Choose from 102 nearby & affordable parking locations.

Find monthly parking in Bay Shore, NY

Choose from 102 nearby & affordable parking locations.

What Neighbor renters in
Bay Shore say

4.8

11,028 reviews

"I'm very happy with it. Communication was seamless."

N

Natalia

January 2026

"Jason was nice to take care of our car."

N

Nimit Kumar

April 2026

profile

Matt

June 2025

A

Austin

May 2025

102 locations near Bay Shore

View map
11Γ—20 Parking Lot in Bay Shore, NY near 38 S Montgomery Ave
11Γ—20 Parking Lot in Bay Shore, NY near 38 S Montgomery Ave 2
11Γ—20 Parking Lot in Bay Shore, NY near 38 S Montgomery Ave 3

Parking Lot

11Γ—20

Bay Shore, NY

0.4 mi

Near 38 S Montgomery Ave

4.8

23 months rented

starting at

$66

/mo
10Γ—20 Driveway in Islip, NY near 28 Bay 3rd St
10Γ—20 Driveway in Islip, NY near 28 Bay 3rd St 2

Driveway

10Γ—20

Islip, NY

1.9 mi

Near 28 Bay 3rd St

4.7

127 months rented

50% OFF1ST MONTH

$79

$40

/mo

$79

/mo after promo
10Γ—20 Driveway in Islip, NY near 28 Bay 3rd St
10Γ—20 Driveway in Islip, NY near 28 Bay 3rd St 2

Driveway

10Γ—20

Islip, NY

1.9 mi

Near 28 Bay 3rd St

4.7

127 months rented

24 hour access, no appointment required year-round.

50% OFF1ST MONTH

$99

$50

/mo

$99

/mo after promo
10Γ—20 Parking Lot in Bay Shore, NY 1701 Sunrise Hwy Bay Shore, New York
10Γ—20 Parking Lot in Bay Shore, NY 1701 Sunrise Hwy Bay Shore, New York 2
10Γ—20 Parking Lot in Bay Shore, NY 1701 Sunrise Hwy Bay Shore, New York 3

Parking Lot

10Γ—20

Bay Shore, NY

1.1 mi

1701 Sunrise Hwy Bay Shore, New York

4.4

6 months rented

Instant book

starting at

$450

/mo
10Γ—20 Unpaved Lot in Bay Shore, NY near 51 3rd Ave
10Γ—20 Unpaved Lot in Bay Shore, NY near 51 3rd Ave 2
10Γ—20 Unpaved Lot in Bay Shore, NY near 51 3rd Ave 3

Unpaved Lot

10Γ—20

Bay Shore, NY

2.9 mi

Near 51 3rd Ave

4.7

200+ months rented

Great location for your storage needs.

starting at

$116

/mo
10Γ—20 Unpaved Lot in Brentwood, NY near 765 Ferndale Blvd
10Γ—20 Unpaved Lot in Brentwood, NY near 765 Ferndale Blvd 2
10Γ—20 Unpaved Lot in Brentwood, NY near 765 Ferndale Blvd 3

Unpaved Lot

10Γ—20

Brentwood, NY

3.1 mi

Near 765 Ferndale Blvd

4.7

200+ months rented

starting at

$116

/mo

Top Host

10Γ—30 Unpaved Lot in Deer Park, NY near 86 W 1st St
10Γ—30 Unpaved Lot in Deer Park, NY near 86 W 1st St 2
10Γ—30 Unpaved Lot in Deer Park, NY near 86 W 1st St 3

Unpaved Lot

10Γ—30

Deer Park, NY

3.8 mi

Near 86 W 1st St

5.0

20 months rented

$100

/mo
20Γ—10 Parking Lot in Bay Shore, NY 700 Sunrise Hwy Bay Shore, New York
20Γ—10 Parking Lot in Bay Shore, NY 700 Sunrise Hwy Bay Shore, New York 2
20Γ—10 Parking Lot in Bay Shore, NY 700 Sunrise Hwy Bay Shore, New York 3

Parking Lot

20Γ—10

Bay Shore, NY

1.5 mi

700 Sunrise Hwy Bay Shore, New York

4.4

Instant book

starting at

$117

/mo
20Γ—10 Driveway in West Babylon, NY near 73 Otis St
20Γ—10 Driveway in West Babylon, NY near 73 Otis St 2
20Γ—10 Driveway in West Babylon, NY near 73 Otis St 3

