Choose from 73 nearby & affordable parking locations.

Find monthly parking in Middle Island

Choose from 73 nearby & affordable parking locations.

The choice for Middle Island renters

Our customers rely on Neighbor for safe, simple, and affordable storage. Join the community and see why renters trust us with monthly-parking in Middle Island.

4.8

Average Rating

8306

Verified Reviews

73 locations near Middle Island

7×20 Parking Lot in Miller Place, NY 922 Route 25A Miller Place, New York
7×20 Parking Lot in Miller Place, NY 922 Route 25A Miller Place, New York 2
7×20 Parking Lot in Miller Place, NY 922 Route 25A Miller Place, New York 3

Parking Lot

7×20

Miller Place, NY

3.4 mi

922 Route 25A Miller Place, New York

5.0

200+ months rented

$97

/mo
10×30 Driveway in Miller Place, NY near 111 Harbor Beach Rd
10×30 Driveway in Miller Place, NY near 111 Harbor Beach Rd 2

Driveway

10×30

Miller Place, NY

3.4 mi

Near 111 Harbor Beach Rd

5.0

6 months rented

$121

/mo
8×15 Parking Lot in Coram, NY 544 Middle Country Road Coram, New York
8×15 Parking Lot in Coram, NY 544 Middle Country Road Coram, New York 2
8×15 Parking Lot in Coram, NY 544 Middle Country Road Coram, New York 3

Parking Lot

8×15

Coram, NY

3.0 mi

544 Middle Country Road Coram, New York

5.0

200+ months rented

$1 FIRSTMONTH

$78

$1

/mo

$78

/mo after promo
10×20 Parking Lot in Port Jefferson, NY 1184 Route 112 Port Jefferson, NY
10×20 Parking Lot in Port Jefferson, NY 1184 Route 112 Port Jefferson, NY 2
10×20 Parking Lot in Port Jefferson, NY 1184 Route 112 Port Jefferson, NY 3

Parking Lot

10×20

Port Jefferson, NY

1.1 mi

1184 Route 112 Port Jefferson, NY

4.6

200+ months rented

1ST MONTHFREE

$107

$0

/mo

$107

/mo after promo
10×20 Unpaved Lot in Middle Island, NY near Middle Country Rd
10×20 Unpaved Lot in Middle Island, NY near Middle Country Rd 2
10×20 Unpaved Lot in Middle Island, NY near Middle Country Rd 3

Unpaved Lot

10×20

Middle Island, NY

3.0 mi

Near Middle Country Rd

5.0

48 months rented

50% OFF1ST MONTH

$110

$55

/mo

$110

/mo after promo
20×10 Driveway in Smithtown, NY near 18 Neil Dr
20×10 Driveway in Smithtown, NY near 18 Neil Dr 2
20×10 Driveway in Smithtown, NY near 18 Neil Dr 3

Driveway

20×10

Smithtown, NY

10.4 mi

Near 18 Neil Dr

$80

/mo
10×20 Unpaved Lot in Selden, NY near 16 Court St
10×20 Unpaved Lot in Selden, NY near 16 Court St 2
10×20 Unpaved Lot in Selden, NY near 16 Court St 3

Unpaved Lot

10×20

Selden, NY

2.8 mi

Near 16 Court St

2.1

4 months rented

Instant book

Thank you, and we look forward to hosting you!

$60

/mo
10×20 Unpaved Lot in Selden, NY near 165 Stuyvesant Dr
10×20 Unpaved Lot in Selden, NY near 165 Stuyvesant Dr 2
10×20 Unpaved Lot in Selden, NY near 165 Stuyvesant Dr 3

Unpaved Lot

10×20

Selden, NY

2.3 mi

Near 165 Stuyvesant Dr

5.0

41 months rented

starting at

$100

/mo
10×20 Driveway in Coram, NY near 179 Kettles Ln
10×20 Driveway in Coram, NY near 179 Kettles Ln 2
10×20 Driveway in Coram, NY near 179 Kettles Ln 3

Driveway

10×20

Coram, NY

4.0 mi

Near 179 Kettles Ln

5.0

46 months rented

$104

/mo
10×20 Unpaved Lot in Medford, NY near 9 Ashton Rd
10×20 Unpaved Lot in Medford, NY near 9 Ashton Rd 2
10×20 Unpaved Lot in Medford, NY near 9 Ashton Rd 3

Unpaved Lot

10×20

Medford, NY

4.6 mi

Near 9 Ashton Rd

50% OFF1ST MONTH

$99

$50

/mo

$99

/mo after promo
9×20 Unpaved Lot in Medford, NY near 43 David Overton Rd
9×20 Unpaved Lot in Medford, NY near 43 David Overton Rd 2
9×20 Unpaved Lot in Medford, NY near 43 David Overton Rd 3

Unpaved Lot

9×20

Medford, NY

4.0 mi

Near 43 David Overton Rd

4.5

32 months rented

We’re a hardworking, down-to-earth family that believes in helping others.

