(844) 448-0805

Garages for rent in Bay Shore, NY

Vehicle type

34 locations available

20×10 Self Storage Unit in Bay Shore, NY 122 Saxon Ave Bay Shore, New York

Self Storage Unit

20×10

Bay Shore, NY

1.1 mi

122 Saxon Ave Bay Shore, New York

5.0

200+ months rented

"The rental is great."－ Verified review

50% OFF1ST MONTH

starting at

$248

per month

20×10 Garage in East Patchogue, NY near 12 Beatrice Ct

Garage

20×10

East Patchogue, NY

13.3 mi

Near 12 Beatrice Ct

4.7

47 months rented

$110

per month

30×10 Self Storage Unit in West Babylon, NY 821 Sunrise Hwy West Babylon, New York

Self Storage Unit

30×10

West Babylon, NY

5.2 mi

821 Sunrise Hwy West Babylon, New York

5.0

200+ months rented

"Nicole was fantastic with her customer service."－ Verified review

$477

per month

22×10 Carport in Wheatley Heights, NY near 7 Broadley Ct

Carport

22×10

Wheatley Heights, NY

6.4 mi

Near 7 Broadley Ct

3.0

43 months rented

50% OFF1ST MONTH

$125

per month

20×10 Self Storage Unit in Patchogue, NY 601 W Sunrise Highway Patchogue, New York

Self Storage Unit

20×10

Patchogue, NY

11.0 mi

601 W Sunrise Highway Patchogue, New York

5.0

200+ months rented

"She goes above and beyond to be helpful."－ Verified review

starting at

$198

per month

20×10 Self Storage Unit in Nesconset, NY 770 Nesconset Hwy Nesconset, New York

Self Storage Unit

20×10

Nesconset, NY

8.6 mi

770 Nesconset Hwy Nesconset, New York

5.0

200+ months rented

"Anthony was awesome! It was my first time renting a storage unit."－ Verified review

50% OFF1ST MONTH

$326

per month

30×10 Self Storage Unit in Farmingdale, NY 305 Del Dr Farmingdale, New York

Self Storage Unit

30×10

Farmingdale, NY

9.6 mi

305 Del Dr Farmingdale, New York

4.8

200+ months rented

"Got really good help from Meredith."－ Verified review

50% OFF1ST MONTH

$255

per month

30×10 Self Storage Unit in Lake Ronkonkoma, NY 363 Portion Road Lake Ronkonkoma, New York

Self Storage Unit

30×10

Lake Ronkonkoma, NY

9.6 mi

363 Portion Road Lake Ronkonkoma, New York

4.9

200+ months rented

$289

per month

Garage

20×10

Hempstead, NY

19.4 mi

Near 79 Kane Ave

5.0

$209

per month

20×15 Self Storage Unit in Farmingdale, NY 47 Broadhollow Road Farmingdale, New York

Self Storage Unit

20×15

Farmingdale, NY

9.8 mi

47 Broadhollow Road Farmingdale, New York

4.9

200+ months rented

starting at

$428

per month

25×10 Self Storage Unit in Bethpage, NY 4113 Hempstead Turnpike Bethpage, New York

Self Storage Unit

25×10

Bethpage, NY

12.5 mi

4113 Hempstead Turnpike Bethpage, New York

4.9

200+ months rented

"Dawn was really helpful in a professional way."－ Verified review

starting at

$302

per month

20×10 Self Storage Unit in Mount Sinai, NY 508 Route 25A Mount Sinai, New York

Self Storage Unit

20×10

Mount Sinai, NY

17.6 mi

508 Route 25A Mount Sinai, New York

4.9

200+ months rented

starting at

$259

per month

20×10 Self Storage Unit in Farmingville, NY 951 HorseBlock Road Farmingville, New York

Self Storage Unit

20×10

Farmingville, NY

13.1 mi

951 HorseBlock Road Farmingville, New York

4.9

200+ months rented

2ND MONTHFREE

$322

per month

20×10 Self Storage Unit in Miller Place, NY 922 Route 25A Miller Place, New York

Self Storage Unit

20×10

Miller Place, NY

19.9 mi

922 Route 25A Miller Place, New York

5.0

200+ months rented

starting at

$318

per month

Shipping Container

40×8

Centereach, NY

10.2 mi

Near 216 W Hills Rd

$360

per month

See all 34 storage options in Bay Shore

Neighbor reviews near Bay Shore, NY

5.0 (4,368 reviews)

Based on 4,368 verified reviews, renters rated Neighbor's service for finding garages for rent in Bay Shore 5.0 out of 5 on average

David C.

Stamford, CT

Jan 25, 2024

Verified Review

Now showing 1-1 of 4,368 reviews for Bay Shore, NY

Private residential garages

Garage

20×20

Babylon, NY

5.8 mi

Near 457 Great East Neck Rd

4.5

Locked Area

Private Entrance

Size: 25ft x 25ft – plenty of room!

50% off first month

$1,647

per month

Garage

35×30

Babylon, NY

5.5 mi

Near 175 Lake Dr N

4.5

Locked Area

Private Entrance

50% off first month

$1,647

per month

View all listings

Find nearby storage locations

North Bay Shore, New York (1 mi)

Islip, New York (2 mi)

Baywood, New York (2 mi)

Brentwood, New York (3 mi)

Islip Terrace, New York (3 mi)

East Islip, New York (3 mi)

Central Islip, New York (4 mi)

West Islip, New York (4 mi)

Deer Park, New York (4 mi)

North Babylon, New York (4 mi)

How Neighbor compares to traditional storage facilities

Neighbor

Traditional facilities

Wide variety of sizes

Lowest prices

Highest safety rating

Protection plans

Nationwide availability

Verified hosts

Manage rental online

Storage for Rent in Bay Shore, NY

Select storage type

What type of garage parking is best for you?

Private, residential garages and commercial parking garages both offer unique advantages. Explore which type is best for you below.

Indoor Residential Garages

house with one garage door open and one closed

Residential garages can provide maximum peace of mind at an affordable price.

Interested in increased privacy? 100% of garage listings in Bay Shore are listed as a private space

Find residential garages

Enclosed Parking Garages

side view of parking garage with open windows

Commercial parking garages are available in urban areas for convenient access.

None of the currently available storage spaces in Bay Shore have security cameras as an amenity

Find parking garages

Additional New York garages locations

61 Duffield St., Bridge Plaza

300 E 39th St., New York

Explore recently added cities

Need garages in Bay Shore?

Neighbor is the world’s largest storage marketplace. Call for rates or search online for the cheapest, closest, and safest storage units.

(844) 448-0805