Driveway

20Γ—10

West Babylon, NY

5.6 mi

Near 73 Otis St

5.0

6 months rented

Instant book

50% OFF1ST MONTH

starting at

$90

$45

/mo

$90

/mo after promo
10Γ—40 Driveway in Central Islip, NY near 70 Casement Ave
10Γ—40 Driveway in Central Islip, NY near 70 Casement Ave 2
10Γ—40 Driveway in Central Islip, NY near 70 Casement Ave 3

Driveway

10Γ—40

Central Islip, NY

6.3 mi

Near 70 Casement Ave

5.0

107 months rented

50% OFF1ST MONTH

starting at

$100

$50

/mo

$100

/mo after promo
10Γ—20 Parking Lot in Deer Park, NY 152 The Arches Cir Deer Park, New York
10Γ—20 Parking Lot in Deer Park, NY 152 The Arches Cir Deer Park, New York 2
10Γ—20 Parking Lot in Deer Park, NY 152 The Arches Cir Deer Park, New York 3

Parking Lot

10Γ—20

Deer Park, NY

3.8 mi

152 The Arches Cir Deer Park, New York

4.9

200+ months rented

starting at

$160

/mo
10Γ—20 Driveway in Brentwood, NY near 93 Heartland Blvd
10Γ—20 Driveway in Brentwood, NY near 93 Heartland Blvd 2
10Γ—20 Driveway in Brentwood, NY near 93 Heartland Blvd 3

Driveway

10Γ—20

Brentwood, NY

4.1 mi

Near 93 Heartland Blvd

4.7

81 months rented

50% OFF1ST MONTH

starting at

$110

$55

/mo

$110

/mo after promo
8Γ—15 Parking Lot in Coram, NY 544 Middle Country Road Coram, New York
8Γ—15 Parking Lot in Coram, NY 544 Middle Country Road Coram, New York 2
8Γ—15 Parking Lot in Coram, NY 544 Middle Country Road Coram, New York 3

Parking Lot

8Γ—15

Coram, NY

16.1 mi

544 Middle Country Road Coram, New York

5.0

200+ months rented

$1 FIRSTMONTH

starting at

$50

$1

/mo

$50

/mo after promo
20Γ—10 Parking Lot in Deer Park, NY near 86 W 1st St
20Γ—10 Parking Lot in Deer Park, NY near 86 W 1st St 2
20Γ—10 Parking Lot in Deer Park, NY near 86 W 1st St 3

Parking Lot

20Γ—10

Deer Park, NY

3.8 mi

Near 86 W 1st St

4.8

23 months rented

$118

/mo
10Γ—50 Driveway in Islip, NY near 9 Richmond St
10Γ—50 Driveway in Islip, NY near 9 Richmond St 2

Driveway

10Γ—50

Islip, NY

2.0 mi

Near 9 Richmond St

5.0

12 months rented

starting at

$325

/mo

See all 102 parking spaces in Bay Shore

Your questions,
answered

Visit our Help Center
Lots & Parking garages
  • Average monthly price for parking lots is $184.

  • Most parking lots offer security cameras at 100% of locations.

  • Average distance to parking lots is within 1.0 mile from main areas.

Cheap prices: Starting at $50
  • Average monthly parking price in Bay Shore is $148; lowest price starts at $66.

  • 100% of listings offer outdoor space; average price for outdoor parking is $186.

  • 100% of top hosts have quick response times, averaging within 4 minutes.

Vehicle Parking and Storage in Bay Shore, NY

Select storage type

What’s the best monthly parking location for you?

There are a variety of options for monthly parking, including parking lots, garages & private driveways. Explore the pros and cons of each.

Outdoor, Uncovered Parking
two cars parked next to a field

Affordable spaces can be found at parking lots, private driveways & unpaved lots.

Uncovered storage is more expensive than covered storage by 40% on average in Bay Shore

Indoor & Covered Parking
motorhome parked in open garage

This is found in private & commercial parking garages as well as covered carports.

Indoor storage spaces are reserved 133% more than outdoor storage spaces in Bay Shore

Indoor Storage Units
row of green closed garage doors

Shared & private storage includes drive-up storage units, warehouses & large spaces.

Indoor storage in Bay Shore is 36% more expensive than nearby areas

Alternative Monthly Parking Facilities near Bay Shore

Neighbor is the largest storage and parking marketplace in the U.S., making it easy to compare trusted facilities and neighborhood options in Bay Shore. Below are more parking facilities in your area you might like.

STATION YARDS PUBLIC GARAGE (9.7 miles)

6 union Ave Ronkonkoma, NY

Independent Parking (14.4 miles)

95 Jerusalem Avenue Hicksville, NY

Need monthly parking in Bay Shore?

Neighbor is the world’s largest parking marketplace. Call for rates or search online for the cheapest, closest, and safest parking spaces.

(844) 440-0175