Choose from 21 nearby & affordable garages.

Find garage parking in Middle Island, NY

Choose from 21 nearby & affordable garages.

What Neighbor renters in
Middle Island say

4.8

6,128 reviews

"My car was left in the garage for 11 months. When I picked it up, it was in great condition, completely undisturbed."

G

Gregory

August 2024

"It was very hard to get in and out for me because my car is kinda big."

S

Shakima

February 2024

"Amazing people and accommodating."

R

Raphael

December 2025

"Very easy to register, simple entrance & exit at a very good garage."

profile

Carol

March 2026

"Excellent service from Zita and Rafael at the garage. ... I was using for seasonal car storage and will do so again next year."

G

Gary

April 2025

"Great communication."

profile

Anthony

June 2026

"Great space at a reasonable price."

Z

Zachary

March 2025

"Good technology available."

P

Peter

July 2025

"Great service — call ahead every time."

P

Phillip

January 2025

21 locations near Middle Island

View map
10×20 Garage in East Patchogue, NY near 12 Beatrice Ct
10×20 Garage in East Patchogue, NY near 12 Beatrice Ct 2
10×20 Garage in East Patchogue, NY near 12 Beatrice Ct 3

Garage

10×20

East Patchogue, NY

9.8 mi

Near 12 Beatrice Ct

4.8

78 months rented

$110

/mo
10×20 Self Storage Unit in Coram, NY 544 Middle Country Road Coram, New York
10×20 Self Storage Unit in Coram, NY 544 Middle Country Road Coram, New York 2
10×20 Self Storage Unit in Coram, NY 544 Middle Country Road Coram, New York 3

Self Storage Unit

10×20

Coram, NY

3.6 mi

544 Middle Country Road Coram, New York

5.0

200+ months rented

2ND MONTHFREE

starting at

$245

/mo

$245

/mo after promo
10×20 Self Storage Unit in Miller Place, NY 922 Route 25A Miller Place, New York
10×20 Self Storage Unit in Miller Place, NY 922 Route 25A Miller Place, New York 2
10×20 Self Storage Unit in Miller Place, NY 922 Route 25A Miller Place, New York 3

Self Storage Unit

10×20

Miller Place, NY

3.0 mi

922 Route 25A Miller Place, New York

5.0

200+ months rented

50% OFFFIRST MONTH

starting at

$303

$152

/mo

$303

/mo after promo
10×20 Self Storage Unit in Mount Sinai, NY 508 Route 25A Mount Sinai, New York
10×20 Self Storage Unit in Mount Sinai, NY 508 Route 25A Mount Sinai, New York 2
10×20 Self Storage Unit in Mount Sinai, NY 508 Route 25A Mount Sinai, New York 3

Self Storage Unit

10×20

Mount Sinai, NY

3.9 mi

508 Route 25A Mount Sinai, New York

4.9

200+ months rented

starting at

$275

/mo
10×30 Self Storage Unit in Port Jefferson, NY 1184 Route 112 Port Jefferson, New York
10×30 Self Storage Unit in Port Jefferson, NY 1184 Route 112 Port Jefferson, New York 2
10×30 Self Storage Unit in Port Jefferson, NY 1184 Route 112 Port Jefferson, New York 3

Self Storage Unit

10×30

Port Jefferson, NY

4.3 mi

1184 Route 112 Port Jefferson, New York

3.0

200+ months rented

$367

/mo
10×20 Self Storage Unit in Medford, NY 3220 Horse Block Road Medford, New York
10×20 Self Storage Unit in Medford, NY 3220 Horse Block Road Medford, New York 2
10×20 Self Storage Unit in Medford, NY 3220 Horse Block Road Medford, New York 3

Self Storage Unit

10×20

Medford, NY

5.5 mi

3220 Horse Block Road Medford, New York

3.0

200+ months rented

1ST MONTHFREE

starting at

$237

$0

/mo

$237

/mo after promo
10×20 Self Storage Unit in Centereach, NY 21 Hammond Rd Centereach, New York
10×20 Self Storage Unit in Centereach, NY 21 Hammond Rd Centereach, New York 2
10×20 Self Storage Unit in Centereach, NY 21 Hammond Rd Centereach, New York 3

Self Storage Unit

10×20

Centereach, NY

6.5 mi

21 Hammond Rd Centereach, New York

3.0

200+ months rented

1ST MONTHFREE

starting at

$202

$0

/mo

$202

/mo after promo
10×20 Self Storage Unit in Lake Ronkonkoma, NY 363 Portion Road Lake Ronkonkoma, New York
10×20 Self Storage Unit in Lake Ronkonkoma, NY 363 Portion Road Lake Ronkonkoma, New York 2
10×20 Self Storage Unit in Lake Ronkonkoma, NY 363 Portion Road Lake Ronkonkoma, New York 3