50% OFF1ST MONTH

starting at

$70

$35

/mo

$70

/mo after promo
10×20 Unpaved Lot in Shirley, NY near 252 River Rd
10×20 Unpaved Lot in Shirley, NY near 252 River Rd 2
10×20 Unpaved Lot in Shirley, NY near 252 River Rd 3

Unpaved Lot

10×20

Shirley, NY

9.1 mi

Near 252 River Rd

Instant book

50% OFF1ST MONTH

starting at

$76

$38

/mo

$76

/mo after promo
20×18 Garage in Setauket- East Setauket, NY near 46 Bennetts Rd
20×18 Garage in Setauket- East Setauket, NY near 46 Bennetts Rd 2
20×18 Garage in Setauket- East Setauket, NY near 46 Bennetts Rd 3

Garage

20×18

Setauket- East Setauket, NY

4.7 mi

Near 46 Bennetts Rd

$650

/mo
10×20 Driveway in Farmingville, NY near 11 Pineoaks Pl
10×20 Driveway in Farmingville, NY near 11 Pineoaks Pl 2
10×20 Driveway in Farmingville, NY near 11 Pineoaks Pl 3

Driveway

10×20

Farmingville, NY

5.4 mi

Near 11 Pineoaks Pl

50% OFF1ST MONTH

starting at

$92

$46

/mo

$92

/mo after promo
20×10 Parking Lot in Centereach, NY 1929 Middle Country Rd Centereach, New York
20×10 Parking Lot in Centereach, NY 1929 Middle Country Rd Centereach, New York 2
20×10 Parking Lot in Centereach, NY 1929 Middle Country Rd Centereach, New York 3

Parking Lot

20×10

Centereach, NY

4.8 mi

1929 Middle Country Rd Centereach, New York

Instant book

$95

/mo

See all 73 parking spaces in Middle Island

Your questions,
answered

Neighbor is the nation’s largest storage and parking marketplace and a hub for the best monthly parking deals Middle Island has to offer. Compare traditional self-storage units, driveways, garages, climate-controlled spaces, and more near you, all in one place! With thousands of locations at your fingertips (and 73 monthly parking locations in Middle Island alone), you can find the best deal in your neighborhood in one simple search. Rent flexible, monthly parking, car storage, RV storage, and self-storage spaces from top-rated facilities and identity-verified hosts–no long-term contracts necessary. Find the extra space you need, where you need it. Cancel anytime. Book monthly parking online in minutes. Save big.

Yes! Neighbor lists top-rated storage facilities, #1 parking operators, and vetted local hosts with a total of over 600,000 customer reviews. Every Neighbor host is ID-verified and backed by up to $1M in liability coverage. For extra protection, renters can also opt into a Property Protection Plan at checkout. While renters aren’t required to obtain an insurance policy before booking, we highly recommend adding on a Property Protection Plan for added peace of mind. We also encourage renters to use their best judgment when booking and visiting a space. Read reviews, check host ratings, and look for spaces that are gated, security camera-monitored, and located in lower-crime Middle Island neighborhoods. In Middle Island, 69 locations are monitored by security cameras. An additional 2 locations are gated.

Monthly rates will depend on the size of the space, the amenities offered (e.g., EV charging, assigned parking, security camera monitoring, on-site staff, gated entry), and the level of coverage: outdoor, covered, or fully enclosed/indoor. Monthly parking near Middle Island starts at $60, with prices averaging around $97. On Neighbor, you never have to worry about expensive long-term contracts or hidden fees. Filter spaces in Middle Island by clicking on the “Price” tab at the top of the page and toggling the bar to your desired price maximum. Currently, 44 locations in Middle Island are eligible for a discount. Price increases are rare, but you will be given advanced notice if your host decides to increase their monthly rate.

It depends, but rest assured that you’ll always have a spot, regardless of the host you rent from! While most of our hosts will assign a designated parking space to each renter, for in/out parking, select parking operators will have renters park in whichever spot is available on that day/time.

Expect to receive parking instructions via email after your reservation request is submitted and approved.

Most hosts will specify whether EV charging is offered in the “About this space” section of the listing. If EV charging isn't specifically mentioned in the listing description, it’s still possible this is an on-site amenity. You are more likely to find EV charging in enclosed parking garages and commercial parking.

