Host

10 x 10 Basement in Massapequa, New York

10×10 Basement

Massapequa, New York

11 miles

Michael's profile

Michael S.

Verified Host

10 x 10 Basement in Massapequa, New York

10×10 Basement

Massapequa, New York

11.1 miles

Michael's profile

Michael S.

Verified Host

12 x 10 Basement in Massapequa, New York

12×10 Basement

Massapequa, New York

11.1 miles

Michael's profile

Michael S.

Verified Host

9 x 9 Bedroom in Bayport, New York

9×9 Bedroom

Bayport, New York

10.9 miles

Christopher's profile

Christopher M.

Verified Host

19 x 13 Basement in Commack, New York

19×13 Basement

Commack, New York

5.8 miles

Joanne's profile

Joanne H.

Verified Host

11 x 11 Bedroom in Bayport, New York

11×11 Bedroom

Bayport, New York

10.9 miles

Christopher's profile

Christopher M.

Verified Host

12 x 10 Shed in Patchogue, New York

12×10 Shed

Patchogue, New York

12 miles

Jon's profile

Jon P.

Verified Host

20 x 20 Basement in Lindenhurst, New York

20×20 Basement

Lindenhurst, New York

8.1 miles

Kayihan's profile

Kayihan K.

Verified Host

10 x 10 Warehouse in Ronkonkoma, New York

10×10 Warehouse

Ronkonkoma, New York

6.8 miles

Yusen's profile

Yusen L.

Verified Host

10 x 10 Closet in Hicksville, New York

10×10 Closet

Hicksville, New York

13.9 miles

Ahaz's profile

Ahaz Q.

Verified Host

3 x 2 Closet in New York, New York

3×2 Closet

New York, New York

37.6 miles

Kyoko's profile

Kyoko C.

Verified Host

12 x 8 Shed in Coram, New York

12×8 Shed

Coram, New York

15.1 miles

Georgia's profile

Georgia L.

Verified Host

42 x 15 Basement in Massapequa, New York

42×15 Basement

Massapequa, New York

11.1 miles

Michael's profile

Michael S.

Verified Host

20 x 10 Garage in East Patchogue, New York

20×10 Garage

5.0

East Patchogue, New York

14 miles

Tyshaun's profile

Tyshaun P.

Verified Host

40 x 8 Shipping Container in Centereach, New York

40×8 Shipping Container

Centereach, New York

8.8 miles

Steve's profile

Steve S.

Verified Host

20 x 10 Garage in Farmingdale, New York

20×10 Garage

Farmingdale, New York

7.9 miles

Reid's profile

Reid B.

Verified Host

10 x 6 Garage in Massapequa, New York

10×6 Garage

Massapequa, New York

11.4 miles

Donna's profile

Donna G.

Verified Host

Can't find what you are looking for?

Bay Shore, NY has 100+ nearby options.

View nearby spaces

Nearby Facilities

Prime Storage in Bay Shore
StorQuest Self Storage in Deer Park
Extra Space Storage in Brentwood
CubeSmart Self Storage in Deer Park
Life Storage in Deer Park
Manor Park Mini Warehousing in Deer Park
Extra Space Storage in Hauppauge
Simply Self Storage in Hauppauge
CubeSmart Self Storage in North Babylon
Life Storage in Bay Shore
Public Storage in Bay Shore
America Safe & Sound in Hauppauge
Extra Space Storage in North Babylon
CubeSmart Self Storage in Brightwaters
Extra Space Storage in Deer Park
Extra Space Storage at 3016 Express Dr S in Islandia
Public Storage in Commack
Extra Space Storage at 1960 Veterans Memorial Hwy in Islandia
Extra Space Storage in East Northport
Public Storage in West Babylon
Premier Storage Solutions in West Islip
Sunrise Storage in West Babylon
StorQuest Self Storage in West Babylon
Extra Space Storage in Kings Park
Metro Self Storage in Oakdale
U-Haul Storage at Bellemeade Avenue in Smithtown
Prime Storage in Farmingdale
U-Haul Moving & Storage in Smithtown
Public Storage in Melville
Simply Self Storage in Lindenhurst
Life Storage in Lindenhurst
Public Storage in Nesconset
U-Haul Moving & Storage in Huntington Station
St James Self Storage Inc in St James
Public Storage in Northport
Life Storage in Farmingdale
Public Storage in Farmingdale
Extra Space Storage in Bohemia
Extra Space Storage in Huntington Station
Safeguard Self Storage in Plainview
U-Haul Moving & Storage in Holbrook
Public Storage in Ronkonkoma
Prime Storage in Bohemia
Omega Self Storage in Amityville
Life Storage in Amityville
CubeSmart Self Storage in Plainview
Extra Space Storage in Centereach
Extra Space Storage in Plainview
CubeSmart Self Storage in Holbrook
Safeguard Self Storage in Massapequa

Need self storage in Bay Shore?

Search the world’s largest vehicle and self storage marketplace for the cheapest, closest and safest car storage, RV storage, boat storage and trailer storage.

(385) 469-2248

Search storage