4.8
5,977 reviews
18 same-day move-in options across Middle Island
Self Storage Unit
5.0 (64)
~9 min drive (3.0 mi)
922 Route 25A, Miller Place, NY 11764
$297
/mo$1.19/sq ft
Self Storage Unit
10' × 25'
$297
/mo$1.19/sq ft
Self Storage Unit
4.9 (50)
~12 min drive (5.9 mi)
951 HorseBlock Road, Farmingville, NY 11738
$241
/mo$1.21/sq ft
Self Storage Unit
10' × 20'
$241
/mo$1.21/sq ft
Self Storage Unit
4.4
~12 min drive (6.4 mi)
20 S Coleman Road, Centereach, NY 11720
$234
/mo$1.17/sq ft
Self Storage Unit
10' × 20'
$234
/mo$1.17/sq ft
Self Storage Unit
4.4
~12 min drive (6.5 mi)
21 Hammond Rd., Centereach, NY 11720
$233
/mo$1.17/sq ft
Self Storage Unit
10' × 20'
$233
/mo$1.17/sq ft
Self Storage Unit
4.9 (94)
~18 min drive (8.9 mi)
363 Portion Road, Lake Ronkonkoma, NY 11779
$399
/mo$2.00/sq ft
Self Storage Unit
10' × 20'
$399
/mo$2.00/sq ft
Self Storage Unit
4.4
~21 min drive (11.3 mi)
868 Lincoln Ave, Bohemia, NY 11716
$239
/mo$1.20/sq ft
Self Storage Unit
10' × 20'
$239
/mo$1.20/sq ft
Self Storage Unit
4.4
~27 min drive (14.8 mi)
625 Eastview Dr, Central Islip, NY 11722
$281
/mo$1.41/sq ft
Self Storage Unit
10' × 20'
$281
/mo$1.41/sq ft
Garage
~18 min drive (7.9 mi)
Setauket- East Setauket, NY
$650
/mo$1.81/sq ft
Garage
20' × 18'
$650
/mo$1.81/sq ft
Your stuff is protected, and so are you
Protection Plans
Add a Property Protection Plan at checkout to cover your belongings against loss or damage. Choose the reimbursement tier that fits — plans scale up to $25,000 in protection.
Full refunds within 24 hours
After move-in, reservations run month-to-month — end anytime through the Neighbor app or website to stop future charges.
Contact support
Our support team is here to help: [email protected], or (855) 555-0100. Average first response is under 2 hours.
15 min read
Garage parking by size in Middle Island
Driveway-length space for sedans, hatchbacks, or compact EVs.
What Neighbor renters in
Middle Island say
4.8
5,977 reviews
"My car was left in the garage for 11 months. When I picked it up, it was in great condition, completely undisturbed."
G
Gregory
August 2024
"Very safe and convenient. ... Great communication."
Anthony
June 2026
"It was very hard to get in and out for me because my car is kinda big."
S
Shakima
February 2024
"Secured parking available for your peace of mind."
Michael
December 2024
"Amazing people and accommodating."
R
Raphael
December 2025
"Very easy to register, simple entrance & exit at a very good garage."
Carol
March 2026
"Excellent service from Zita and Rafael at the garage. ... I was using for seasonal car storage and will do so again next year."
G
Gary
April 2025
"Great service — call ahead every time."
P
Phillip
January 2025
Browse every storage option
