Size guide
Choose from 66 secure & affordable boat storage locations.

Find boat storage in Middle Island

Choose from 66 secure & affordable boat storage locations.

What renters in Middle Island say

4.9

(9,750)

Verified reviews

K

Kim H.

August 2025

"Happy to know my son’s car is in a safe residential area."

Verified Review

C

Carol H.

June 2025

"Host was pleasant and accommodating to my needs."

Verified Review

C

Carlos G.

May 2024

"Good safe space. Easy communication, always pleasant."

Verified Review

J

Jason D.

December 2023

"awesome guy very receptive."

Verified Review

J

Jason L.

October 2023

"All good. Definitely recommend!"

Verified Review

C

Christopher R.

December 2023

"thank you!"

Verified Review

The Neighbor rating for boat storage hosts in Middle Island is a rating based on verified reviews from our comunity of renters who have booked with these hosts to meet their storage needs. Last updated August 2025

66 locations near Middle Island

9×20 Unpaved Lot in Medford, NY near 43 David Overton Rd
9×20 Unpaved Lot in Medford, NY near 43 David Overton Rd 2
9×20 Unpaved Lot in Medford, NY near 43 David Overton Rd 3

Unpaved Lot

9×20

Medford, NY

0.9 mi

Near 43 David Overton Rd

4.4

22 months rented

50% OFF1ST MONTH

starting at

$70

$35

/mo

$70

/mo after promo
10×20 Driveway in Coram, NY near 179 Kettles Ln
10×20 Driveway in Coram, NY near 179 Kettles Ln 2
10×20 Driveway in Coram, NY near 179 Kettles Ln 3

Driveway

10×20

Coram, NY

1.1 mi

Near 179 Kettles Ln

5.0

44 months rented

$87

/mo
10×20 Unpaved Lot in Middle Island, NY near Middle Country Rd
10×20 Unpaved Lot in Middle Island, NY near Middle Country Rd 2
10×20 Unpaved Lot in Middle Island, NY near Middle Country Rd 3

Unpaved Lot

10×20

Middle Island, NY

0.5 mi

Near Middle Country Rd

5.0

47 months rented

50% OFF1ST MONTH

$110

$55

/mo

$110

/mo after promo

Top Host

10×20 Driveway in Yaphank, NY near 239 Mill Rd
10×20 Driveway in Yaphank, NY near 239 Mill Rd 2
10×20 Driveway in Yaphank, NY near 239 Mill Rd 3

Driveway

10×20

Yaphank, NY

3.0 mi

Near 239 Mill Rd

5.0

8 months rented

50% OFF1ST MONTH

starting at

$99

$50

/mo

$99

/mo after promo
10×20 Parking Lot in Medford, NY near 43 David Overton Rd
10×20 Parking Lot in Medford, NY near 43 David Overton Rd 2
10×20 Parking Lot in Medford, NY near 43 David Overton Rd 3

Parking Lot

10×20

Medford, NY

1.2 mi

Near 43 David Overton Rd

5.0

49 months rented

$94

/mo
10×20 Unpaved Lot in Selden, NY near 165 Stuyvesant Dr
10×20 Unpaved Lot in Selden, NY near 165 Stuyvesant Dr 2
10×20 Unpaved Lot in Selden, NY near 165 Stuyvesant Dr 3

Unpaved Lot

10×20

Selden, NY

3.7 mi

Near 165 Stuyvesant Dr

5.0

38 months rented

starting at

$100

/mo
10×25 Unpaved Lot in Coram, NY near 36 Grady Ln
10×25 Unpaved Lot in Coram, NY near 36 Grady Ln 2
10×25 Unpaved Lot in Coram, NY near 36 Grady Ln 3

Unpaved Lot

10×25

Coram, NY

0.8 mi

Near 36 Grady Ln

Instant book

starting at

$140

/mo
10×30 Parking Lot in Port Jefferson Station, NY near 25 Davis Ave
10×30 Parking Lot in Port Jefferson Station, NY near 25 Davis Ave 2
10×30 Parking Lot in Port Jefferson Station, NY near 25 Davis Ave 3

Parking Lot

10×30

Port Jefferson Station, NY

5.4 mi

Near 25 Davis Ave

5.0

3 months rented

"Easy smooth move in."－ Verified review

50% OFF1ST MONTH

$84

$42

/mo

$84

/mo after promo
10×30 Driveway in Miller Place, NY near 111 Harbor Beach Rd
10×30 Driveway in Miller Place, NY near 111 Harbor Beach Rd 2

Driveway

10×30

Miller Place, NY

6.2 mi

Near 111 Harbor Beach Rd

5.0

4 months rented

$121

/mo
9×20 Unpaved Lot in Manorville, NY near 210 Weeks Ave
9×20 Unpaved Lot in Manorville, NY near 210 Weeks Ave 2
9×20 Unpaved Lot in Manorville, NY near 210 Weeks Ave 3

Unpaved Lot

9×20

Manorville, NY

6.4 mi

Near 210 Weeks Ave

4.4

13 months rented

"Excellent host. Very accommodating."－ Verified review

starting at

$110

/mo
10×40 Unpaved Lot in Yaphank, NY near 252 River Rd

Unpaved Lot

10×40

Yaphank, NY

5.3 mi

Near 252 River Rd

4.6

200+ months rented

starting at

$150

/mo
10×30 Driveway in Farmingville, NY near 11 Pineoaks Pl
10×30 Driveway in Farmingville, NY near 11 Pineoaks Pl 2
10×30 Driveway in Farmingville, NY near 11 Pineoaks Pl 3

Driveway

10×30

Farmingville, NY

4.3 mi

Near 11 Pineoaks Pl

Just message me through the Neighbor App if you have questions.