Self Storage Unit

10×20

Lake Ronkonkoma, NY

8.9 mi

363 Portion Road Lake Ronkonkoma, New York

4.9

200+ months rented

2ND MONTHFREE

starting at

$247

/mo

$247

/mo after promo
10×20 Self Storage Unit in Centereach, NY 20 S. Coleman Rd. Centereach, New York
10×20 Self Storage Unit in Centereach, NY 20 S. Coleman Rd. Centereach, New York 2
10×20 Self Storage Unit in Centereach, NY 20 S. Coleman Rd. Centereach, New York 3

Self Storage Unit

10×20

Centereach, NY

6.4 mi

20 S. Coleman Rd. Centereach, New York

3.0

200+ months rented

starting at

$216

/mo
10×25 Self Storage Unit in Nesconset, NY 770 Nesconset Hwy Nesconset, New York
10×25 Self Storage Unit in Nesconset, NY 770 Nesconset Hwy Nesconset, New York 2
10×25 Self Storage Unit in Nesconset, NY 770 Nesconset Hwy Nesconset, New York 3

Self Storage Unit

10×25

Nesconset, NY

11.0 mi

770 Nesconset Hwy Nesconset, New York

5.0

200+ months rented

starting at

$277

/mo
10×30 Self Storage Unit in Bellport, NY 73 Horseblock Road Bellport, New York

Self Storage Unit

10×30

Bellport, NY

6.6 mi

73 Horseblock Road Bellport, New York

4.9

200+ months rented

2ND MONTHFREE

starting at

$382

/mo

$382

/mo after promo
10×20 Self Storage Unit in Bohemia, NY 868 Lincoln Ave Bohemia, New York
10×20 Self Storage Unit in Bohemia, NY 868 Lincoln Ave Bohemia, New York 2
10×20 Self Storage Unit in Bohemia, NY 868 Lincoln Ave Bohemia, New York 3

Self Storage Unit

10×20

Bohemia, NY

11.3 mi

868 Lincoln Ave Bohemia, New York

3.0

200+ months rented

1ST MONTHFREE

starting at

$220

$0

/mo

$220

/mo after promo
10×20 Self Storage Unit in Shirley, NY 235 William Floyd Parkway Shirley, New York
10×20 Self Storage Unit in Shirley, NY 235 William Floyd Parkway Shirley, New York 2
10×20 Self Storage Unit in Shirley, NY 235 William Floyd Parkway Shirley, New York 3

Self Storage Unit

10×20

Shirley, NY

10.9 mi

235 William Floyd Parkway Shirley, New York

3.0

200+ months rented

starting at

$314

/mo
10×20 Garage in East Moriches, NY near 7 Pine St
10×20 Garage in East Moriches, NY near 7 Pine St 2
10×20 Garage in East Moriches, NY near 7 Pine St 3

Garage

10×20

East Moriches, NY

11.7 mi

Near 7 Pine St

50% OFF1ST MONTH

$211

$106

/mo

$211

/mo after promo
10×20 Self Storage Unit in Bayport, NY 709 Church St Bayport, New York

Self Storage Unit

10×20

Bayport, NY

10.6 mi

709 Church St Bayport, New York

4.9

200+ months rented

starting at

$397

/mo

See all 21 storage units in Middle Island

Private residential garages
  • Average price of garages is $351, with a minimum of $201.

  • 100% of garages have security cameras for added safety.

  • Average host response time is under 6 hours for all listings.

Closest spaces to my location
  • Average distance to garages is 9.6 miles, with a minimum of 3 miles.

  • Median price for garages is $329, with 23 ratings across listings.

  • Access features present in 100% of locations, ensuring easy entry.

  • Search your zip code:

Other types of storage in Middle Island, NY

Select storage type

What type of garage parking is best for you?

Private, residential garages and commercial parking garages both offer unique advantages. Explore which type is best for you below.

Indoor Residential Garages
house with one garage door open and one closed

Residential garages can provide maximum peace of mind at an affordable price.

Interested in increased privacy? 22% of garage listings in Middle Island are listed as a private space

Enclosed Parking Garages
side view of parking garage with open windows

Commercial parking garages are available in urban areas for convenient access.

20% of storage spaces in Middle Island have security cameras as an amenity provided by the host

Additional New York garages locations

Need garages in Middle Island?

Neighbor is the world’s largest parking marketplace. Call for rates or search online for the cheapest, closest, and safest parking spaces.

(844) 448-0805