To confirm that EV charging is offered on-site, it never hurts to check with your host. Just use Neighbor’s in-platform messaging system: Neighbor Messages.

It depends on the space’s height restrictions and the host’s policy on oversized vehicles!

Many commercial parking garages impose restrictions on oversized fleet vehicles. If that is the case, these hosts will specify in the “vehicle restrictions” section of the listing that they don’t allow oversized vehicles, so be sure to review the listing description carefully before submitting a reservation request.

Even if oversized vehicles aren’t specifically prohibited, certain height restrictions may prevent you from parking an oversized vehicle, like a delivery van, in a commercial parking garage or private residential garage. If the garage’s height restrictions aren’t posted in the “About this space” section of the listing, you can contact your host via our in-platform messaging system for more information.

On Neighbor, payment is hassle-free! Just create a Neighbor account and connect your preferred payment method (Visa, Mastercard, American Express, and Discover cards are all accepted). Once you select a space and submit a reservation request, a preauthorization hold will be placed on the funds in your account until the reservation is approved. Once approved, your card will be charged immediately. Thereafter, you’ll be charged on the first day of each successive monthly rental period. Most reservations are renewed on the same day each month (E.g., if a reservation started on the fifth day of the month, you’ll be charged on the fifth day of each successive month). Once you’ve removed your items and cancelled online, automatic payments will stop.

When you find the right space, click "Reserve space" to submit your request. You'll be prompted to enter what you're storing, a preferred start date, and your payment information.

Hosts have 24 hours to respond to your request. If you rent an instant-book space, your reservation will automatically be approved. Otherwise, you’ll be notified via email, SMS, and push notifications (if you have the Neighbor app) when a host responds to your pending request. Currently, 23 locations in Middle Island are instant-book.

Yes! To make sure you get the space you want, we recommend submitting a reservation request ASAP. However, we understand that sometimes you need a few more details before you’re ready to place a reservation. In that case, reach out to your host via Neighbor Messages — a safe, secure platform designed specifically for hosts and renters to communicate.

Once your reservation is approved, you’ll receive all the details needed for a successful move-in via email, including the exact listing address. Note that some commercial locations will automatically display the listing address prior to approval.

From there, all that’s left to do is to schedule a move-in time. You can refer to your host’s move-in calendar (if available) or reach out to the host at your convenience via Neighbor’s in-platform messaging system: Neighbor Messages. Here, you can set a date and time that works for your schedule.

Many Neighbor hosts grant renters 24/7 access–the ultimate convenience for parkers who work early in the morning or late into the night. To view an individual host’s access policy, click on the desired listing and scroll down to the “Access” section.

If you rent a space in a parking garage or parking lot with an access control system, your host will issue you a key code or key fob. That way, you can come and go at your convenience.

Our hosts are known for going above and beyond for their renters. If you need to pick up or drop off your vehicle at a specific time of day (or at the last minute), most hosts will be willing to accommodate these requests.

Visit our Help Center
Top-rated: 4+ star reviews
  • Average rating of locations is 4.8; 43 locations have reviews.

  • Average price is $193; market price for 20x10 size is $109.

  • 35% of locations offer security cameras; 23% have top host status.

Vehicle Parking and Storage in Middle Island, NY

Select storage type

What’s the best monthly parking location for you?

There are a variety of options for monthly parking, including parking lots, garages & private driveways. Explore the pros and cons of each.

Outdoor, Uncovered Parking
two cars parked next to a field

Affordable spaces can be found at parking lots, private driveways & unpaved lots.

Uncovered storage is more expensive than covered storage by 75% on average in Middle Island

Indoor & Covered Parking
motorhome parked in open garage

This is found in private & commercial parking garages as well as covered carports.

Indoor storage spaces are reserved 172% more than outdoor storage spaces in Middle Island

Indoor Storage Units
row of green closed garage doors

Shared & private storage includes drive-up storage units, warehouses & large spaces.

Indoor storage in Middle Island is 58% cheaper than nearby areas

Alternative Monthly Parking Facilities near Middle Island

Neighbor is the largest storage and parking marketplace in the U.S., making it easy to compare trusted facilities and neighborhood options in Middle Island. Below are more parking facilities in your area you might like.

STATION YARDS PUBLIC GARAGE (8.4 miles)

6 union Ave Ronkonkoma, NY

Need monthly parking in Middle Island?

Neighbor is the world’s largest parking marketplace. Call for rates or search online for the cheapest, closest, and safest parking spaces.

(844) 440-0175