50% OFF1ST MONTH

$125

$63

/mo

$125

/mo after promo
10×20 Parking Lot in Calverton, NY Calverton, New York
10×20 Parking Lot in Calverton, NY Calverton, New York 2
10×20 Parking Lot in Calverton, NY Calverton, New York 3

Parking Lot

10×20

Calverton, NY

14.1 mi

Calverton, New York

60 months rented

starting at

$50

/mo
50×30 Unpaved Lot in Yaphank, NY near 262 Garden Ln
50×30 Unpaved Lot in Yaphank, NY near 262 Garden Ln 2

Unpaved Lot

50×30

Yaphank, NY

2.9 mi

Near 262 Garden Ln

5.0

9 months rented

$225

/mo
10×20 Parking Lot in Medford, NY 3220 Horseblock Rd., Medford, NY 11763 Medford, New York
10×20 Parking Lot in Medford, NY 3220 Horseblock Rd., Medford, NY 11763 Medford, New York 2
10×20 Parking Lot in Medford, NY 3220 Horseblock Rd., Medford, NY 11763 Medford, New York 3

Parking Lot

10×20

Medford, NY

3.7 mi

3220 Horseblock Rd., Medford, NY 11763 Medford, New York

4.4

200+ months rented

10% OFFFIRST MONTH

$130

$117

/mo

$130

/mo after promo

See all 66 storage units in Middle Island

Closest storage to my location

  • Average distance to boat storage is 8.9 miles; closest is 0.8 miles away.

  • 58 minutes average host response time for fast assistance and 24/7 access options.

  • 133 locations available for boat storage; great variety near Middle Island.

  • Search your zip code:

    • 11953
10×20 Garage in Coram, NY

Garage

10×20

Coram, NY

2.0 mi

544 Middle Country Road Coram, New York

4.9

On-site Host

Security Camera

starting at

$324

per month

25×114 Unpaved Lot in Coram, NY

Unpaved Lot

25×114

Coram, NY

2.2 mi

Near RT-112

Instant book

Fenced Property

50% off first month

$455

per month

100×200 Unpaved Lot in Medford, NY

Unpaved Lot

100×200

Medford, NY

2.9 mi

Near 900 Blue Ridge Dr

5.0

Fenced Property

Gravel

I have more than a half acre lot for rent.

starting at

$3,195

per month

30×10 Garage in Selden, NY

Garage

30×10

Selden, NY

3.7 mi

Near 165 Stuyvesant Dr

5.0

Instant book

Electricity Available

Security Camera

$700

per month

9×19 Parking Lot in Farmingville, NY

Parking Lot

9×19

Farmingville, NY

3.9 mi

951 HorseBlock Road Farmingville, New York

4.9

Security Camera

Smoke Free

$107

per month

10×20 Garage in Farmingville, NY

Garage

10×20

Farmingville, NY

3.9 mi

951 HorseBlock Road Farmingville, New York

4.9

Security Camera

Lockable Space

$216

per month

10×30 Driveway in Farmingville, NY

Driveway

10×30

Farmingville, NY

4.3 mi

Near 11 Pineoaks Pl

50% off first month

$125

per month

10×20 Parking Lot in Port Jefferson, NY

Parking Lot

10×20

Port Jefferson, NY

4.4 mi

1184 Route 112, Port Jefferson, NY 11776 Port Jefferson, New York

4.4

starting at

$105

per month

10×20 Garage in Port Jefferson, NY

Garage

10×20

Port Jefferson, NY

4.4 mi

1184 Route 112, Port Jefferson, NY 11776 Port Jefferson, New York

4.4

starting at

$341

per month

10×20 Garage in Mount Sinai, NY

Garage

10×20

Mount Sinai, NY

4.6 mi

508 Route 25A Mount Sinai, New York

4.9

Security Camera

Lockable Space

starting at

$267

per month

10×25 Garage in Miller Place, NY

Garage

10×25

Miller Place, NY

4.7 mi

922 Route 25A Miller Place, New York

4.9

On-site Host

Security Camera

$282

per month

View all listings
Cheapest units: Starting at $70

  • Average price for lowest boat storage is $189 per month.

  • 33% of locations have first month discounts available.

  • Outdoor storage options average 40 feet in length.

10×20 Parking Lot in Port Jefferson, NY

Parking Lot

10×20

Port Jefferson, NY

4.4 mi

1184 Route 112, Port Jefferson, NY 11776 Port Jefferson, New York

4.4

starting at

$105

per month

9×19 Parking Lot in Farmingville, NY

Parking Lot

9×19

Farmingville, NY

3.9 mi

951 HorseBlock Road Farmingville, New York

4.9

Security Camera

Smoke Free

$107

per month

11×30 Parking Lot in Port Jefferson, NY

Parking Lot

11×30

Port Jefferson, NY

6.4 mi

225 Sheep Pasture Rd Port Jefferson, New York

4.9

Security Camera

Lockable Space

$154

per month

10×30 Unpaved Lot in Medford, NY

Unpaved Lot

10×30

Medford, NY

5.1 mi

Near 1900 Medford Ave

5.0

Instant book

Security Camera

starting at

$180

per month

10×40 Driveway in Medford, NY

Driveway

10×40

Medford, NY

5.2 mi

Near 266 Southaven Ave

Fenced Property

$200

per month

10×20 Garage in Farmingville, NY

Garage

10×20

Farmingville, NY

3.9 mi

951 HorseBlock Road Farmingville, New York

4.9

Security Camera

Lockable Space

$216

per month

50×30 Unpaved Lot in Yaphank, NY

Unpaved Lot

50×30

Yaphank, NY

2.9 mi

Near 262 Garden Ln

5.0

Security Camera

Private Space

$225

per month

View all listings
Indoor or covered boat storage

  • Average price for indoor covered storage is $471 with 100% business hours access.

  • 77% of locations have no outdoor exposure for better protection.

  • 2 locations are rated, indicating trusted and reliable storage options.

10×25 Garage in Miller Place, NY

Garage

10×25

Miller Place, NY

4.7 mi

922 Route 25A Miller Place, New York

4.9

On-site Host

Security Camera

$282

per month

15×20 Garage in Centereach, NY

Garage

15×20

Centereach, NY

5.2 mi

Near 6 Kara Ct

Security Camera

Electricity Available

50% off first month

$410

per month

10×20 Garage in Farmingville, NY

Garage

10×20

Farmingville, NY

3.9 mi

951 HorseBlock Road Farmingville, New York

4.9

Security Camera

Lockable Space

$216

per month

10×20 Garage in Port Jefferson, NY

Garage

10×20

Port Jefferson, NY

4.4 mi

1184 Route 112, Port Jefferson, NY 11776 Port Jefferson, New York

4.4

starting at

$341

per month

10×20 Garage in Centereach, NY

Garage

10×20

Centereach, NY

5.0 mi

21 Hammond Rd., Centereach, NY 11720 Centereach, New York

4.4

starting at

$279

per month

10×20 Garage in Mount Sinai, NY

Garage

10×20

Mount Sinai, NY

4.6 mi

508 Route 25A Mount Sinai, New York

4.9

Security Camera

Lockable Space

starting at

$267

per month

10×20 Garage in Port Jefferson, NY

Garage

10×20

Port Jefferson, NY

6.4 mi

225 Sheep Pasture Rd Port Jefferson, New York

4.9

Security Camera

Lockable Space

starting at

$362

per month

View all listings
Top-rated: 4+ star reviews
    10×20 Garage in Mount Sinai, NY

    Garage

    10×20

    Mount Sinai, NY

    4.6 mi

    508 Route 25A Mount Sinai, New York

    4.9

    Security Camera

    Lockable Space

    starting at

    $267

    per month

    View all listings
    Oversized
      10×40 Driveway in Medford, NY

      Driveway

      10×40

      Medford, NY

      5.2 mi

      Near 266 Southaven Ave

      Fenced Property

      $200

      per month

      View all listings

      Find nearby storage locations

      Vehicle Parking and Storage in Middle Island, NY

      Select storage type

      boat storage
      car storage
      garages
      long term parking
      monthly parking
      RV storage
      self storage
      truck parking

      What type of boat storage is best for you?

      When storing your boat, you can choose between outdoor dry storage, indoor dry storage, or wet storage. Each type offer unique pros and cons.

      Outdoor Dry Boat Storage
      boat on trailer in covered outdoor storage

      Dry stack or outdoor storage is the most popular and affordable boat storage option

      In Middle Island, you will save 41% by choosing outdoor boat storage instead of indoor boat storage

      Find outdoor storage
      Indoor Dry Boat Storage
      blue boat parked on trailer indors

      Indoor storage ensures maximum protection but at a more expensive price.

      30% of available boat listings in Middle Island are listed as indoor listings

      Find indoor storage
      Outdoor Wet Boat Storage
      boat in marina with other boats surrounding

      Storing your boat at a marina slip or dock is convenient in areas without harsh winters

      No need to use a boat trailer

      Immediate access to the water

      Limited protection from the elements

      Not currently available

      Additional New York boat storage locations

      8971 County Road 7, Avoca
      6749 Maple Ave, Sodus
      300 Wheeler Rd, Hauppauge
      9 Clinton Street, New York Mills
      2 Westchester Park Dr, White Plains

      Need boat storage in Middle Island?

      Neighbor is the world’s largest parking marketplace. Call for rates or search online for the cheapest, closest, and safest parking spaces.

      (844) 449-1088